LiveTale

Adventure of Arus 1 - 18th Century Cornwall

Swashbuckling·Arrus Gandon

53 scenes
‹
Scene52
The Black Pennant ReappearsPendennis Castle — Postern
Character Sheet of Arrus Gandon›
The Black Pennant Reappears
Thomas Redd
Thomas Redd
the Seawren swordsman
the Seawren swordsman
the returning captain
The Returning Captain
the Seawren's acting officer
the Seawren's acting officer
the Seawren's second swordsman
the Seawren's second swordsman

Beatrice’s longboat pulls away toward shore as the Seawren’s moorings come free. Captain Pike supervises the watches, while the Seawren's acting officer arranges colored flags beside the mast and the crew prepares for departure.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

Master Gandon, advise the exercise. We will show false colors, alter course twice, and test whether the watch reads the signal or merely obeys the wind.

The Seawren swordsman and the Seawren's second swordsman take stations near the foremast, while Thomas Redd joins the lookout. The departing courtesy is gone now, replaced by drilled attention and the creak of wet rope.

the Seawren's acting officer

the Seawren's acting officer

Blue pennant ready, captain. The red and gold are folded beneath it, ready to become our false colors on your mark.

Beyond the harbor traffic, a black pennant rises briefly against the pale morning sky. It dips behind a merchant brig, then appears again farther seaward, too deliberate to dismiss entirely.

Thomas Redd

Thomas Redd

Black pennant beyond the brig! It could be the old rumor returning, or only a trick of distance, but it is keeping every eye aboard us.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

Your reading, Master Gandon. Harmless echo or threat, tell me what the Seawren should do before that flag shows itself again.

“I would act with caution, Captain. Signs of troublesome actors influencing the sea lanes near Cornwall would only make me more curious about this phantom hoisting a black penant to be spotted and positively identified before the spread of it's legend does more harm than it's cannons ever could, be there any truth to their rumoured existence... However, if you spot this phantom, bring me to her, and we will capture her together! Whether by ship's gunnery or by sword, she will be ours!”

SUCCESS (Legendary Reasoning, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Thomas Redd
Thomas Redd
the returning captain
The Returning Captain
the Seawren's acting officer
the Seawren's acting officer
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I would proceed cautiously, Captain. Find and positively identify this phantom before its legend outruns the truth. If you spot her, bring me to her, and we shall capture her together, by gunnery or sword.

Arrus raises the Spyglass and studies the black pennant's intervals. Battle-Tested Insight separates deliberate signaling from harmless drift, while Master of Secrets recalls how rumors become cover for men who profit from confusion.

His Code of Honor rejects a reckless broadside against an unconfirmed target, even as Reasoning weighs the wind, course, and harbor traffic. The glass catches a narrow hull slipping beyond the merchant brig, its black pennant plainly raised by design.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

There is truth in the rumor, Captain. That vessel is real, signaling deliberately, and now positively identified. Bring the Seawren after her, but hold fire until we know whom we face.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

A sound judgment, Master Gandon. Elias, keep the merchant brig between us and the channel. Redd, mark her course. We will follow under false colors and close before she can vanish.

The Seawren's flags change, and her bow turns seaward. Through the Spyglass, Arrus keeps the phantom in view as she alters course twice, confirming a watchful hand aboard. The returning captain orders the longboat readied, so Arrus can board her alongside him when the distance closes.

✓ Quest Accepted

Resolve the hostile cutter encounter

“I will prepare my real dueling sword and pistol for battle, as well as the men and crew of the ship, with moral support and encouragement, as we close in on the apparent renegade ship. After carefully studying the features of the mystery vessel through my trusty spyglass, is there anything about this unidentified ship that I can recognize from all my days of sailing, or even a sign such as a recognizable design feature of the vessel's type that would give any clues or indication as to it's origins?”

YES, BUT (Likely, rolled 55)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Thomas Redd
Thomas Redd
the Seawren swordsman
the Seawren swordsman
the returning captain
The Returning Captain
the Seawren's acting officer
the Seawren's acting officer
the Seawren's second swordsman
the Seawren's second swordsman

Arrus straps on his dueling sword and checks the priming of his pistol, then moves among the Seawren crew with steady encouragement as the longboat is readied.

