C.S. Lewis, Phoenix Company, and fighting oppression

Historical Fiction·Aaron Barndell

featuring Paul Foot from the Tavern

41 scenes
‹
Scene16
The Shop’s TributeA village lane beneath hedges
›
The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Morris
Morris
Parsley
Parsley
The Older Boy
The Older Boy
The Shopkeeper
The Shopkeeper

The village shop stands at the bend of the road, its front window bright against the grey afternoon. Two older boys in Malvern blazers block the doorway, and the shopkeeper hovers behind his counter, stiff with unease.

One of the older boys taps the glass with a coin, then holds out his hand. The other watches the street, making sure everyone sees who owns the space.

The Older Boy

The Older Boy

You know the arrangement. Pay up, and there is no trouble.

Parsley slows beside Lewis, his mouth tightening. John and Morris stop in step, all four boys taking in the same ugly lesson at once.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

This is the school in miniature.

The Shopkeeper

The Shopkeeper

I have already paid what I can, sir. The man from the College was here yesterday.

The older boy smiles without warmth and turns his head, just enough to notice Lewis and the others. For a moment, the whole business hangs between them, a test of whether younger boys look away or stand their ground.

✓ Quest Accepted

Get past the older boys at the shop doorway

That boy is liable to receive corporal punishment for his insolence.

“Lewis steps up to the door and asks to be let in.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +0)

Lewis steps in at once, taking the doorway with the calm of a boy who means to be admitted, not challenged. The older boy’s hand lowers a fraction, coin still in it, as he registers the move.

The Older Boy

The Older Boy

You want in? Then wait your turn.

Lewis reaches the threshold and the space inside the shop opens to him, small and warm behind the glass. The shopkeeper looks from him to the older boys, as if afraid of whichever answer comes next.

The Shopkeeper

The Shopkeeper

If the boy stands there, the others will make it trouble.

The lookout shifts aside half a step, forced to make room without quite surrendering the line. John and Morris hold back in the street, watching the opening Lewis has made.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

The door is no longer theirs alone.

A rule of the place seems to settle over the doorway, sudden and official, as the older boy’s show of authority hangs on his opening demand. Lewis is inside the mouth of the shop now, and the question becomes whether the others let him pass fully or try to crowd him back.

“Lewis doesn't give them the option and pushes into the shop. He starts searching for fishing tackle.”

SUCCESS (Fair Agility, rolled +1)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Morris
Morris
The Older Boy
The Older Boy
The Shopkeeper
The Shopkeeper

Lewis slips past the edge of the doorway without waiting for permission, and the older boy’s coin hand hesitates as the body behind it has to make room. The shop breathes him in, smelling of paper, twine, damp wool, and river mud on boots.

He turns at once toward the tackle display, eyes skimming hooks, gut lines, and a brass reel in the window light. The shopkeeper watches him like a man hoping the smallest possible trouble is already done.

The Older Boy

The Older Boy

You heard me. Wait your turn.

But Lewis is already inside the shop’s line of sight, and the older boy’s warning has come too late to keep him at the threshold. John and Morris remain in the street, now only reflections in the glass and a pair of still faces beyond it.

The Shopkeeper

The Shopkeeper

If he is buying, let him buy.

Lewis reaches the counter and the tackle shelf in one smooth motion, close enough now to take stock of the hooks and bobbers laid out under the glass. The tribute at the door loses a little of its certainty when the boy it tried to stop is no longer outside it.

In the window’s faint reflection, a dark pebble sits in Edwin’s hand back on the street, while the older boy stands checked at the entrance and the shopkeeper waits for the next move.

✓ Quest Accepted

Secure fishing tackle

Quest Complete

Get past the older boys at the shop doorway

New Gift: Calculated Deception

“Lewis points to the supplies he needs, hooks, lures, reels, etc. Enough for 5 people. He asks the merchant to ring him up. Ignoring the older boy.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -1)

Lewis lifts a finger, then another, laying out the order on the glass with quiet precision. The older boy sees the gesture and gets nothing from it but a steady back and a boy who refuses to look his way.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Those hooks, the lures, and two reels. Enough for five.

The shopkeeper’s face loosens at once. He reaches for the ledger and the scale, as if speed itself might keep the doorway from hardening again.

The Shopkeeper

The Shopkeeper

Very well. I will ring it up.

Behind the glass, Lewis’s chosen gear is drawn together into a single purchase, no longer scattered odds and ends but supplies with a purpose. The older boy stays at the entrance, now looking like a man who has been made to wait.

The Older Boy

The Older Boy

He is buying as if I am not here.

John and Morris hold their ground outside, watching the shopkeeper’s hands move to the till. Edwin’s dark pebble glints for a moment near the street glass, small and stubborn in the light.

Quest Complete

Secure fishing tackle

“Lewis pays for his purchases and moves to leave. Casually, as if discussing the weather, Lewis mentions that this isn't Malvern, and constables are on the prowl. He didn't know why they would bully the old merchant anyway. If he ever leaves town they would lose access to his goods and be shit out of luck on Saturdays. It's poor strategy.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +1)

The Shop’s Tribute
Lewis
Lewis
The Older Boy
The Older Boy
The Shopkeeper
The Shopkeeper

Lewis hands over the coins and takes the little parcel from the counter. The shopkeeper wraps the tackle fast, as if speed can keep the room civil.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

This is not Malvern. Constables are about, and it is poor strategy to bully the man who sells your Saturdays.

The Older Boy

The Older Boy

He says it like a lesson, and everyone here can hear it.

The older boy’s mouth tightens. He shifts one step back from the threshold, and the doorway stops belonging to him.

The Shopkeeper

The Shopkeeper

Quite so. I serve my customers, and I have my own roof to mind.

Lewis turns for the street with his purchase in hand. Outside, John and Morris make room, while Edwin’s dark pebble flashes once near the glass like a small, watchful eye.

+ New Item Acquired

Fishing tackle parcel

“Lewis looks back impassively to see of the older boy leaves the man alone.”

The Shop’s Tribute
Lewis
Lewis
The Older Boy
The Older Boy
The Shopkeeper
The Shopkeeper

Lewis pauses in the street and looks back. The older boy, balked by the shopkeeper’s plain answer, lets the doorway go and drifts off along the pavement, empty-handed and mute.

“Lewis thanks the shopkeeper for his time and apologizes for the trouble.”

SUCCESS (Superb Etiquette, rolled +1)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Thank you. Sorry for the trouble.

The Shopkeeper

The Shopkeeper

No trouble from you, sir. Only from the sort that likes to stand in doorways and call it business.

He gives a short, tired laugh and sets the ledger flat, the tension in his shoulders easing at last.

The Shopkeeper

The Shopkeeper

You have saved me a miserable evening, truth be told.

Outside, the pavement is suddenly ordinary again, with the older boy gone and the glass no longer serving as a stage for him.

The Shopkeeper

The Shopkeeper

If you and your friends come by again, you may do so without apology.

