A Bard and a Rogue: a partial love story

Fantasy·Carciel

50 scenes
Scene28
The Evidence Held TogetherHearing chamber
The Evidence Held Together
Court Clerk
Court Clerk
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
The Registrar
The Registrar
The Finely Dressed Envoy
The Finely Dressed Envoy

The records annex settles into a rare hush. Beyond the closed door, the envoy waits under watch, while lamplight pools over the writing table.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Hold still. The bandage is stained, not failing. That is a distinction worth keeping.

Serren reties the cloth around Carciel’s palm, careful not to pull the knot too tight. The Court Clerk arranges the copied index, black-wax docket, and testimony in a precise order.

Court Clerk

Court Clerk

The chain begins with the copied index, continues through the docket, and ends with the Registrar’s willing testimony. Nothing stands alone.

The Registrar

The Registrar

And my statement does not erase my earlier silence. I will answer for both, if the magistrates ask.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Good. Then we tell it plainly. No softening the danger, and no making it larger than the record proves. After that, perhaps we can have a quiet meal.

I take a moment with Serren.

Carciel takes a quiet moment with Serren. The room’s careful work continues around them, but Serren pauses and meets his gaze.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Whatever comes before the magistrates, you will not face it alone. When this is over, we will have that quiet meal.

"I know, but ...I guess part of me was hoping for a little more than that you know" I laugh half heartedly

SUCCESS (Fair Persuasion, rolled +1)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
Carciel

Carciel

I know, but... part of me was hoping for a little more than that, you know?

Carciel gives a half-hearted laugh. The motion pulls at his fresh bandage, and a small red stain spreads through the linen.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

More than reassurance. Yes. I should have heard that in what you said.

Serren reaches across the table and rests their fingers over Carciel's bandaged hand, careful not to press the wound.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

I want more too. Not a grand promise made for witnesses. I want the life after them, when no one is asking us to prove what we mean.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

A quiet meal. A room that belongs to us. Music because you choose to play it, not because someone needs a witness. Is that the more you meant?

Beyond the annex door, the envoy's muted impatience remains only a distant pressure. Here, Serren waits with their hand over his, leaving the answer open to Carciel.

✓ Quest Accepted

Share a quiet meal with Serren

I gently lift our hands and kiss theirs. "I do. A small place just the two of us, maybe a child we found and decided to adopt or animal."

SUCCESS (Legendary Agility, rolled -2)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
Carciel

Carciel

I do. A small place for just us, perhaps with a child we find and choose to adopt, or an animal who needs a home.

Carciel gently lifts their joined hands and kisses Serren's fingers. The tenderness is careful, but the movement pulls his injured palm against the bandage.

The linen darkens again. A sharp sting follows, and one bright drop falls onto the table's bare edge, missing the evidence by a finger's breadth.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

A child, or an animal. You make it sound wonderfully ordinary.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

I can imagine the room. Your lute by the window. My records somewhere they cannot threaten anyone. A place where our names are not evidence before they are ours.

Serren turns their hand beneath Carciel's and closes their fingers around his, accepting the kiss and the costly tenderness with it.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

But when we speak before the magistrates, I need to say everything plainly. Even the parts that make me look afraid. Will you let me do that without trying to make the fear disappear?

✓ Quest Accepted

Build an honest life with Serren

"of course my love. But for now let's eat before we go."

FAILURE (Fair Persuasion, rolled +0)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
The Registrar
The Registrar
Carciel

Carciel

Of course, my love. But for now, let us eat before we go.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

I want that. I do. But I cannot let a quiet meal become another way to soften what must be said.

Their fingers tighten around Carciel's hand, then release it carefully. The fresh stain on his bandage remains between them, a small cost neither can pretend away.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

I will speak plainly before the magistrates, even about my fear. Afterward, we eat together. Bread, broth, and no records on the table.

The Court Clerk closes the evidence packet beneath the archive seal. The Registrar signs the custody statement, and the annex's waiting work ends without another appeal.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Come beside me now, Carciel. Let me answer in my own voice, and let our meal wait for the truth.

The annex door opens onto the magistrates' passage. The promised meal stays behind, untouched, while the hearing bell begins to toll.

Let Serren speak their truth

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +2)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale

The hearing chamber receives them beneath the tolling bell. Carciel arrives beside Serren, and the annex door shuts behind them, cutting off the untouched meal and the waiting records table.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

I was afraid. I stayed silent when Maelin Hart needed witnesses, and I let that silence become part of the harm. I will not do so again.