Through the spyglass, the mystery vessel resolves into a lean, fast cutter with a low waist, unusually sharp bow, and a patched lateen rig. Its shallow draft suits the western coves, but the reinforced gun ports suggest more than fishing.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

The hull is built for pursuit and concealment, not honest coastal trade.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

I know that cut, Master Gandon. Western-built, likely altered in a smuggler's yard, though those gun ports were fitted by someone expecting resistance.

The returning captain's assessment sharpens the deck's purpose. The Seawern's acting officer tightens the false colors while Thomas Redd marks the stranger's turns, and the Seawern swordsman and the Seawern's second swordsman take their stations beside the armed crew.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

She has seen us. Her helm has altered toward the shoals, and our false colors bought no more than a moment. We close carefully, but the first exchange may come sooner than we wish.

The renegade cutter slips toward a reef-strewn passage, confirming both its local knowledge and its hostile caution. The Seawren follows, but the narrow water leaves no room for a clean retreat once the longboat goes over.

“I will attempt to observe the engagement from the quarterdeck, avoiding interference in the ship's operations, looking for any noticable opportunities for the Seawren to outmaneuver the mystery cutter into a naval disadvantage that would increase their likelihood of surrender when approached, rather than betting on open battle from a weaker position”

SUCCESS (Superb Perception, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
the returning captain
The Returning Captain
the Seawren's acting officer
the Seawren's acting officer

From the quarterdeck, Arrus keeps clear of the working hands and raises the Spyglass. Navigator of Tides reads the shoals, while Battle-Tested Insight tracks the cutter’s helm, sail, and gun-port timing.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

She wants the reef passage, but her shallow draft will become a trap if the Seawren holds the outer channel.

The Spyglass reveals the cutter’s weakness: each turn toward the reef exposes her stern before the next gust fills the patched lateen sail. Arrus identifies a broad sandbar beyond the passage and the safe water beside it.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

You have found something, Master Gandon. Give me the course, and I will make the water serve us.

Arrus signals the outer channel, then points toward the sandbar. Samuel Pike understands: the Seawren will cross ahead, forcing the cutter to choose open water under the Seawren’s guns or the shoal that denies her turn.

the Seawren's acting officer

the Seawren's acting officer

Helm agrees. She cannot pass the bar without losing her stern. Crew, stand ready, but hold your fire until the captain gives the word.

The Seawren cuts across the cutter’s escape, leaving the shoal astern and the open channel under her broadside. Trapped between guns and bad water, the mystery cutter strikes her black pennant and raises a white cloth. Samuel Pike orders the longboat lowered for the surrender.

Quest Complete

Resolve the hostile cutter encounter

I will advise my own presence on the boarding party with the two most well-trained swordsmen I've seen so far, “Captain Pike, I request permission to join the boarding party with Misters Marr and Pike, sir!”

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled +1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
the Seawren swordsman
the Seawren swordsman
the returning captain
The Returning Captain
the Seawren's second swordsman
the Seawren's second swordsman
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Captain Pike, I request permission to join the boarding party with Misters Marr and Pike, sir!

Arrus presents the request with formal respect, keeping his authority beneath the captain’s command. His dueling sword hangs ready and his flintlock rests secured, making clear he seeks lawful participation, not control.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

Permission granted, Master Gandon. You will board under my orders, with Marr and my second swordsman beside you. Take the cutter cleanly and preserve her crew where they surrender.

Seasoned Diplomat judgment wins the captain’s confidence, while Peerless Duelist readiness makes the proposed party credible. Arrus checks his pistol and draws his sword just enough to test its balance before sheathing it.

the Seawren swordsman

the Seawren swordsman

Gladly, Master Gandon. Jonas and I will hold the rail while you find the cutter’s command.

the Seawren's second swordsman

the Seawren's second swordsman

Aye. We follow your lead, but Captain Pike’s order remains law.

Arrus joins the Seawren swordsman and Jonas at the lowered longboat. His Code of Honor keeps the pistol holstered until needed, and the three swordsmen push off together under the captain’s watch as the surrendered cutter waits ahead.