He reaches for Lewis's parcel with a small, appreciative nod, as if the transaction has become something steadier than a purchase.

“Lewis takes his goods and smiles, saying they will definitely be back.”

Lewis takes the parcel, and the shopkeeper’s hands fall away from the ledger at last. The boy’s smile is brief but real, and the room feels properly his again, if only for a moment.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

We shall.

The Shopkeeper

The Shopkeeper

I should be glad of it.

“Lewis returns to his friends and asks Edwin if he was readying for battle with that pebble. He smiles as he says it.”

The Shop’s Tribute
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis

Lewis steps back out to the pavement, parcel snug under his arm, and finds his friends waiting in a loose knot by the shopfront. Edwin is there too, pebble in hand, looking as if he means to hide it.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Were you arming yourself with that pebble for battle, Edwin?

The question draws a small, easy grin from the group, and the street feels lighter for it.

“Lewis smiles at him and waits for Edwin to answer”

Edwin glances up from the pebble and gives a sheepish little shrug, then the grin spreads to the others. The street goes quiet around the small joke, and their shoulders ease as they wait for his answer.

Edwin

Edwin

Only in case you asked for one.

“Lewis says he noticed right at thebstart and appreciated it. He's glad they have each other's backs.”

SUCCESS (Superb Etiquette, rolled +1)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I noticed it at once, and I appreciated it. We do have each other’s backs.

Edwin

Edwin

His mouth quirks, and he lowers the pebble a little. I am glad, because I was trying.

John

John

John gives a brief nod toward Edwin, then Lewis. That is the only sensible way to do it.

Morris

Morris

Morris lets out a small breath and looks from one face to the next. Better than standing about alone, anyway.

The shop window holds their reflections in a thin strip of glass, parcel tucked under Lewis’s arm, the pavement suddenly feeling less like a test and more like a place they have claimed together.

Edwin

Edwin

He glances down at the pebble, then back up with a shy, steady look. Shall I keep this on me, then, if we are walking on?

The question hangs in the warm street air, simple and practical, while the others wait for Lewis to decide the next step.

“Lewis nods, he says he wants to make it to the stream in the next hour so they had better pick up the pace.”

SUCCESS (Fair Agility, rolled +2)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis
Morris
Morris
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

We had better pick up the pace if we mean to reach the stream within the hour.

Lewis’s nod sets the others moving at once, and the loose little knot of boys breaks into a brisk walk down the narrow street, parcel steady under his arm.

Edwin

Edwin

He tucks the pebble tighter in his palm, then falls in step with the others, looking relieved to have a direction.

John

John

Then let us not loiter like town boys with nowhere to be.

Morris

Morris

Good. The river will not wait on us.

The shop window slips behind them. Boots begin to tap quicker on the pavement, and the lane ahead opens toward the fields.

By the time they clear the last cottages, the stream lies ahead within easy reach, its bank visible beyond the turn, and the question becomes who leads them down to it.

“Lewis breaks into an eager run. Trying to find them a good spot.”

SUCCESS (Fair Agility, rolled +1)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis
Morris
Morris

Lewis breaks first, boots quickening into a run. The parcel bumps once against his side as he overtakes the others and heads for the bend where the stream comes into view.

John looks up in surprise and lengthens his stride after him, while Morris angles right to keep the whole party together on the narrow lane.

Edwin hurries along with his pebble still clenched tight, trying not to be left behind as the boys spill toward the turn.

At the bend, Lewis finds the first proper spot, a little grassy bank above the water with enough room to sit, watch, and keep the parcel dry.

John

John

That will do nicely. You have chosen better ground than I expected.

Morris

Morris

Yes. Here we can see anyone coming, and the stream gives us room.

Edwin

Edwin

Shall I put the pebble down there, or keep it ready?

The lane falls quiet behind them, but the bank waits for an answer, with the water running on below and the boys pausing at the edge of deciding what to do next.

✓ Quest Accepted

Settle the group at the stream bank

“Lewis pulls Edwin into a brief hug. "You did good Edwin, you don't have to keep asking. Just pocket the pebble and focus on having a good time."”

SUCCESS (Fair Agility, rolled +1)

The Shop’s Tribute
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis
Morris
Morris

Lewis steps in close and gathers Edwin into a brief, brotherly hug, parcel tucked safely against his own side. Edwin stiffens for half a breath, then leans in and lets it happen.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

You did good, Edwin. You do not need to keep asking. Just pocket the pebble and enjoy yourself.

Edwin

Edwin

He is relieved by the certainty in Lewis's voice, and the pebble suddenly feels less like a weapon than a token.

Edwin slips the dark pebble away into his pocket, his shoulders loosening at once. John watches the exchange with a small, approving tilt of the head, while Morris's hard look eases into something warmer.

John

John

That settles it, then. We are not scouting for trouble, we are here together.

Morris

Morris

And the bank is a sound choice. Nobody can crowd us here without being seen.

The boys hold their ground by the water, parcel dry, pockets full, the stream running easy below them. For a moment, the whole party feels arranged rather than merely gathered.

Quest Complete

Settle the group at the stream bank

“Lewis waves Parsley to come sit with him while he shows them how to set up the fishing kit.”

SUCCESS (Fair Agility, rolled +3)

The Shop’s Tribute

Lewis lifts a hand and beckons Parsley over to the bank beside him. The parcel shifts under his arm as he makes room on the grass and starts laying out the tackle with quick, careful fingers.

Parsley

Parsley

All right, then. Show me.

Parsley comes at once and drops down close, knees tucked, eyes fixed on the wrapped gear. Edwin hovers a step nearer too, his dark pebble gone safely into his pocket, while John and Morris angle in to watch.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Here, this reel sits on first. The line goes through like this.

Lewis fits the reel into place and threads the line cleanly, showing each step as if he means to make the whole business plain. Parsley leans in with absorbed seriousness, and Morris gives a brief nod at the neatness of it.

Edwin

Edwin

He makes it look easy.

When Lewis turns the second reel in his hands, the brass catches the light and reveals a tiny maker’s mark inside the casing, the sort of detail a shopkeeper would usually never mention. Parsley spots it too, and grins as if they have been let in on a private joke.

“I help Parsley set up the second reel. Guiding his hands through the motions until he catches on.”

SUCCESS (Fair Agility, rolled -1)

Lewis shifts closer to Parsley and takes his hands in the work, turning the second reel so the maker’s mark faces down and out of sight. He guides Parsley’s fingers to the spindle, then to the line, correcting the angle with a light touch until the boy follows cleanly.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Like this, keep the tension even.

Parsley nods and repeats the motion without hesitation. The line slips through properly, the reel seats with a neat little click, and his grin widens at the feel of it settling true in his hands.

Parsley

Parsley

That is better. I should think I can manage it now.

Lewis lets go once the trick is caught, and Parsley keeps going on his own, fingers steady where they were uncertain a moment before. Edwin leans in, pleased, while John watches the clean finish with a small approving tilt of the head.

