
Before any formal summons can reach her, Elizabeth Billings descends from the castle steps in a travelling cloak, the Viscount’s acknowledgment held securely in one hand. She crosses straight to the Black Gull and steps aboard beside Mara Trevithick.

Elizabeth Billings
I am coming with you, Arrus. An engagement does not make me a sheltered witness while you investigate the lime kilns.
Mara checks the mooring lines, water casks, and wrapped provisions without pausing. Her sharp glance moves from Elizabeth’s cloak to the open channel, measuring the danger of uncertain waters against the urgency of the black-pennant report.

Mara Trevithick
The boat can carry us, but not carelessness. The lime kilns have a concealed approach, and whoever retrieved that pennant may still be watching it.

Elizabeth Billings
Then take the concealed approach. I brought the acknowledgment for Mara, and I know how to read a document without waving it beneath a sentry’s nose.
Elizabeth offers Mara the sealed acknowledgment, keeping her travelling cloak gathered clear of the gunwale. Mara accepts it, checks the seal, and tucks it beneath the provisions before loosening the final line.

Mara Trevithick
There. We are committed now. Arrus, you stand between a determined fiancée and a practical risk. Choose our course, and choose it quickly.
✓ Quest Accepted
Determine the truth behind the phantom ship at the lime kilns
✓ Quest Accepted
Persuade Elizabeth to respect my desire not to bring my intended bride into the path of outlaws and pirates.
“I will take a stern tone, "Now see here, my love, I am very committed to our stated agreement to respect each other, in life as in love, and with regard to my sworn oath of service to Viscount Falmouth, but at no point did we agree that I am to stand by in silence, like a fool, while you presume to tell me to be content with a plan as ludicrously mad as for me to expect no one to respect MY desire not to bring my intended bride into the dangerous path of outlaws and pirates. And since I, between the two of us, is the expert on surviving danger on the seas, and since it IS my expert opinion that it is exactly such danger that this mission is intended to move directly into the path of, I must accept nothing!" I will soften my voice, "Give me a thousand other reasons to take you sailing for the joy of it, and I shall be so, but this?... I cannot allow it, and I will not, my beloved." I will then stand firmly but with open arms of pleading. "Tell me what you wish, and I'll bring word."”
SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +1)


Arrus Gandon
Now see here, my love. I am committed to our agreement, to our love, and to my oath of service, but I will not stand by while you enter a path of outlaws and pirates. I am the expert on surviving danger at sea, and I must refuse this plan.

Arrus Gandon
Give me a thousand reasons to take you sailing for joy, and I shall. But this I cannot allow, and I will not, my beloved. Tell me what you wish, and I will bring word.
Arrus stands firmly with his arms open in pleading. His stern Oratory strains against the difficulty, while Silver Tongue lends the refusal warmth and his Seasoned Diplomat instinct gives Elizabeth’s dignity and choice their proper place.
His Code of Honor makes the boundary plain rather than coercive: he will not command his intended bride, but neither will he pretend that love requires surrendering his judgment about danger.

Elizabeth Billings
You have made your position unmistakable, Arrus. I will remain here, and I will not follow you to the lime kilns. I want your safe return, not the victory of proving that I can share every danger.

Elizabeth Billings
Tell me what you discover, and bring me word through Mara. I will study the acknowledgment, prepare what support the castle can lawfully provide, and trust you to return to me.
Elizabeth presses the sealed acknowledgment back into Mara’s keeping, then steps ashore. The Black Gull is free to depart with Arrus and Mara, while Elizabeth remains safely at the castle, persuaded without surrendering her resolve.
Quest Complete
Return the Crown’s acknowledgment to Mara
Skill Upgrade: Oratory Fair→Good
Quest Complete
Persuade Elizabeth to respect my desire not to bring my intended bride into the path of outlaws and pirates.
“Once we are underway aboard the Wren, I will bring Mara into the ship's captain's cabin and congratulate her on the Crown's acknowledgement, and then begin describing the plan hatched with Bessy and John Carter to use the Wren to covertly investigate coastal trade while posing as one of Carter's local smuggling vessels and funded by The Quietus Exchange as a way to generate good will towards John Carter, increasing his information gathering as well as concealing donations to the needy as his charitable gifts from duty-free cargo and alleged contraband, paid for in secret by the Viscount's own secretly controlled goods exchange... Then I will tell Mara about the exciting discoveries when I searched this very ship for secret records and show her the results to analyze together in secret while sailing up the Fal river past Flushing and the lime kilns, landing well beyond so that we only observe and sail by for reconnaissance when we reach them so that we can approach by Bessy's footpath.”
SUCCESS (Good Oratory, rolled +1)