The magistrates' scribes bend over their tablets. No one interrupts. Serren's account enters the chamber in their own voice, with Carciel visibly beside them.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

The refuge was altered. The records were moved under authority that did not belong to the order shown. I witnessed enough to testify, and I will distinguish what I know from what I fear.

A magistrate signals for the doors to be barred. The record keeper marks Serren's testimony as voluntary, while the sealed evidence remains beyond the magistrates' hands.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Carciel is here as a witness, not as my voice. Let the record judge both of us by what we say plainly.

The presiding magistrate turns from Serren to Carciel. The next question is reserved for him, and every quill in the chamber waits.

I look Serren in the eye, with full trust in them. "Say your peace Serren."

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
Carciel

Carciel

Say your piece, Serren.

Serren meets Carciel’s eyes, steadied by his trust, then turns back to the magistrates.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Then I will. I remember what I witnessed, and I will name what I do not. We stand together in truth, not in borrowed certainty.

I look at the court. "As will I"

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
Carciel

Carciel

As will I.

The presiding magistrate accepts the parallel testimony, and the scribes mark both witnesses for examination. The barred chamber settles into formal hearing; the envoy’s demand remains outside it, unable to interrupt.

"I ask that the Envoys demands be recorded."

FAILURE (Fair Persuasion, rolled -1)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate
Carciel

Carciel

I ask that the envoy's demand be recorded.

The request reaches the bench, but the presiding magistrate raises a hand. The envoy is not present to answer for the demand, and the chamber will not turn an absent voice into testimony.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

Denied as a separate deposition. The challenge is already entered as contestable. It will not be duplicated here without the envoy before us.

The refusal closes the easy path. Yet the magistrate orders the existing annex entry read aloud, preserving the envoy's incomplete authority as the reason the evidence remains under protection.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Then let the record show the distinction. We are not claiming what the envoy knows. We are stating what the written demand fails to prove.

A senior scribe reads the entry. The presiding magistrate then seals the preliminary examination, ending the chamber's review of the demand and turning the hearing toward the witnesses' direct account.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

The challenge stands outside the testimony, but its deficiency is preserved. Serren Vale, continue with what you personally witnessed.

I look at Serren and nod.

Carciel nods to Serren. The gesture settles between them as a quiet promise: speak plainly, and neither will stand alone.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

I saw the records moved, and I stayed silent when fear told me to look away. I will not do that again.

I give the magistrate a clear and accurate testimony

SUCCESS (Legendary Reasoning, rolled +4)

The Evidence Held Together
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate

Carciel gives the magistrate a clear account, separating what he witnessed from what the records merely suggested: the altered custody line, the black-wax authority, the missing receiving mark, and the envoy’s unentered demand.

He identifies each fact without claiming knowledge he does not possess. The scribes keep pace, their quills scratching through the chamber’s guarded silence.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

Your testimony is precise. It distinguishes evidence from inference, and it confirms the custody challenge already entered.

The magistrate accepts Carciel’s account into the preliminary examination. The barred hearing chamber changes at once from a place of questioning into a record of formal finding.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

That is what I witnessed as well. Where my knowledge ends, I will say so. Where fear made me silent, I will name that silence plainly.

Serren’s testimony now reinforces Carciel’s rather than borrowing from it. The magistrate’s clerk marks their statements as parallel accounts, giving the evidence a second independent witness.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

The evidence remains under magistrate seal. Registrar, prepare your statement. Witnesses, remain ready for questions about the authority behind the altered line.

"what about the Registrar will you also question them?"

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +0)

The Evidence Held Together
The Registrar
The Registrar
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate
Carciel

Carciel

Will you also question the Registrar?

The question crosses the chamber without embellishment. The scribes pause, then turn their attention toward the Registrar's waiting statement.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

Yes. Their statement is necessary. The altered custody line cannot be weighed without the person who signed against it.

The Registrar steps forward from the side table, carrying no document. Their earlier admission now stands beneath the magistrate's seal, and their silence has nowhere left to hide.

The Registrar

The Registrar

I will answer. The docket appeared valid only because the older custody line was copied over. I can identify the entries I changed, and the authority that line concealed.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Then let the questions separate what you did from what you were ordered to believe. Carciel and I will hear the answer plainly.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

Registrar, begin with the first alteration. State whose authority the original line named, and why it was removed.