Edwin

Edwin

See, he has it.

The reel is now fully set, the tackle no longer a parcel of parts but a working thing in Parsley’s hands. Beyond them, the stream runs under the bank and the open afternoon waits for what they will do next.

“Lewis helps guide Edwin's hands insetting up the next one. Not looking to leave anyone out.”

SUCCESS (Fair Agility, rolled +1)

Lewis shifts beside Edwin and takes his wrists gently, guiding them toward the reel. The boy’s fingers stop hovering and settle where the line needs them, while Parsley keeps working a step ahead and watches the lesson with open interest.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

There, yes, keep that pressure even.

Edwin follows the correction at once. The line lies straighter under his hands, and the little mechanism answers with a neat, obedient turn.

Edwin

Edwin

Oh, that is it. I thought I should muddle it.

John looks from Parsley to Edwin, then back to Lewis, his mouth easing into a small smile. The parcel paper slumps open at Lewis’s knee as the second setup begins to look less like gear and more like a shared craft.

John

John

You have a gift for making it plain.

Parsley

Parsley

He does. Now Edwin has it too.

Lewis lets Edwin try the motion alone, and the boy keeps it steady. Around them, the stream goes on under the bank, indifferent and bright, while the friends gather closer over the next reel.

“Lewis helps John amd Morris with theirs next, until they are all ready to start casting into the stream.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Reasoning, rolled +1)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis
Morris
Morris

Lewis turns from Edwin’s finished reel and crosses to John and Morris, taking up the spare tackle with brisk hands. The stream keeps flashing below the bank, but the work now gathers around the last two setups.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Let us get yours sorted, then we can all cast together.

John crouches at once, laying his gear in Lewis’s reach. Morris follows, patient and neat, holding still while Lewis checks the line and guides the reel into place.

John

John

He makes even the fiddly part seem ordinary.

Lewis’s fingers move from knot to knot, and John’s rod settles into readiness. Morris tilts his own tackle closer, and Lewis adjusts that as well, straightening the line until it lies clean and taut.

Morris

Morris

There, that is proper now.

Edwin looks on with the pebble now hidden away, grinning as the last loose bit of paper is tucked aside. One by one, the boys rise with their rods in hand, their spacing along the bank opening into a neat line.

By the time Lewis steps back, John and Morris are ready, the tackle is set, and the bank itself has changed state, from a worksite into a launch point. The stream waits in front of them, and the first cast hangs on the edge of happening.

“I cast my line into the stream”

Lewis flicks the line outward, and the float lands cleanly on the stream with a soft tap. John and Morris shift to make room, while Edwin leans in, pleased to see it go right at once.

The bank settles into an easy hush, rods angled over the water, as the first ripples widen and thin.

“I let Edwin take the next cast”

Lewis eases the rod into Edwin’s hands, and the boy takes the line with a careful little grin. The float drifts on, the others make space, and the shared turn at the water feels settled at last.

“Lewis helps show them all how to cast properly. Watching them cast the lines themselves.”

SUCCESS (Fair Agility, rolled +0)

Lewis takes the lead without asking for it, stepping in close enough to show the angle of the wrist and the pause before the cast. The others copy him, and the bank becomes a little school of its own.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

The line runs straighter when the wrist stays loose.

John flicks his rod out and the float lands clean, farther than before. Morris follows with a smaller, steadier cast, and his line settles neatly on the water.

John

John

So that is the trick of it, is it?

Morris

Morris

Aye, much better than flinging it.

Edwin tries again, this time copying the timing instead of the force, and his cast goes out true. The little pebble in his pocket gives a faint hard bump as he shifts his balance.

Edwin

Edwin

I can do that properly now.

For a moment all four lines are out together, each boy managing his own cast, each float making its own patient little path.

Then a rough shout carries up from the lane behind them, and the spell of the bank breaks at once as every head turns toward the sound.

✓ Quest Accepted

Deal with the shout from the lane

“Lewis turns to look at the source of the noise”

Lewis turns toward the lane, and the others follow his look as a figure barrels into view. The shout was for them, and the next moment is already here.

“I face the runner and ask what he wants”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +2)

Lewis squares himself to the lane, rod still down at his side. The runner slows at last, close enough now to be read, and the whole bank holds on that shape.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

What do you want?

Francis

Francis

You lot are wanted. Not for trouble, just, come on. The older boys are at the shop, and they are talking about your gear.

John shifts a half-step nearer to Lewis, eyes fixed on the lane. The stream keeps slipping over stones below them, bright and unconcerned.

Francis

Francis

If they go now, maybe it stays quiet.

The boy jerks a thumb back toward the road, breathless and urgent. Behind him, the lane lies open, but the mention of their tackle makes the invitation feel like a test.

Edwin is just visible beyond John, one hand at his pocket where the pebble rests. The bank, the rods, and the path all seem to wait for Lewis to choose the next move.

“Lewis asks Edwin and Morris to protect Parsley while he and John see what this is about.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -1)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis
Morris
Morris
Runner Boy
Runner Boy
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Edwin, Morris, keep Parsley with you. John and I will see what this is about.

Edwin nods at once and shifts closer to Parsley, his hand leaving his pocket but not the pebble in his head. Morris steps in beside him, squaring his shoulders as a quiet wall between Parsley and the lane.

John answers with a brief look and a small movement of his rod, ready to go. The runner boy watches the exchange, panting, as if the message has finally been taken seriously.

Francis

Francis

Good. Come now, then.

Behind Edwin’s elbow, Parsley is left in safe company while Lewis and John angle toward the road. The stream keeps ticking over stones, indifferent to the new division of the party.

The runner boy jerks his chin toward the lane and backs off a pace, making room for them to pass. What was a summons becomes a route, and the bank is no longer the whole of the matter.

“Lewis looks to Parsley real quick and nods to him. "I'll be back."”

SUCCESS (Fair Agility, rolled -1)

Lewis glances to Parsley and gives a quick nod, the parcel tucked firm under his arm. His mouth opens just enough for the words to land plainly.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I’ll be back.

Parsley

Parsley

He takes it at once, his face easing while he keeps to Edwin and Morris.

Parsley answers with a small, steady look, not reaching out, only holding the promise in place. Edwin and Morris keep their quiet wall around him as the bank gives Lewis and John room to move.

John

John

Then let us make it quick.

Lewis turns with John toward the lane. Behind them, Parsley stays put, guarded and visible, while the stream keeps slipping over the stones below.

“Lewis and John follow the boy to whoever summoned them.”

SUCCESS (Fair Agility, rolled +1)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy

Lewis and John follow the boy along the lane, quick over the ruts and grass. The stream drops behind them, and the village shop recedes to a hard little strip of glass and brick.

The runner cuts between hedge and wall, then veers toward a narrow side yard behind the buildings. Lewis keeps the parcel tucked close, matching John step for step as the path tightens.