Once the Wren clears the harbor, Arrus brings Mara into the captain’s cabin. The vessel’s quiet creak and steady tide leave them a private space for careful work.

Arrus Gandon
Mara, congratulations on the Crown’s acknowledgement. Bessy and John Carter have helped shape the Wren into a lawful-looking local trader, funded through the Quietus Exchange and the Viscount’s concealed goods exchange.
He lays out the arrangement precisely: honest cargo and discreet investigation above deck, charitable deliveries below the accounts, and Carter’s reputation strengthened by gifts that appear to come from his own duty-free trade.

Mara Trevithick
So the Wren earns goodwill while concealing the source of the charity, and Carter gains both village trust and better intelligence. That is generous, but the books must survive scrutiny.
Arrus produces the confidential authority order, then unlocks the hidden records he found aboard the ship. Grandmaster of Secrets separates operational clues from harmless trade entries, while Account Keeper aligns cargo, payments, and missing figures.

Arrus Gandon
These are the discoveries from my search. We will analyze them together while sailing up the Fal, pass Flushing and the lime kilns, then land beyond them and approach by Bessy’s footpath.

Mara Trevithick
Agreed. Your authority makes the voyage defensible, your secrecy keeps the records contained, and your plan leaves us observing before we commit ourselves ashore. Put the ledgers here.
Mara spreads the records across the cabin table as the Wren turns upriver. Together they identify duplicated entries and a suspicious gap near the lime kilns, securing their findings before the concealed landing.
✓ Quest Accepted
Report the lime-kiln findings to Elizabeth
“I will tell Mara that I have no less concern for her safety than I did for Elizabeth's before we set sail, and I intend to leave her safely aboard in command of the ship while I go ashore after dark with armed men, looking for a lanternless ship. How many good, able fighting men do I have among the crew who I can bring ashore while leaving the Wren in Mara's command? Are there at least a dozen I can take ashore with me while leaving enough to guard the ship with Mara?”
NO, AND WORSE (Unlikely, rolled 100)


Arrus Gandon
Mara, I have no less concern for your safety than I had for Elizabeth's before we sailed. You will remain aboard in command while I go ashore after dark with armed men to hunt that lanternless ship.
Mara studies the quiet deck, then counts the available hands by sight. The Wren carries only seven able sailors besides her, and merely four have the strength and experience for a shore fight.

Mara Trevithick
No dozen, Arrus. Not even close. Four can fight ashore, but leaving with them would give me three sailors to guard the Wren, and one is already limping.
A sailor hurries from the foredeck, pale beneath the moonlight. The Wren's only longboat is no longer secured beneath its davits, and its painter has been cleanly severed.

Mara Trevithick
And there is worse. Our boat is gone. Whoever watches the lime kilns has taken away our easiest retreat, or means to make us believe they have.
Mara moves to the rail and searches the black water. The remaining crew cluster behind her, suddenly aware that the Wren is not merely carrying observers toward danger, but has already been touched by it.

