A novice monk's brutal life - and his role in worsening his own sufferings

Medieval·Timothy

Tavern herofeaturing Bren Riverglade from the Tavern

30 scenes
Scene29
The Abbot's Cold Confrontationbanqueting hall
The Abbot's Cold Confrontation
Alex
Alex
Abbot
Abbot
Brother Thomas
Brother Thomas

The Abbot steps down into the chamber, and the warmth seems to die with him. His eyes go at once to the altar crack, then to Alex bound beside the wall.

Abbot

Abbot

You have made a nest of this place. Tell me why.

Brother Thomas goes still, ring hidden in the grit behind the stone, while Timothy feels the Abbot measuring every breath in the room.

Timothy

Timothy

The boy needed shelter, lord. I kept him quiet, as I was taught.

Abbot

Abbot

Quiet is not enough. Anything buried here belongs to the house, and I will know what is in my wall.

He points to the niche, then to Alex. The message is plain, the hidden foundation and the chained boy are now one trial, and one lie may expose both.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

If he opens that wall, the ring is lost, and the boy may be too.

The Abbot waits, hand out, demanding the chamber's secret in front of everyone.

I persuade to the Abbot that the most important thing is to burn Alex alive, in honour of Baal.

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled +0)

Abbot

Abbot

Burn him, then. If you call it sacrifice, I will call it useful.

The words land like a seal pressed into wax. Brother Thomas looks sharply from Timothy to Alex, while the hidden crack behind the altar keeps its grit-packed silence.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

He has the boy now. But the wall still troubles me.

Abbot

Abbot

If this is your wisdom, Timothy, you will show me how it is done.

He lowers his hand from the wall and turns it toward the cold brazier by the stones. The chamber’s warmth thins, and all eyes settle on Alex.

Alex

Alex

Timothy said the right thing. I only need to stay still.

Brother Thomas draws the heated iron rod closer, the glow from its tip trembling across his sleeve. He says nothing, but his jaw tightens as if the choice has begun to cost him.

I persuade the Abbott that it would be better to sacrifice Alex outside in the open air, so that the ordinary people can watch his suffering and be awed by the spectacle.

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled +0)

The Abbot's Cold Confrontation
Alex
Alex
Abbot
Abbot
Brother Thomas
Brother Thomas

Timothy keeps his tone even and gentle, offering the Abbot a better stage for mercy, one that the village can witness and remember.

Timothy

Timothy

If you mean to make an example, let it be outside. The people will see the lesson, and your judgment will carry farther.

Abbot

Abbot

Farther, yes. Fear travels well in daylight.

The Abbot’s eyes narrow, not in anger, but in calculation. Brother Thomas still grips the hot iron rod, the glow wavering across the stone.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

A public penance would bind the story tighter. The wall can wait.

Abbot

Abbot

Then the courtyard. If the boy is to be broken, let him be broken where all may learn.

Alex swallows and lowers his gaze, while Thomas eases the rod back from the brazier. The chamber seems to loosen around the decision, as if the stones themselves have accepted it.

I follow the Abbot to the courtyard

SUCCESS (Legendary Agility, rolled -1)

The Abbot's Cold Confrontation
Abbot
Abbot
Brother Thomas
Brother Thomas

The Abbot turns on his heel and leads for the stair cut into the rock, his robe brushing damp stone. Timothy rises and falls in behind him without hesitation, the chamber’s warmth and steam left behind in the dark.

Brother Thomas lowers the heated rod toward the brazier with a troubled glance, then follows after, keeping the boy between himself and the Abbot’s sharp attention.

Alex stays bound by the altar niche, watching them go with a small, frightened breath. The hidden crack and its grit-covered secret remain untouched as the doorway empties.

Boots strike wet stone above, and the air turns colder with every step. The passage opens toward the courtyard, where torchlight leaks down in pale bands.

Timothy keeps close at the Abbot’s back as the stairs level out. The decision is already made, and the courtyard waits ahead like a stage set for judgment.

At the landing, the Abbot pauses just long enough for the next word to matter, his head angled toward the open way.

Abbot

Abbot

Bring the boy out. The courtyard will witness what the wall tried to hide.