Ahead, the boy stops at a back gate and points once toward the yard beyond. A small knot of older boys is visible there, with one broad-shouldered figure turned to listen.

Francis

Francis

There, that is where they are.

Morris is not with them, but from his angle the little yard looks boxed in, and the older boys seem to have found the very place the runner meant. John draws a slower breath beside Lewis, ready but waiting.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

The gate is already half open.

Lewis and John reach the gate and stop at the mouth of the yard, where the older boys can see them if they turn. The runner holds just ahead, no longer guiding, as if the next word must come from inside.

Quest Complete

Deal with the shout from the lane

Attribute Upgrade: Agility Fair→Good

“Calmly, Lewis walks inside.”

SUCCESS (Good Agility, rolled -2)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy

Lewis steps through the gate at once, keeping his parcel hugged tight as the runner slips aside. The yard takes him in, tight and ordinary, with the older boys now inside the same space as his boots.

John follows on his heel, and the half open gate swings farther back behind them. The click of it against the post sounds louder than it should.

Francis

Francis

They are all here.

One broad boy turns his head toward the gate, then another. The little knot in the yard breaks its own stillness and starts to look at Lewis instead of each other.

The Older Boy

The Older Boy

Well then, he has come in.

Lewis keeps moving two paces farther before stopping, and the parcel bumps hard under his arm. A faint scrape of paper on wood gives away how tightly he has been holding it.

The yard falls quiet around him, but not kindly. Someone inside shifts a step to block the back way, and the boys at the far side hold their ground, waiting for what this means now.

“Lewis does a headcount. Assessing their numbers and physical size.”

SUCCESS (Good Perception, rolled +3)

Lewis lets his eyes move once, quick and exact, over the yard. Three older boys stand in the open, two by the wall and one broader figure near the back way. A fourth shape is half-hidden by the shed, making four that he can see, with the gate behind him and John to his right.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Four. One is built to shove, not run.

The broad-shouldered one is the largest by far, thick through the chest and set to cover the yard, while the others are slimmer and a little younger-looking than he is. None of them are as tall as he first seemed from the lane.

That measurement changes the yard at once. It is not a pack waiting to swarm, but a small knot trying to look larger by holding still.

Francis

Francis

He has counted them already. Good.

The runner, still at the threshold, edges his weight back as if the numbers have given him permission to breathe. His hand brushes the gatepost, and he glances from Lewis to the bigger boy, waiting for the first move.

Lewis also sees something useful by the back wall, a stack of cracked crates that could block a rush or a retreat. The yard is still closed, but now it is mapped.

That boy is liable to receive corporal punishment for his insolence.

“Lewis asks quietly what they are interrupting his hike that he put so much effort into planning with College Head Porridge for.”

SUCCESS (Superb Etiquette, rolled -1)

The Shop’s Tribute
Broad-Shouldered Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

What are we interrupting my hike for? I put a good deal of effort into planning it with Porridge.

The question lands cleanly. A couple of the older boys shift their weight, and the broad-shouldered one looks past Lewis at the gate as if weighing whether the answer matters.

Francis

Francis

You are meant to come quiet. They are calling it in, and they want the gear seen.

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Broad-Shouldered Boy

A hike, is it? Then perhaps you should have stayed with your little party and not wandered into our yard.

At the back wall, one of the slimmer boys reaches for the cracked crates and drags them half a foot, making a rough barricade that changes the yard at once. John angles closer to Lewis, and the runner swallows hard, trapped between them and the gate.

“Lewis actually grins. "This isn't a Malvern schoolyard big guy. I don't have to bow my head and take it here. You want to do this you best be prepare to lose an eye. I get to fight out here."”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +1)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

This isn't a Malvern schoolyard, big fellow. I don't have to bow and take it here. If you want this, you best be ready to lose an eye. I get to fight out here.

Lewis's grin lands like a challenge thrown flat across the yard. The broad-shouldered boy stiffens, and the two slimmer ones stop moving their crates. Even the runner goes still, caught between the gate and the wall.

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Broad-Shouldered Boy

You talk brave for a smaller chap. But this is still our place.

John shifts his footing beside Lewis, while the yard seems to tighten around the half-built barricade. The crate stack holds at the back wall, but the back way is no longer open in any easy sense, and the older boys are now watching Lewis as if he has changed the terms.

Francis

Francis

Oh, no.

From above, the yard reads like a trap being measured, with Lewis and John near the gate, the runner boxed in, and the older boys fanned between wall and crates. Edwin's dark pebble is still visible near the lane edge where he clutched it earlier, a small, stubborn witness to the whole affair.

That boy is liable to receive corporal punishment for his insolence.

“Lewis lets the ice of his malice back into his voice. He says with absolute certainty, "No, it's my place now. You just haven't figured that out. But you will. I'm willing to go much farther than you are."”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +1)

Lewis lets the smile vanish from his face, and the yard seems to feel the change before anyone speaks.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

No, it is my place now. You have only not understood that yet. But you will. I am willing to go much farther than you are.

The broad-shouldered boy’s chin lifts a fraction, then stills. One of the slimmer boys glances from Lewis to the crates as if measuring distance instead of loyalty.

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Broad-Shouldered Boy

You are a bold little brute, then.

John edges half a step nearer Lewis, keeping his rod low. The runner boy swallows and presses himself flatter against the gatepost, while Edwin’s dark pebble remains a hard little dot in the lane beyond.

Francis

Francis

He means it.

The older boys do not advance, but the crates and wall no longer look like their whole answer. The yard has changed, Lewis’s claim hanging over it like a fresh order.

“Lewis takes a step forward. He says simply, "I always speak sincerely. I was threatening a black eye. I will take that eye. With my fishing hook specifically."”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +1)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy

Lewis steps forward into the yard’s center, and the little advance shifts the whole balance of it.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I always speak sincerely. I was threatening a black eye. I will take that eye, with my fishing hook specifically.

The broad-shouldered boy stops broadening. The nearer boys draw back from the crates, leaving a thin, clear lane between the gate and the wall.

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Broad-Shouldered Boy

You mean to say that plainly?

John holds his ground beside Lewis, rod low and ready, while the runner boy flattens harder against the gatepost as if the boards might swallow him.

Far beyond the gate, Edwin’s pebble is still a dark dot in the lane, and the yard has gone very still around the hook in Lewis’s words.

Francis

Francis

He does.

That boy is liable to receive corporal punishment for his insolence.

“Lewis draws a fishing hook from the parcel. "I do”

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I do.

Lewis eases the parcel open and lifts out the hook at last. The older boys see the gleam of it, and the yard tightens around the simple, ugly little tool.

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Broad-Shouldered Boy

That will do.

That boy is liable to receive corporal punishment for his insolence.

“Lewis says simply he intends to change things around here. Even if he has to do it by force. He may be small now but he won't always be. And he is already as dark inside as the worst of them. But he would rather it not come to that. It's a waste of both their time and resources.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +2)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

He says he means to change things around here, even if force is what it takes.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

He adds that he may be small now, but he will not always be. He is already as dark inside as the worst of them, though he would rather it not come to that.