"whose authority was concealed"

SUCCESS (Legendary Reasoning, rolled +0)

The Evidence Held Together
The Registrar
The Registrar
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate

Carciel indicates the copied custody line, directing the question toward the authority erased beneath it.

The Registrar

The Registrar

The concealed authority was Odran Vey's. His seal stood behind the removals, though the copied line made the transfer appear lawfully received.

The admission lands in the chamber. The scribes mark Vey's name beside the altered entry, joining the custody fraud to the removals already entered into evidence.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

That is what the altered line hid. The record did not merely lose a name, it concealed whose power made the erasure possible.

The Registrar

The Registrar

I changed the copied entry. I did not understand the whole design then, but I knew Vey's authority was being removed from sight.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

Registrar, identify the mark that carried Vey's authority. Then state whether any lawful receiving seal replaced it.

"please preserve the private records"

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -2)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
The Registrar
The Registrar
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate
Carciel

Carciel

Please preserve the private records.

The request enters the hearing as a demand for custody, not concealment. Carciel's injured palm tightens against the rail, and fresh red seeps through the bandage onto the wood.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

Granted. The private records remain sealed under this court's custody. No envoy, registrar, or magistrate may remove them without a verified order entered into the record.

The Registrar

The Registrar

Then mark this plainly. No lawful receiving seal replaced Vey's authority. The copied line made an unlawful transfer look received.

The scribes add the preservation order beside Vey's name. The evidence chain is secured, but the Registrar's admission now places their own alteration beneath the magistrate's scrutiny.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

We will keep the facts separate. Their alteration, Vey's authority, and the missing receiving seal must each stand in the record.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

So entered. Registrar, identify every hand that saw the older line before it was copied. Begin with the person who instructed you.

"Register please name the instructor"

SUCCESS (Legendary Reasoning, rolled -1)

The Evidence Held Together
The Registrar
The Registrar
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate
Carciel

Carciel

Registrar, please name the instructor.

The request cuts through the chamber's formal language. The scribes pause, quills hovering over the custody ledger.

The Registrar

The Registrar

It was Magistrate Halren Doss who instructed me. He said the older line endangered the court, and ordered me to copy over Vey's authority before the transfer was received.

The name lands in the record beside Odran Vey's mark. The Registrar's admission now reaches beyond the archive and toward the magistrates themselves.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Then record the distinction plainly. The Registrar altered the line, Vey's authority was concealed, and Magistrate Doss gave the instruction.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

Scribes, enter Magistrate Halren Doss as the named instructor. Registrar, state whether anyone else witnessed that instruction.

The quills resume. Across the bench, the magistrate's sealed custody writ remains untouched, while every face turns toward the Registrar's next answer.

I help the Registrar secure the private records

SUCCESS (Superb Strength, rolled -1)

The Evidence Held Together
The Registrar
The Registrar
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate

Carciel braces the private records while the Registrar fits the archive cord through the coffer’s iron clasp. His injured palm splits again, and a red smear marks the cord before the knot holds.

The Registrar

The Registrar

The seal is secure. Your blood is on it now, witness and custodian together.

The Registrar draws the clasp shut and presses their sign beside Carciel’s mark. The private records are secured under the chamber’s authority, their custody visible to every scribe.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Then let the record show what his hand protected, and what mine witnessed. Neither of us will carry this account alone.

The Presiding Magistrate orders the coffer placed beneath the bench, but the fresh blood on its cord gives the assembled court a new detail to weigh, proof of protection and a reason for hostile eyes to linger.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

Registrar, name every person who saw the older line before it was copied. Begin with the first witness, and do not omit anyone who may dispute this account.

Has anyone else witnessed the altered custody line?

YES, AND MORE (VeryLikely, rolled 14)

The Registrar

The Registrar

Yes. Magistrate Halren Doss saw the older line before I copied over it. The former archive warden witnessed the instruction, and two transfer scribes saw the line before the alteration. More than one account can dispute mine.

The answer is emphatic: the altered line was not witnessed by one person alone, but by several, giving the magistrates more testimony to weigh and more hostile eyes to turn toward the witnesses.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Then let each account stand separately. No fear, loyalty, or pressure should make one witness carry another’s certainty.

Did the former warden keep a copy of the older line?

YES (Likely, rolled 48)

The former archive warden kept a copy of the older custody line, hidden among their private records. That copy could independently confirm what was erased and who ordered it, but it remains outside the magistrates’ secured coffer.