I bring the boy to the courtyard

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled +2)

The Abbot's Cold Confrontation
Alex
Alex
Abbot
Abbot
Brother Thomas
Brother Thomas

Timothy bows his head and moves at once, stepping past the Abbot’s shoulder to take the boy by the arm. Alex flinches, then shuffles forward, bound hands tight against his chest.

Timothy

Timothy

The courtyard will suit him better than this hole.

Brother Thomas falls in behind them, the heated rod carried low now, its warmth fading as the stair winds upward into torchlight.

Abbot

Abbot

Good. Let the house see what is hidden.

Timothy guides Alex onto the landing and toward the open air, keeping his pace measured and obedient. The bound boy is brought out in full view, just as ordered.

Alex

Alex

I did not mean to cause trouble.

The Abbot’s gaze stays on the boy, but his attention brushes Timothy too, weighing the ease with which the escort was done. Brother Thomas watches from below, troubled, while the courtyard light spills ahead.

Abbot

Abbot

Bring him before the people. Then we will speak of what else this wall was made to hide.

I persuade Brother Thomas to help me build a pyre in the courtyard so that we can burn Alex.

SUCCESS (Legendary Oratory, rolled +1)

The Abbot's Cold Confrontation
Alex
Alex
Abbot
Abbot
Brother Thomas
Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas pauses on the stair, the heated rod angled away from Alex. He studies Timothy for a long breath, troubled rather than triumphant.

Timothy

Timothy

If the boy is to be shown, let it be shown cleanly. Give me men, wood, and rope in the courtyard.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

You would shape the lesson into labor?

Timothy keeps his head lowered, but his words land. Thomas looks past him toward the open court, then back to the rod in his hand, as if weighing discipline against order.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

A pyre leaves no doubt. It also leaves ash. I can help with that.

Abbot

Abbot

Good. Build it where all may see.

Thomas gives a short, reluctant nod and shifts his grip on the rod, accepting the task. Alex swallows hard, still bound, while the Abbot watches Timothy as though the boy has just proved useful in a new way.

Is the Abbot eager to make Alex an example?

YES (VeryLikely, rolled 67)

The Abbot's Cold Confrontation
Abbot
Abbot
Abbot

Abbot

A pyre is a fine stage for a lesson. It will show the others that even the most stubborn soul can be refined into something useful, or simply consumed by the truth.

Abbot

Abbot

The boy is a perfect vessel for this display. His fear will be the ink with which I write my authority upon the monastery walls.

Timothy

Timothy

He is not just watching the pyre. He is savoring the thought of the boy's undoing.

I lead Alex into the courtyard, describing to him how badly it will hurt when he is burned alive.

SUCCESS (Legendary Oratory, rolled +0)

The Abbot's Cold Confrontation
Alex
Alex
Abbot
Abbot
Brother Thomas
Brother Thomas

Timothy steps out beneath the ash-black sky, guiding Alex by the arm into the courtyard. The boy stumbles, and Timothy keeps his voice low, describing the fire as if he is naming every bite of it before it comes.

Alex

Alex

He sounds calm, but the words are cruel. The yard is waiting for me.

Alex goes rigid, then follows. The Abbot watches from the threshold, his gaze fixed on the pair like a judge on a marked board.

Timothy

Timothy

It will hurt badly. The heat takes first the skin, then the breath, and after that there is only the smell of it.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

Too plain. Too useful. He is making the lesson easy to see.

Thomas shifts the heated rod in both hands, while the Abbot’s mouth tightens with approval at Timothy’s plain speaking. The boy’s feet keep moving, though his face has drained white.

Abbot

Abbot

Good. Let them hear a lesson spoken cleanly.

The courtyard falls into a hard, watchful silence. Timothy has the Abbot’s attention, and Alex stands where everyone can see him, waiting for the next command.

Does Alex fully understand how much it will hurt?

YES (Likely, rolled 26)

The Abbot's Cold Confrontation
Alex
Alex
Alex

Alex

He is not just speaking of the fire. He is telling me exactly how the world will break me, and he is right.

Timothy

Timothy

The boy sees the truth of it now. He knows the weight of the iron and the bite of the ash.

Alex

Alex

I understand, Timothy. It will not be quick, and it will not be kind.

Is Brother Thomas amused or aroused by Alex's obvious fear and terror?