The yard goes still. The older boys do not rush him, but their feet shift, and the rough little barricade by the back wall suddenly looks less like confidence and more like a habit under strain.

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Broad-Shouldered Boy

You are a bold little brute.

Lewis keeps the hook raised. John stays close enough to count as a promise, and the runner at the gate is now plainly boxed in by the law of the place, miserable enough to draw notice from the wrong sort of authority.

Then the broad-shouldered boy gives a short, cutting glance toward the gate and the lane beyond, and the whole yard feels as if it has to decide whether this is still a shakedown or a retreat.

That boy is liable to receive corporal punishment for his insolence.

“Lewis says he wouldn't consider himself a brute. Brutes may be big but they are mostly bluster. Om the ither hand, every threat from Lewis is a promise. Malvern will change. And what happens to them will be determined by whether they try to stand in his way.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +0)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I would not call myself a brute. Brutes are mostly bluster. Every threat I make is a promise. Malvern will change, and what happens to you depends on whether you stand in the way.

The broad-shouldered boy stills at that, his chin lifting a fraction as if he has heard something more dangerous than a shout. The rest of the yard checks him, then Lewis, then the gate, and the whole business stops feeling like a game of pressure.

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Change, is it? You talk as if you can order it.

At the gate, the Runner Boy is taken firmly by the arm by one of the older boys from the lane, and his miserable look is answered at once with the kind of attention that promises punishment rather than mercy. John shifts one step nearer Lewis, keeping the center ground with him.

John

John

He has made them listen.

The older boys begin to move, not rushing, but giving ground in a way that opens the yard toward the lane. Their little barricade by the back wall is no longer treated as a barrier, only clutter to be left behind.

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Broad-Shouldered Boy

We shall see whose order matters.

The parcel stays tucked under Lewis's arm, the fishing gear secure, while the yard itself changes shape around his words. For the first time, the older boys are the ones deciding whether to step aside.

That boy is liable to receive corporal punishment for his insolence.

“Lewis tells them to leave the runner with him. As far as Lewis is concerned that is as bad as standing in his way. And no, he doesn't think he can order change. But he does think he can force it.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +2)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
Broad-Shouldered Boy
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Leave the runner with me. If you mean that much to keep him, you are standing in my way.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I do not think I can order change. I do think I can force it.

The boys hesitate. Then the arm on the Runner Boy loosens, and the older one takes a step back as if the yard itself has shifted under him.

John holds his ground at Lewis’s shoulder while the Broad-Shouldered Boy turns his head toward the lane, measuring the cost of refusing.

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Take him, then. If he runs again, it is on him.

The Runner Boy is shoved free and left in Lewis’s reach, no longer claimed by the older boys. Edwin’s pebble glints once near the gatepost in the afternoon light as the yard settles into a new shape.

✓ Quest Accepted

Keep the runner under Lewis’s protection

“Lewis leads the runner boy gently by the arm and turns and walks out the gate with John.”

SUCCESS (Good Agility, rolled +0)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy

Lewis takes the Runner Boy by the arm and turns him toward the gate. John falls in on the other side, close enough to block any second thoughts without touching him.

The older boys do not stop them. Their little court has already broken, and they let the three younger boys pass as if the matter is finished.

The Runner Boy keeps pace beside Lewis, no longer reaching back for the yard. His shoulders ease a fraction as the gate opens onto the lane.

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Broad-Shouldered Boy

Go on, then. Take your man and be gone.

Lewis guides him through the gate. John follows just behind, and the cramped yard falls away behind their backs.

Outside, the afternoon light catches Edwin’s dark pebble by the post, while the Runner Boy looks from it to Lewis as if waiting for what comes next.

Quest Complete

Keep the runner under Lewis’s protection

That boy is liable to receive corporal punishment for his insolence.

“Lewis leads the runner boy back toward the stream. He whispers to him to just stick close and they will make sure he gets back to Malvern safely.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +1)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy

Lewis turns the Runner Boy back the way they came, and the lane gives onto the open path beside the stream. John keeps pace on the other side, making a quiet wedge of the three of them.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Just stick close, and we will see you back to Malvern safely.

The Runner Boy nods once and shortens his step to match Lewis's, no longer glancing toward the yard behind them. The pebble by the gatepost is left to the light as the boys move on.

An older voice from the yard does not follow them. The threat has spent itself, and the way ahead is clear enough to walk.

Francis

Francis

If he says stay close, then I stay close.

Together they head toward the stream, the runner now folded into Lewis's protection instead of the older boys' reach.

That boy is liable to receive corporal punishment for his insolence.

“Lewis asks John to speak up. He wants to know if John approved of his methods or not?”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -1)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

John, tell me straight. Do you think I went too far?

The three keep walking, but Lewis turns his head just enough to make the question private. The runner stays between them, listening without quite looking up.

John

John

No. I think you made them give ground without having to hit first.

John

John

He says it quietly, as if testing the words and finding them sound.

John glances at the parcel under Lewis's arm, then at the runner at their side. His mouth tightens once, in approval rather than doubt.

John

John

If I had one complaint, it is that you made it look easy. That tempts fools to try the same trick.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

He means it.

John

John

Still, yes, I approved. You took the yard from them without handing them a story.

“Lewis relaxes a little at that. He says he would rather intimidate them into backing off for as long as possible. He will fight back if he has too. He will follow through on promises But if they can break their will instead, it is a preferable alternative. But he wants John to know he doesn't plan to change the school that way.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -1)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I would rather make them back off by fear, if it lasts. If I must, I will fight. But I do not mean to change the school by that means.

Lewis lets the words sit between them, his grip easing a little on the parcel. The path stays quiet around their feet, with the stream and the village both left behind.

John

John

That is different from wanting a brawl.

John

John

He studies Lewis a moment, then gives a small nod, as if the distinction matters and he is glad of it.

John

John

Intimidation is a tool. Hitting is another. But neither of them is the same thing as ruling by them.

The runner, a step behind, keeps his eyes lowered. Edwin’s dark pebble shows for an instant near the gatepost in Lewis’s memory, then the path narrows ahead of them under the hedges.

John

John

If you mean to stand with people, that is plain enough.

“Lewis says that he does. And John is right. Intimidation is a particularly good tool here because it is a language the bullies all understand. Because they were all themselves at some point vicitms.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +0)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Yes. John is right. Intimidation works because it is a language they understand, and because they began as victims themselves.

The words settle in the narrow lane like something carefully placed, not flung. The runner keeps pace behind them, listening without interrupting, while the hedges draw close on either side.

John

John

That is the heart of it, then. They learned it from being hunted, and now they pass it on.

John

John

There is no glory in that kind of power, only appetite and fear.

John’s mouth tightens, not in anger now but in recognition. The parcel stays snug beneath Lewis’s arm, and the fishing hook no longer feels like a challenge so much as a plain tool.