Mara Trevithick
I can hold this vessel with the remaining hands, but not against a boarding party. If you go ashore, you must assume the missing boat was taken deliberately and that our watcher knows we are here.
“I will order the ship to wheel around hard astern and to immediately illuminate all ship's lights and lanterns as well. I will then go to the bow and scan the water from both sides of the river in the darkening night's light and use my spyglass to scan the river for signs of the saboteurs who stole our longboat, as they couldn't likely have hauled it ashore very long ago, if they tried to do so afterwards... Can I make out the dark shapes of a crewed row boat possibly towing an empty stolen one, rowing away from us down the river?”
NO, BUT (Likely, rolled 68)


Arrus Gandon
Wheel her hard astern. Light every lantern. I want both banks visible, and I want that stolen boat found before its trail cools.
The Wren heels sharply as her crew obeys. Lanterns bloom along the deck and rigging, scattering gold across the darkening river while the current swings her stern around.
Arrus reaches the bow and searches both banks through his spyglass. No rowing boat emerges, no second hull follows a wake, and the river remains empty beneath the fading light.

Mara Trevithick
Nothing moving on the water. But there, below the eastern bank, the reeds are flattened in a fresh line toward the old lime-kiln path.
The glass confirms her observation: wet reeds bend away from the river, and a dark scrape marks the mud where something heavy was dragged ashore recently. The stolen longboat is not escaping downstream.

Mara Trevithick
They hauled it inland under cover of the bank. If we keep the Wren lit and hold here, we may force them to choose between hiding and crossing back to the water.
The Wren steadies under full lantern light, revealing no enemy but exposing the fresh drag trail plainly enough to follow from shore. The missing boat has become a landward trail, not a vanished river chase.
“"We must continue sailing towards the kilns from the scraped trail through the reeds, which can get a few of us ashore there faster than a team of men struggling to carry a heavy longboat overhead in the dark..." I will order the crew to steer us as close to shore as the shallow draft of the Wren can safely keep moving near a known soft mudbank to hop overboard and wade ashore from there. I will recruit the three most able men of the crew to bear arms to come ashore with me while the other four stay aboard to guard the ship with Mara. I will instruct them to keep a cannon loaded toward both directions of the open river, and all eyes open and looking for a dark ship... The rest I lead ashore with sword and gunpowder heald aloft to load dry pistols and find our boat thieves before they can reach the kilns on foot. We will find the path and lay in dark ambush for a small crew to pass, with or without carrying the longboat. I will command them to follow my lead and hold their fire.”
SUCCESS (Great Seamanship, rolled -3)

Arrus orders the Wren toward the flattened reeds, using the spyglass to judge the mudbank while the Navigator of Tides reads the current and shallow draft. The hull grinds softly, then settles safely within wading distance.

Arrus Gandon
Bring her in close. Keep four aboard with Mara, load the cannon toward both reaches of open river, and watch for any dark ship. The three strongest men come ashore with me. Hold your fire until I give the word.
The three selected Wren sailors take muskets and follow Arrus over the side, while the remaining crew secure the vessel. Mara stations them by the loaded cannon, preserving a guarded retreat and clear river view.
Arrus retrieves his flintlock from its locker, keeps the powder horn raised beneath his cloak, and draws his dueling sword only after reaching firmer ground. Battle-Tested Insight turns the fresh drag marks into a likely route toward the kilns.
He leads the shore party through the reeds and finds the stolen boat’s track, then places the three sailors in concealment beside the footpath. The ambush is set before the thieves can reach the lime kilns.
The soft bank takes Arrus’s footing as he crosses, twisting his ankle and sending him against a willow trunk. He absorbs the bruise, steadies his pistol, and raises one hand for absolute silence.