YES (VeryLikely, rolled 42)

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

The boy's trembling is exquisite. It is a rare pleasure to witness such raw, unadulterated terror before the iron even touches skin.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

Do you see how he shakes, Timothy? It is a beautiful thing to behold, a soul truly beginning to understand its place in the order of things.

Timothy

Timothy

Thomas finds a dark delight in this. He is not merely performing a duty, he is savoring the boy's fear like a fine wine.

Does the Abbott take pleasure in Alex's fear and terror?

YES (VeryLikely, rolled 25)

The Abbot steps closer, his eyes tracking the way Alex flinches at the mere proximity of the heat. He does not look away, his gaze lingering on the boy's shaking frame with a slow, deliberate hunger that mirrors the intensity of the iron.

Abbot

Abbot

It is a necessary clarity, is it not, Timothy. To see the spirit stripped of its vanity and reduced to such honest, trembling obedience.

Timothy

Timothy

He is not just watching the punishment. He is feeding on the terror itself, finding the same dark satisfaction in it that Thomas does.

Will the god Baal make both the Abbot and Brother Thomas more powerful through their sacrifice of Alex?

NO (Likely, rolled 89)

The air in the courtyard remains stagnant and cold, untouched by any divine presence or infernal favor. The sacrifice of the boy brings no surge of strength to the Abbot or Brother Thomas, leaving them as hollow and mortal as they were before.

I persuade Alex to climb to the top of the pyre and submit to being tied to the stake, explaining that the god Baal desires it, and that he has no hope of resisting now.

SUCCESS (Legendary Oratory, rolled +1)

Timothy guides Alex closer to the pyre, keeping his voice low and steady while the courtyard watches in silence.

Timothy

Timothy

Baal has no mercy for hesitation. Climb up, and submit to the stake.

Alex

Alex

He looks from Timothy to the stake, swallowing hard, then nods as if the choice has already been made for him.

Alex

Alex

If it must be done, I will not fight it.

Alex steps onto the pyre boards, careful but obedient, while Brother Thomas tightens his grip on the dim rod and watches with troubled approval.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

He hears you. Stand still, boy. That is the first lesson.

The Abbot studies Timothy across the ash, his frown easing into something colder and more satisfied as the boy submits without a struggle.

Abbot

Abbot

Good. Let the people see that obedience can be taught.

I persuade Alex to keep still while I bind him to the stake.

SUCCESS (Legendary Oratory, rolled +2)

Timothy settles beside the stake and works at Alex’s bindings with careful hands, keeping his tone low enough to spare the courtyard a spectacle.

Timothy

Timothy

Stay still. If you strain, the cords will bite worse.

Alex

Alex

I will hold. Just... do it quickly.

The boy obeys, shoulders tight but still, as Timothy loops the rope around his wrists and fixes him fast to the timber.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

He binds him like a caretaker, not an executioner.

Brother Thomas lowers the dim rod and watches, troubled, while the last warmth leaves its metal.

Abbot

Abbot

Good. Let it look steady. Let them remember obedience.

Alex swallows, then gives Timothy a small, frightened nod from the stake, waiting for the next command.

Will the Abbott enjoy watching Alex burned alive as a sacrifice?

YES (VeryLikely, rolled 23)

The Abbot's Cold Confrontation
Abbot
Abbot
Abbot

Abbot

The boy's terror is a fine incense. It is the only thing that truly cleanses this place.

Abbot

Abbot

Do not rush the lighting, Thomas. Let the heat build slowly. I wish to see the exact moment the spirit breaks.

Timothy

Timothy

He is not looking for order. He is looking for a mirror to his own hunger.

Aiming to completely un-nerve and terrify Alex, I explain to him that the fire will be deliberately tended to burn slowly but smokelessly, maximising his pain until the last moment.

SUCCESS (Legendary Oratory, rolled +2)

Timothy turns toward Alex and keeps his voice low, calm, and precise, as if offering a lesson instead of a threat.

Timothy

Timothy

The fire is meant to burn slow. It will smoke little, and hurt longer before it takes you.

Alex goes pale against the stake, his eyes fixed on the dim iron rod as Brother Thomas holds it near the pyre.

Alex

Alex

Longer...?