John

John

If you can make them feel the line, before they decide to cross it, that may be enough.

Ahead, the lane bends toward the road, and the boys’ shadows shorten under the late light. The runner glances up at Lewis, waiting to hear whether that lesson is meant for him too.

“Lewis says that if possible, John should try not to feel so coldly to them. They are people who are damaged by others who were damaged in a mad cycle. So they have to break it.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +0)

The Shop’s Tribute
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

If you can, try not to feel so coldly toward them. They are people who have been damaged by others who were damaged in a mad cycle, and somebody has to break it.

John

John

John’s face softens as he listens, the hard look draining away into something more thoughtful.

John

John

Yes. That is fair. If we do not break it, we only learn their manners and call it strength.

The lane bends on, but the pace stays easy. John’s shoulders loosen beside Lewis, and the runner behind them keeps close without being told.

John

John

Then we must answer them differently, not with their own coldness.

Francis

Francis

Do you mean we can stop it, if we keep together?

Lewis’s parcel stays tucked tight under his arm as the three boys walk beneath the hedges. Edwin’s dark pebble flashes once near the runner’s hand, then disappears again as he listens for the answer.

“Lewis smiles at the boy and says, "yes, that is exactly what he means."”

SUCCESS (Superb Etiquette, rolled +0)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Runner Boy
Runner Boy
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Lewis smiles at the boy. “Yes, that is exactly what he means.”

Francis

Francis

Then perhaps it can be done. I thought they were simply larger than us.

John

John

Larger is not the same as stronger. They depend on people keeping quiet.

The lane stays easy beneath the hedges, the three boys keeping pace without hurrying. Lewis’s parcel rides steady under his arm, and the runner’s shoulders ease as he looks from one face to the next.

Francis

Francis

My father says the small sort must make themselves useful if they mean to keep their place. Is that what this is?

John

John

No. This is refusing to let bullies decide what place means.

Ahead, the road lightens where the hedges thin. The runner glances down at Edwin’s dark pebble in his hand, then slips it into his pocket as if it were part of the answer.

“Lewis stops and introduces himself, extending a hand and asking the boys name”

SUCCESS (Superb Etiquette, rolled +1)

Lewis slows and comes to a stop beneath the hedges, turning cleanly toward the boy beside him. He offers his hand with the easy courtesy of a schoolroom introduction, parcel still tucked under his other arm.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Lewis says his name, then asks the boy’s name in return.

Francis

Francis

He takes the hand at once, a little surprised but pleased. I'm Runner Boy, sir, only that's what they call me.

John

John

John watches the exchange and sees the runner straighten at it, as if the simple formality has given him room to breathe.

Francis

Francis

Not that anyone uses my proper one much at Malvern.

The lane keeps brightening ahead, but the three boys pause in a small, companionable knot, the runner’s pocketed pebble gone from view and his attention fixed on Lewis.

“Lewis says he would be glad to be the first to use it if the boy will give it. Callig him runner boy js degrading.”

SUCCESS (Superb Etiquette, rolled -1)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Lewis
Lewis
Francis
Francis
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Lewis says he would gladly use the boy's proper name, if the boy will tell it.

Francis

Francis

Then call me Francis, if you please. Nobody bothers with that here.

John

John

The boy stands taller for having said it.

Francis’s grip loosens, but he does not let go at once. The lane seems to open a little around the three of them, the hedges less like walls and more like cover.

Francis

Francis

Francis is a better name than Runner Boy.

John gives a small, approving nod, and the pebble in Francis's pocket bumps faintly against the cloth as he shifts his weight.

“Lewis leads Francis and John back to Morris, Parsley, and Edwin.”

SUCCESS (Good Agility, rolled +2)

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis
Morris
Morris
Francis
Francis
Parsley
Parsley

Lewis turns on his heel and starts them back down the hedge-lined lane, Francis falling in at his side while John keeps pace on the other. The stream side drops away behind them, and the boys move as a small, purposeful knot toward the others waiting below.

The path bends out toward the open bank, and the sound of water reaches them before the figures do. Below the hedges, the rest of the party comes into view, spread where Lewis left them.

Morris stands first in sight, near Parsley and Edwin, with the little guard they made still intact. Edwin’s dark pebble flashes once in his hand as he shifts to look up the lane.

Francis slows at once when he sees the three boys waiting, his shoulders loosening with recognition. John glances from the bank to Lewis, then ahead again, as if counting the whole company and finding it steady.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I have brought Francis back.

Parsley’s attention fixes on the newcomer, while Morris makes room without a word. The little group tightens into one cluster beside the stream, no longer split between bank and lane.

Francis steps in with the others, now plainly part of Lewis’s side of the line. The old distance from the yard is gone, but the wider question of what they do with their afternoon still hangs in the air.

“Lewis asks if they managed to catch any fish while he was gone?”

The Shop’s Tribute
John
John
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis
Morris
Morris
Francis
Francis
Parsley
Parsley
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Have you caught any fish while I was away?

Edwin

Edwin

Not yet, only patience and splashing. The line has been behaving itself, though.

Morris

Morris

We have had time to talk instead. It was no bad thing.

“Lewis takes up his fishing line a recasts it. Encouraging John to do the same. He give the rest of them a brief explanation of what happened with the boys who planned to ambush them.”

SUCCESS (Good Agility, rolled +1)

Lewis lifts his line, flicks it out again, and the float lands cleanly farther from the bank. The little cast resets the water between them, as if the stream itself has accepted the new start.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

John, you should cast again too, if you like. It keeps the line honest.

John reaches for his rod at once, while Lewis keeps his own parcel tucked tight and gives the group a brief, low account of the boys waiting by the yard, the crates, and the way they had meant to corner the runner.

John

John

Then they meant intimidation, not a fair meeting. Good. We saw enough of that.

Morris

Morris

And they found they had misjudged the number of boys against them.

Francis

Francis

He listens hard, standing a little straighter than before.

The explanation settles over the bank without breaking it. Edwin’s pebble stays hidden, the float drifts steady again, and the others make room for John’s cast as the group keeps its quiet order.

“Lewis hands his reel over to Francis and moves to sit between Parsley and Edwin.”

Lewis hands the reel across, then lowers himself onto the grass between Parsley and Edwin. The little circle tightens, comfortable and made more honest by the simple exchange.

Francis

Francis

I will try it properly, then.

Francis turns the reel over in both hands, studying it with the grave care of something newly trusted, while Edwin shifts closer and the pebble in his pocket gives a small, familiar lump to his side.

“Lewis quietly thanks Edwin for staying behind and helping guard Parsley. He was worried about splitting them up. He gives Parsley an easy smile.”

SUCCESS (Superb Etiquette, rolled -3)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Thank you for staying back with Parsley.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I was worried about splitting you two up.

Lewis lets the words land softly, then gives Parsley an easy smile across the grass. Edwin’s pebble shifts with a faint click in his pocket as he straightens, pleased to be counted as useful.