The Registrar

The Registrar

Yes. The warden retained a duplicate before surrendering the official register. It bears the older line and the marks of those who examined it.

Is the warden’s duplicate still intact?

NO (Likely, rolled 90)

No. The duplicate is not intact; its older line has been damaged beyond reliable reading, leaving the magistrates without a complete independent confirmation.

"I would like the Registrar to secure the strap"

NO, BUT (Likely, rolled 72)

No, the Registrar does not secure the strap. Their lowered hand stops short, and the damaged record remains unsecured while the scribes continue noting the negative finding.

I would like the Registrar to secure the strap

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -1)

The Evidence Held Together
The Registrar
The Registrar
Carciel

Carciel

Please secure the strap before the fragment slips farther.

The Registrar studies the exposed record, then reaches beneath the witness rail instead of touching the writing.

The Registrar

The Registrar

Agreed. The fragment remains visible, and its condition will be recorded.

They draw the narrow strap across the damaged record and fasten it to the witness-space clasp. The fragment stays exposed, but no longer shifts.

The Registrar

The Registrar

It is secured without concealing the damage. Let the record show that distinction.

The scribes mark the restored custody of the fragment. The Presiding Magistrate turns from the damaged duplicate toward the next question.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

Registrar, name the person who ordered the duplicate retained, and state whether that order was entered lawfully.

"I would also like to know"

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +0)

The Evidence Held Together
The Registrar
The Registrar
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate
Carciel

Carciel

I would also like to know who ordered the duplicate retained, and whether that order was lawful.

The request joins the magistrate’s question without breaking the chain of custody. Across the rail, the Registrar lifts their hands clear of the fragment and faces the bench.

The Registrar

The Registrar

The order came from Magistrate Halren Doss. It was given privately, to preserve a duplicate outside the public transfer. No lawful entry, seal, or receiving mark records that order.

A scribe pauses, then writes Doss’s name beside the damaged duplicate. The answer makes the fragment more than a failed copy. It becomes evidence that an unentered instruction shaped what the archive kept.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Then record the limits plainly. The fragment cannot prove the altered line by itself, but the Registrar’s account proves who ordered it retained and that the order was never lawfully entered.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

So entered. Carciel’s request and Serren Vale’s distinction will stand with the Registrar’s testimony. No private order shall be treated as a lawful custody mark.

"I would like to know what else Harlen Doss is hiding"

SUCCESS (Legendary Reasoning, rolled -2)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
The Registrar
The Registrar
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate
Carciel

Carciel

I would like to know what else Halren Doss is hiding.

The question turns the court’s attention from the damaged fragment to the hand behind its concealment. Carciel’s injured palm presses against the rail, and the bandage opens, marking the wood with fresh blood.

The Registrar

The Registrar

Doss hid more than the duplicate. He kept a private list of the witnesses and entries connected to the removals, including which names were to be omitted from the public register.

The Registrar

The Registrar

He ordered the list retained beside the damaged fragment so he could deny its reliability if questioned, while still using it to control whose testimony reached the magistrates.

A scribe records the admission. The Registrar’s account gives Carciel the concealed purpose, but the blood on the rail draws wary glances and leaves his hand visibly worsening.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Record that as the Registrar’s account, not as proof beyond it. The hidden list must be found and examined separately.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

So entered. Registrar, identify where Doss kept this private list, and state whether anyone else knew of it.

✓ Quest Accepted

Expose what Halren Doss concealed in his private list

I apply pressure to my hand. "I wish to know where Doss kept the list"

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +1)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
The Registrar
The Registrar
Carciel

Carciel

I wish to know where Doss kept the list.

Carciel presses his injured palm firmly beneath the bandage. The pressure steadies the bleeding long enough for him to keep his hand on the rail.

The Registrar

The Registrar

In the former archive warden’s private records room, behind the west shelf. Doss concealed it inside a false-bottomed folio case.

The Registrar

The Registrar

The former warden knew of it. So did Magistrate Doss, the two transfer scribes, and one clerk assigned to copy the removals. I cannot name that clerk without examining the list.

The answer places the hidden list within reach of the court’s inquiry, but also widens the circle of those who may have profited from its concealment.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Then record the location and every claimed witness separately. We will not let uncertainty become another tool for hiding the truth.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

So ordered. The private records room will be sealed and searched under magistrate authority. Registrar, name the clerk before the search begins.

Beyond the barred chamber, a fist strikes the annex door. The envoy’s muffled demand follows, and the scribes pause over the fresh order.