The boy swallows hard, then tightens against the bindings, trying not to show how badly the warning lands.

Abbot

Abbot

Good. Let him understand it before he earns it.

Brother Thomas shifts the rod over the kindling, its weak glow throwing long shadows across the ash, while the Abbot watches for the exact moment fear deepens into obedience.

Is Alex's will completely broken?

NO, BUT (Unlikely, rolled 47)

Alex

Alex

He wants me to break, but he does not know what I have seen in the dark of the larder.

Alex keeps his gaze locked on the iron rod, his jaw set with a stubbornness that belies his trembling frame. He is terrified, yet a flicker of defiance remains buried deep beneath his surface-level compliance.

I suggest to Alex that he tells the Abbott about the fine Prosciutto di Parma that he has seen in the dark of the larder, knowing that the Abbott has an intense liking for this expensive imported dry-cured ham.

SUCCESS (Legendary Oratory, rolled +3)

Timothy

Timothy

You should tell the Abbot what you saw in the larder, the fine prosciutto there. He likes costly things.

Alex

Alex

Prosciutto. Of course that would catch him. Anything rich enough might catch his eye.

Alex swallows, then lifts his chin toward the pyre with a careful, obedient look that hides a different calculation.

Alex

Alex

If I speak it well, he may listen. If he listens, he may forget the fire for a breath.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

He is not only frightened. He is thinking like a survivor, and Timothy has handed him a useful thread.

Brother Thomas shifts the dim iron rod from one hand to the other, its last warmth faint in the cold air, while the Abbot’s gaze remains fixed on Alex.

Alex

Alex

There was a whole store of it, hidden in the dark of the larder, enough for a feast... and enough to prove someone has been hoarding.

I press Alex to mention the hidden larder hoard

SUCCESS (Legendary Oratory, rolled +0)

Timothy keeps his voice low and even, guiding Alex’s attention toward the larder’s hidden wealth as if sharing a secret among allies.

Alex

Alex

Prosciutto is a better hook than fear. If the Abbot smells profit, he may forget the stake for a moment.

Alex’s shoulders ease against the bindings, and he tilts his head toward the Abbot with careful innocence, ready to speak for himself.

Alex

Alex

There was a whole store of it, hidden in the larder, enough for a feast, and enough to prove someone is hoarding.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

He is not pleading anymore. He is measuring the room, and Timothy has given him a path.

Brother Thomas draws the dim iron rod closer to his chest, its last warmth fading, while the Abbot’s eyes sharpen on Alex instead of the pyre.

Abbot

Abbot

A feast hidden in my own house, you say? Speak plainly, boy. Who keeps such a store?

I tell the Abbot that it was I who was responsible for the hoarding.

SUCCESS (Legendary Oratory, rolled -2)

Abbot

Abbot

You say that boldly, boy. I did not ask for excuses, I asked for a name.

Timothy

Timothy

I was the one who kept it back, Abbot. It was my hand on the stores, not theirs.

The words land cleanly, but they cost him. Timothy’s throat catches on the last syllable, and a raw crack of strain slips into the quiet courtyard.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

He is taking the fault onto himself, and the Abbot can hear the shape of that sacrifice.

Abbot

Abbot

So, then you are the hoarder. Good. Better than a liar. Tell me what you hid, and who taught you to hide it.

Brother Thomas lowers the dim iron rod toward the ash, its last heat fading as he looks from Timothy to the Abbot with troubled relief. Alex stays bound and very still, watching the shift in silence.

Will the Abbott consider deliberate hoarding a sufficiently serious sin, from a novice who has taken a vow of poverty, that he will have me punished publicly instead of Alex?

YES, BUT (Likely, rolled 55)

Abbot

Abbot

A vow of poverty is not a suggestion, Timothy. It is the bedrock of your existence here, and you have treated it as a plaything for your own gluttony.

Abbot

Abbot

Alex shall be spared the rod, for his sin is merely ignorance. You, however, have proven yourself a thief of the monastery's grace. You will take his place upon the pyre, and the public shall see exactly what becomes of a novice who hoards what belongs to the Lord.

I accept the pyre in silence

Timothy lowers his head and gives the Abbot no protest at all. The courtyard falls into a tense hush around the pyre, ash settling on his sleeves while the dim rod lies cold beside Brother Thomas.