Edwin

Edwin

It was no trouble. I liked being there.

Parsley

Parsley

I am glad you were.

The little circle holds its shape, but the reel in Francis’s hands slips once and taps the rod, a small clumsy sound that earns a quick glance from everyone at once.

Francis

Francis

I must not break it.

“Lewis apologizes to Parsley for splitting the group up. He knew it was a trap. Having Parsley there would have distracted him in a fight because he would be more focused on protecting him.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -1)

The Shop’s Tribute
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis
Francis
Francis
Parsley
Parsley
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I am sorry for splitting us up. I knew it was a trap, and I did not want you dragged into a fight because I was thinking of keeping you safe.

The apology goes out plainly over the grass. Parsley’s face softens at once, and the small circle around the rods settles back into ease as if the words have made room for everybody again.

Parsley

Parsley

You were thinking of me. I am glad of that.

Parsley

Parsley

He does not need to carry me and the fight both.

Francis lowers the reel in both hands, chastened but still listening, while Edwin’s fingers drift to the pebble in his pocket and then away again.

Edwin

Edwin

It seemed sensible to me. I should not have wanted to be in the middle of it either.

Parsley turns a little toward Lewis, the stream quiet behind them, and the three boys closest to him look less like a party on alert and more like companions sharing a secret under the hedges.

Parsley

Parsley

Next time, you may tell me before you decide such things for yourself.

“That draws Lewis up short, and in that moments he realized he screwed up. Woth a properly abashed expression he says, "You're right, I'm sorry. I should have asked you first. I let taking charge get to my head. I don't get to make decisions for you just because we're a couple now."”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +0)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

You are right. I am sorry. I should have asked you first.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I let taking charge get to my head. I do not get to make decisions for you just because we are a couple now.

Parsley

Parsley

Thank you. That is all I wanted.

Parsley

Parsley

I like being with you, but I want to be asked.

The line of Parsley’s shoulders eases, and the little ring of boys around the tackle seems to breathe again. Francis lowers his gaze to the reel and Edwin’s hand slips out of his pocket, the pebble left to rest unseen.

Edwin

Edwin

That sounds fair to me.

The stream keeps whispering under the hedges. Nothing else moves to claim the moment, and the boys simply sit with what has been said.

“Lewis takes Parsley's hand. I promise, next time I won't make a decision without you. And I won't push one you disagree with on you.”

Lewis takes Parsley’s hand, and the little circle settles deeper into the grass. The stream murmurs on while the boys sit close, unhurried and quiet.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I promise, next time I will ask you first, and I will not force what you dislike.

Parsley’s fingers tighten once, then ease, and his shoulders loosen beside Lewis. Edwin glances up with a small approving smile, while Francis keeps his eyes on the reel and listens.

“Lewis relaxes back on the grass beside Parsley, still holding his hand. "I've never been with somebody before. I'm realizing there is a learning curve."”

The Shop’s Tribute
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis
Francis
Francis
C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I've never been with somebody before. I'm realizing there is a learning curve.

He eases back onto the grass, still keeping Parsley's hand, and the little circle breathes with him. Parsley gives a small, knowing look, while the stream goes on murmuring under the hedges.

Parsley

Parsley

There is. But you are learning it properly.

“Lewis relaxes and helps watch the five fishing lines as they wait for a bite.”

Lewis stretches out again and scans the five lines with calm attention, keeping one eye on the floats while the others settle around him. The stream whispers on beneath the hedges, and the little party falls into an easy watchfulness.

Parsley

Parsley

That is the trick, really. Watch, and do not fuss at the water.

“Lewis nods. He says that is half of it. For him, the other half is always good company.”

Lewis gave a small nod. "That is half of it. For me, the other half is good company."

Parsley

Parsley

Parsley smiled at that, glancing from Lewis to the others. "Then we are doing it properly, at least."

“I keep fishing with good company”

SUCCESS (Good Agility, rolled +0)

Lewis lets the line run with an easy hand, keeping his eyes on the float while the water slides dark and patient beneath the hedges. The little circle stays close, shoulders loose now, and the quiet feels chosen rather than imposed.

Parsley

Parsley

That is the best sort of fishing, I think, when nobody is hurrying you.

Edwin shifts nearer on the grass, peering toward the float as if he expects it to reward attention. Francis keeps the reel steady in his lap, careful and pleased to be trusted with it.

Edwin

Edwin

It is nicer when there is time for talking as well.

Lewis’s line twitches once, only a small warning, and the boys all lean in by habit before settling again. The moment passes cleanly, leaving only the ripple and the smell of damp grass.

Francis

Francis

At Malvern, that is worth more than it ought to be.

A little while later, Francis hands the reel back with both care and pride, and the group makes room for Lewis without fuss. Edwin’s dark pebble shows for an instant as his pocket shifts, then disappears again while the boys keep fishing together in the warm, unhurried light.

“Lewis keeps fishing and asks Francis about himself.”

SUCCESS (Superb Etiquette, rolled +2)

Lewis keeps the rod steady and lets the float drift where the current chooses, then turns his head toward Francis as if the question belongs naturally beside the fishing. Francis shifts the reel to his lap and gives him his full attention without losing sight of the water.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

What do you do, then, when you are not being sent about for other people?

Francis

Francis

Mostly I am sent about for other people, if I am honest. But when I can, I like to read and wander. I know the lanes better than most of the boys who boast about knowing everything.

Edwin looks up at that with open interest, and Parsley’s mouth quirks in approval. Francis’s shoulders ease, pleased to be asked something ordinary rather than useful.

Francis

Francis

I have a brother in the village, and a sister who thinks I am entirely too grand for school. She is probably right. I help at the shop sometimes, when they let me breathe.

The line trembles once more, but only from the stream, and Lewis does not need to snatch at it. Francis glances at the water, then back to Lewis, as if deciding the question has earned an answer in kind.

Francis

Francis

You ask as though you mean it, which is rare enough to notice. At Malvern, that makes a difference.

“Lewis smiles and admits that he does mean it. He took Francis under his protection. So he is kind of one of them now. He hopes that's alright?”

SUCCESS (Superb Etiquette, rolled +2)

Lewis’s smile comes easy now, small but certain, and he lets it sit there while the line drifts. The rod stays steady in his hand.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I do mean it. I have taken you under my protection, so you are, in a way, one of us now. I hope that is all right.

Francis

Francis

Francis’s face opens with relief, and he lets out a soft laugh through his nose. All right? That sounds better than most things I have been offered at Malvern.

Edwin brightens at once, glancing from one boy to the other as if a new space has opened in the circle. Parsley’s approval is plain in the tilt of his mouth.

Francis

Francis

I think I can manage being one of yours, if you will have me. It is nicer than being useful at people.

Francis rests the reel more carefully in his lap, no longer guarding it like borrowed property. The stream murmurs on, and the little group stays close, settled and listening.