I demand the private records room be searched now

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +0)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
The Registrar
The Registrar
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate
Carciel

Carciel

I demand that the private records room be searched now.

His voice carries through the chamber. The demand joins the fresh order already waiting on the clerk’s table, and the Presiding Magistrate strikes the seal into the wax.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

Granted. The search begins immediately, under this court’s authority. No record leaves that room, and no private hand directs the examination.

The cost arrives with the victory. Carciel’s bandage darkens again, and a drop of blood marks the witness rail. The nearest scribe glances from the stain to him, suspicion sharpening behind careful silence.

The Registrar

The Registrar

I will lead the court’s officers to the west shelf. The false-bottomed folio case is concealed behind the third ledger tier. I will also identify the copy clerk from the list if we find it.

The barred annex door is unfastened only long enough for two sworn wardens to pass. They turn toward the former archive warden’s private records room as the court seal on its entrance flares with pale light.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Let the record show that Carciel demanded immediate preservation, and that we both remain witnesses to what the search uncovers.

A court scribe raises a fresh slate before following the search party. The slate waits for the names of those permitted to enter.

Does the hidden list name the copy clerk?

YES (Likely, rolled 29)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
The Registrar
The Registrar

The fresh slate catches the Registrar’s first confirmation before the search party vanishes from sight: the hidden list does name the copy clerk, placing that person among the entries tied to the removals and omissions.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Then the list may show who changed the record, not only who ordered it. Let that distinction stand beside the name.

The scribe writes the finding under the court’s search authority, while the sealed doorway’s pale light narrows to a hard line, making the promised examination feel less like recovery than a test of whose testimony will survive.

I give my hand to Serren to look at. "Did the clerk alter the record?"

SUCCESS (Superb Perception, rolled +0)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale

Carciel offers his injured hand across the witness rail. The fresh stain on the bandage catches the chamber’s pale light.

Carciel

Carciel

Did the clerk alter the record?

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Let me see.

Serren takes Carciel’s hand carefully, turning the bandage aside just enough to inspect the reopened wound without disturbing the evidence rail.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

The list places the copy clerk among the removals and omissions. That proves access, perhaps participation, but not yet the hand that copied over the older line.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

I know how easily fear turns suspicion into certainty. I will not do that to you, or to the record.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

The Registrar’s testimony names the alteration and Doss’s instruction. The clerk may have carried it out, but we should let the list show what it actually says. Will you read it with me when it returns?

"I will, and when this is all over we will have that quiet meal." I smile

Carciel

Carciel

I will, and when this is over, we will have that quiet meal.

Carciel smiles, steady despite the stain spreading through his bandage.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

Then I will hold you to it. No testimony, seal, or magistrate gets to take that promise from us.

I read the list with Serren

SUCCESS (Legendary Reasoning, rolled +0)

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale

The Registrar returns with the false-bottomed folio case held beneath the court seal. The damaged duplicate remains strapped in the witness space, while the hidden list lies open between Carciel and Serren.

Together, Carciel and Serren read the cramped entries. The list names the copy clerk, Halren Doss, and the witnesses marked for omission from the public register.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

These are not one accusation. They are separate acts, separate knowledge, and separate silences.

The final column records Doss’s private instructions beside the erased entries. It exposes what he concealed, while leaving each named person’s responsibility for the court to examine.

The Registrar

The Registrar

I confirm this is the list I described. It was kept outside the public register so these names could be controlled or omitted.

The Presiding Magistrate orders the list entered as a witnessed exhibit. The sealed doorway is unbarred, ending the private search and opening the chamber to the waiting court.

Presiding Magistrate

Presiding Magistrate

The concealed list is now before the court. Witnesses, remain together while the examination proceeds.

Quest Complete

Expose what Halren Doss concealed in his private list

New Gift: Reads Hidden Motives

I finally share that meal with Serren

The Evidence Held Together
Serren Vale
Serren Vale
Presiding Magistrate
Presiding Magistrate

When the examination pauses, Carciel and Serren finally share the quiet meal promised in the annex, seated together at the chamber’s side table. The court continues its orderly work nearby, but for a few bites, their testimony gives way to ordinary company.

Serren Vale

Serren Vale

There. We kept one promise today. We can keep the smaller ones too.

Quest Complete

Share a quiet meal with Serren

New Gift: Quiet Companionship

+ New Item Acquired

Meal cup

Contact Us

Did you have a bad experience? Think we can do better? Tell us!