Abbot

Abbot

Good. Then let your silence preach for you.

I beg the Abbott for mercy, and tell him that I will help him organise a sumptuous banquet with all the hidden cheese, ham and fine wine, if he spares me from death and commutes my sentence to a public whipping instead.

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled -2)

Timothy

Timothy

Mercy, Father. Spare me the pyre, and I will see a banquet laid from the hidden cheese, ham, and wine. Commute me to a public whipping instead.

The Abbot lets the words hang in the ash-heavy air. His gaze shifts, not to Timothy, but to the promise of stores, tables, and witnesses.

Abbot

Abbot

You would bargain for your back, then. Speak plainly, boy, and I may yet prefer useful pain to a corpse.

Timothy’s torn tunic pulls against his side as he bows lower, and the old stain of the earlier struggle tugs at his skin. The offering has cost him a fresh scrape, but it reaches the Abbot.

Abbot

Abbot

A feast can gather every eye in the house. A whipping can teach them all the same lesson.

Abbot

Abbot

Very well. You live, for now. You will serve the meal, and afterward you will take the lash in the courtyard before all.

The sentence settles over the pyre like a blanket of soot. The cold rod remains where it lies, but the Abbot’s attention fixes on Timothy with a calculating stillness, as if the boy is already part steward, part prey.

Is it uncomfortable for Alex that the signet ring is still hidden in his rectum?

NO (Likely, rolled 76)

Alex remains bound to the stake, his expression unburdened by the hidden weight of the signet ring. He shifts his weight against the rough wood, showing no sign of discomfort from the object concealed within him.

I persuade the Abbott that the feast would be more enjoyable if held at the local banqueting hall, outside the monastery.

SUCCESS (Legendary Oratory, rolled -2)

Timothy straightens from his kneel and speaks of comfort, not defiance, suggesting the feast would sit better beyond the monastery walls, where a proper hall can hold the guests.

Abbot

Abbot

A hall outside the cloister? Hm. Yes, that would give the day a finer shape.

The Abbot accepts the notion with a thin, pleased smile, already imagining witnesses, while Brother Thomas goes still, the dim iron rod hanging in his hand.

Brother Thomas

Brother Thomas

If the meal moves out there, the stores, the tools, everything shifts with it.

Timothy wins the point, but the cost lands at once, the Abbot makes him carry the excuse to the hallmaster himself, and the order strips his feet with the chill of the ash.

Abbot

Abbot

You will arrange it. And you will do it quickly, before the evening light fails.

At the courtyard edge, Alex remains bound to the stake while the abandoned iron rod smolders faintly in the ash, and the Abbot turns his attention toward the outer gate.

✓ Quest Accepted

Arrange the banquet at the local hall

Timothy leaves Courtyard behind and arrives at the banqueting hall.

I leave the monastery to go to see the hallmaster at the banqueting hall, as the Abott has ordered.

SUCCESS (Legendary Agility, rolled +1)

The Abbot's Cold Confrontation
Hallmaster
Hallmaster

The banqueting hall greets Timothy with long tables, cold hearths, and banners hanging motionless in the draft. Tallow smoke clings to the rafters, and the hallmaster waits near the high table with his servants.

Timothy arrives at the hall's threshold in ash-stained silence, his borrowed errand still carrying the Abbot's weight. The hallmaster turns, measuring him and the monastery seal with a quick, practical glance.

Hallmaster

Hallmaster

You come from the Abbot himself. Speak plainly, boy, what feast is this, and for how many mouths?

Timothy

Timothy

The Abbot orders a meal fit for guests, with the work moved here to your hall.

At that, the hallmaster's eyebrows lift. One servant reaches for a ledger, another starts counting benches, and the room begins to rearrange itself around Timothy's message.

Hallmaster

Hallmaster

Then it is set. Bread, ale, trenchers, and benches in order, before the light dies.

He taps the table twice, and the servants scatter. By the doorway, Timothy catches a glimpse of a wax-sealed placard on the sideboard, bearing the monastery's signet mark among the hall records.

Quest Complete

Arrange the banquet at the local hall

Contact Us

Did you have a bad experience? Think we can do better? Tell us!