“Lewis says he doesn't have to wonder if they will have him. They made that choice when they pulled him through the gate earlier. He keeps checking the lines as he speaks.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -1)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

I do not have to wonder whether you will have me. You made that choice when you pulled me through the gate.

Lewis keeps his eyes on the line as he speaks, fingers steady on the rod. The water slides by in pale ribbons beneath the hedges, and Francis looks down with a grin that is half relief, half surprise.

Francis

Francis

Then that settles it, does it not. I would rather be chosen than merely useful.

Edwin lets out a pleased little sound and shifts nearer the others, his attention fixed on Francis. Parsley’s mouth curves again, and the four of them sit as one knot in the grass, the pebble still hidden away somewhere in Edwin’s pocket.

Francis

Francis

It feels strange, being told plainly. At Malvern, one usually waits to be dragged along and called lucky for it.

Francis sets the reel down with care and opens his hands, no longer guarding the tackle as if it might be taken back. Lewis’s line drifts on untouched, but the little circle around him holds fast, quieter and surer than before.

“Lewis agrees. He admits he has been thinking about the way things are wrong at Malvern a lot.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +1)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

Yes. I have been thinking about it for a long time, and it is wrong.

The words come out level, almost matter of fact, as Lewis keeps his rod steady. Francis looks up at once, his open hands still resting on his knees, and Edwin goes very still, as if listening for a rule to break.

Francis

Francis

That is the first sensible thing anyone has said about it all term.

Parsley gives a small, quick laugh through his nose, then settles again, watching Lewis with a look that says this is not quite a surprise. The stream keeps its soft pull beneath the hedges, and the little circle seems to tighten by a breath.

Edwin

Edwin

You mean the older boys, not just Malvern in general?

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

The difference matters to him.

Francis shifts forward a little, interested now, while the dark pebble in Edwin’s pocket catches the light when he moves. The fish line stays level in the water, but the talk has turned the bank into something sturdier than a resting place.

Francis

Francis

If you mean it, say it plain. I should like to hear where you mean to put the blame.

“Lewis says it isn't as simple as just blaming. The older boys are twisted and do terrible things. But Malvern isn't innocent. It let those things happen. It has let them happen for a long, long time.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -3)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

It is not as simple as just blaming. The older boys are twisted, and they do terrible things. But Malvern is not innocent. It lets them happen, and it has let them happen for a long time.

The words land softly, but they change the shape of the bank at once. Francis stares at Lewis, then glances down as if the grass itself has become complicit, while Edwin’s pebble gives a small, dark flash against his pocket seam.

Francis

Francis

That is the part they never say aloud.

Francis

Francis

He means the place, not only the boys.

Parsley shifts onto both elbows, his earlier amusement gone, and watches Lewis with a quieter, sharper attention. The stream keeps moving, but the circle feels less like a rest and more like a witness box.

Edwin

Edwin

Then it is all of them, in a way.

Francis lets out a breath through his nose, half agreement and half alarm, and the line in Lewis’s hands trembles once before settling. The confession has gone over the bank like a stone, and the water below answers with a single dim ripple.

“Lewis says, "yes and no. The whole school isn't bad. But it has to take responsibility for what it has ignored and start doing something about it instead if being complacent. The fact that some boys are forced into being catamites shouldn't ever be ignored."”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +1)

The Shop’s Tribute
Edwin
Edwin
Lewis
Lewis
Francis
Francis
Parsley
Parsley
Francis

Francis

Yes, and no. The whole school is not rotten, but it cannot keep looking away from what it allows.

Francis

Francis

He means the older boys, and the masters, and the silence between them.

Edwin

Edwin

If it knows, and does nothing, then it shares it.

Parsley

Parsley

The line has been crossed, and now they are naming the crossing.

Lewis’s words settle over the grass and do not stay there. Francis goes still, then gives a small nod as if something private has been named in public at last. Edwin’s hand tightens in his pocket around the pebble, and Parsley’s gaze sharpens, less wary now than exacting.

Francis

Francis

Then it is responsible. If boys are made to endure things no one should be made to endure, the school cannot pretend that is only one boy’s wickedness.

The river keeps on under the bank, but the little fishing party has changed shape. The rods stay upright, the line stays slack, and nobody reaches for the tackle. What had been a quiet afternoon now stands still around a truth that can no longer be left unnamed.

“Lewis puts a hand on Francis's shoulder and squeezes it. "People who have had to go through that should be protected. And never shamed. And i want to protect those people however I can."”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -1)

Lewis leans forward and rests a hand on Francis’s shoulder, giving it a firm, steady squeeze. The touch lands like an offer, not a command, and Francis does not flinch.

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

People who have gone through that should be protected, not shamed. I want to protect them however I can.

Francis

Francis

He means it. Not as talk, but as a sort of rule.

Francis’s posture changes at once. He draws a slow breath, then lets his shoulders drop a little under Lewis’s hand, as if the words have weight enough to hold him up.

Parsley

Parsley

Then that is what makes the difference. Not loudness, but who you choose to stand beside.

Edwin

Edwin

And who you refuse to laugh at.

The little circle stays where it is, quiet over the water. Edwin’s pebble is still tucked in his pocket, but his hand has gone loose around it, and Francis looks from one face to another as though he has been newly counted in.

That boy is liable to receive corporal punishment for his insolence.

“Lewis says quietly, "And if you need to get something off your chest, we will always listen."”

SUCCESS (Superb Etiquette, rolled -2)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

And if you need to get something off your chest, we will always listen.

Francis

Francis

I know. That is... a comfort.

Francis

Francis

He has not said it to be polite.

Francis rubs a thumb against the seam of his sleeve, then lets his hand fall open in his lap. The lines in his face ease, but the motion costs him a little steadiness.

Parsley

Parsley

That is a very proper sort of promise.

Edwin

Edwin

Yes, and it means you do not have to keep things all knotted up.

The circle remains quiet over the stream, warm but still. Edwin’s hand comes out of his pocket empty, the dark pebble left where it is, and Francis looks from face to face as though he has been allowed into a room he did not expect to enter.

“Lewis says that this, right here, is how they change Malvern.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +1)

C. S. Lewis

C. S. Lewis

This is how we change Malvern.

The words settle over the grass and do not bounce away. Francis straightens where he sits, as if the air has gone less hostile. Parsley’s mouth tips in a small, satisfied line, and Edwin looks from one face to the next with quiet wonder.

Francis

Francis

Then it can be done.

Above them, the stream keeps moving, but the little circle has changed shape. No one is waiting to be told what to endure. The boys sit as if they have made a rule between them, and the rule has weight.

Parsley

Parsley

Yes. Not by ourselves, perhaps, but by this.

Edwin

Edwin

And by keeping one another in it.

Francis glances down at his own empty hands, then toward the hidden pebble in Edwin’s pocket, as if both are proof of something kept and something chosen. The old shape of the school feels a little less fixed now, pressed back by four boys and their watchfulness.

Contact Us

Did you have a bad experience? Think we can do better? Tell us!

Want to delete your account? Account Deletion