Arrus Gandon
Stay low. No shot, no shout, and no pursuit until I identify them. We let the boat thieves pass into our hands.
Behind him, the Wren’s lanterns hold steady over the river, cannon trained in both directions. Ahead, reeds whisper along the concealed path, and the shore party waits in disciplined darkness.
“I will wait in disciplined silence for signs of the boat thieves suspected to be returning to the abandoned kilns, quietly instructing my men that our goal is, "Captured informants rather than blood, but do not give these men a chance to take your lives dishonorably." The plan is to let them approach in the darkness and then pop out of hiding just ahead of them and threaten them at musket point and the threat of immediate death without surrender, and to mean it... However, if any lives can be spared, they must be, and the thieves captured for interrogation. We will prepare, and wait...”
SUCCESS (Legendary Stealth, rolled -1)


Arrus Gandon
Captured informants, not blood. Do not give them a dishonorable chance to take your lives. Hold until I give the word.
The three Wren sailors sink into the reeds, while Arrus uses Battle-Tested Insight to read the thieves’ returning route. Master Infiltrator discipline leaves the ambush invisible.
His Code of Honor hinders the murderous threat he could make, forcing him to leave surrender visibly possible. The flintlock covers the path, while the dueling sword waits for any rush.
Two shadows emerge, the taller boat thief, a lean young adult man with a weathered face, cropped dark hair, a brown wool jacket, dark breeches, and mud-stained boots, dragging the stolen boat’s painter, alongside the shorter boat thief, a stocky young adult man with a ruddy face, sandy hair, a gray wool shirt, dark breeches, and worn leather shoes, and whispering toward the kilns. Arrus lets them pass the hidden sailors, then rises with his pistol leveled.

Arrus Gandon
Stop. Drop the painter and raise your hands, or I fire. Surrender now, and you live to answer questions.
The three sailors step out with muskets trained, completing the trap. Arrus’s sword bars the nearest path, and the thieves find every escape covered without a shot fired.

The Taller Boat Thief
Easy, sir. We surrender. Take the rope, the boat, everything. Just keep that pistol lowered.

The Shorter Boat Thief
We are caught. No need for blood. We will tell you who paid us.
Both men drop the painter and kneel in the wet grass. The Wren’s crew secures them, alive and disarmed, while the stolen boat lies recovered beside the bank.
“I will locate the stolen boat and ask the thieves where exactly they managed to slip aboard and cut our longboat loose without an excess of patience for their answers. Then, once they are in the habit of answering questions, I will demand all of the information they know about their group that we already know they were on their way to rejoining at the kilns. I will warn them that if they lie to me, the King's sentence for thieves is cutting off their hand, one from each. I will then offer to reconsider immediate punishment if their mouths do satisfy my questions better than their hands could obey the King's laws... And then stand above them with sword drawn before demanding truth and compliance with cold judgement.”
SUCCESS (Legendary Intrigue, rolled +0)

Arrus has the thieves bound beneath the Wren’s lanterns, with the recovered boat pulled clear of the reeds. His flintlock covers them while his drawn sword makes escape unthinkable.

Arrus Gandon
Tell me exactly how you boarded the Wren, cut loose our longboat, and reached the bank. Speak plainly, or the King’s sentence will remove one hand from each of you. Satisfy my questions, and I may reconsider immediate punishment.
The cold warning is lawful only in its consequence, not a promise Arrus intends to enact himself. His pistol controls the taller thief, his sword controls the shorter, and Battle-Tested Insight catches every glance toward the kilns.

The Taller Boat Thief
We came by the eastern bank in a punt, hid beneath the Wren’s quarter, and climbed aboard when your watch turned toward the lanterns. Our man cut the painter while we kept the deck’s shadow. We dragged the longboat inland to leave no wake.

Arrus Gandon
Now give me your group: its size, its leader, its purpose, its weapons, and precisely where it waits among the lime kilns. Leave nothing out.

The Shorter Boat Thief
Seven in all, counting us. Hobb leads them. They wait in the kiln’s old firing shed, with two muskets, pistols, and knives. They mean to seize your papers and burn the Wren if she follows. A black-pennant ship is due before dawn, offshore beyond the western shoal.
The answer comes cleanly. Arrus’s Grandmaster of Secrets turns the confession into a usable map of men, arms, shelter, and timing, while the wounded palm protests beneath the sword grip. The three Wren sailors keep the prisoners covered.