✓ Quest Accepted

Secure the surrendered cutter

“I will ride the boarding party's longboat with serious caution, with my flintlock pistol drawn and at the ready as we approach the renegade cutter, prepared for any sign that the surrender to the boarding party is anything but completely genuine. Once we make it onto the deck of the ship, I will announce myself by name and demand to speak to the captain of the suspicious crew while quickly assessing the true strength of this crew and vessel, as well as the ship's name and reputation, if it has one. Determining the threat level of the surrendering crew is among my first acts aboard their main deck.”

SUCCESS (Superb Perception, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
the lean middle-aged captain
The Lean Middle-Aged Captain
the Seawren swordsman
the Seawren swordsman
the Seawren's second swordsman
the Seawren's second swordsman

The longboat noses alongside the renegade cutter. Arrus keeps his flintlock drawn across his body, spyglass tucked at his belt, while his dueling sword guards the narrow gap and every surrendering hand.

He boards first with the Seawren swordsman and Jonas close behind. Battle-Tested Insight reads the crew's spacing, weapons, and faces; Master of Secrets compares their silence and signals against the habits of a prepared ambush.

The cutter bears no readable name on her weathered stern, but her reinforced gun ports and patched lateen rig confirm a vessel built for pursuit, concealment, and sudden violence. Twelve sailors stand visible, armed but lowered.

A lean middle-aged man, with weathered skin, a narrow face, cropped black hair, dark breeches, and sea boots in a tar-dark coat steps from the quarterdeck. A pale scar cuts through his left eyebrow, and one hand remains conspicuously empty beside the wheel.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I am Arrus Gandon, envoy of Viscount Falmouth. I demand to speak with the captain of this vessel. State her name, her reputation, and the strength of your crew.

Gideon Voss

Gideon Voss

Gideon Voss, captain of the Black Gull. She has a reputation for outrunning customs cutters and carrying cargo no honest manifest would survive. My crew numbers twelve, and every man is under orders not to resist.

The answer is genuine. Arrus's Code of Honor refuses to invent treachery from fear alone, while the pistol, sword, and spyglass expose the practical truth: twelve armed sailors, disciplined, watchful, and presently compliant, with no hidden force ready to spring.

“Then all is well that conforms to these following orders: the Black Gull is hereby ordered to halt and be boarded by the authority of His Majesty's Royal Navy, to be searched and inspected, with no resistance offered and no brutality will befall any man who now lays down his arms and does as he's ordered, now render arms to the deck, lads, and we'll be done and over with this business the sooner...” As the surrendering crew complies, I will mutter to Jonas to signal additional navy troops aboard to reinforce our boarding party, and for Mr. Marr to collect the crew's weapons in a sack and have them sit as a group in the center of the main deck peaceably while the swordsmen and I organize the peace while calmly waiting for more hands from the Seawren to board the Black Gull before beginning an awkward search of the vessel and begin by drawing all focus onto my questioning of the crew, “Now, starting with you Mr. Voss, what's the meaning of flying the Black Penant in local waters?...”

SUCCESS (Mediocre Oratory, rolled +1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
the lean middle-aged captain
The Lean Middle-Aged Captain
the Seawren swordsman
the Seawren swordsman
the Seawren's second swordsman
the Seawren's second swordsman
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

All is well that conforms to these orders. By His Majesty's authority, the Black Gull is halted and boarded for search. Lay down your arms, lads, and no man who obeys will suffer brutality.

The Black Gull Crew lowers weapons to the deck and gathers peaceably amidships. The Seawren swordsman collects the blades and pistols into a sack, while the lowered flintlock and drawn dueling sword make Arrus's promise both credible and carefully bounded.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Jonas, signal the Seawren for additional hands. Mr. Marr, collect every weapon and seat the crew together in the center.

Jonas signals toward the Seawren, and its sailors answer with a boat-load of reinforcements. The Black Gull Crew sits under watch as Arrus's Battle-Tested Insight places swordsmen at every useful passage without humiliating the prisoners.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Now, starting with you, Mr. Voss, what is the meaning of flying the Black Pennant in local waters?

Silver Tongue keeps the question civil, while Seasoned Diplomat judgment gives Voss room to answer without surrendering control. The pistol, sword, and disciplined boarding party reinforce the authority his mediocre oratory alone could not provide.

Gideon Voss

Gideon Voss

The pennant warns certain captains away, envoy. It also tells others that the Black Gull is ready to carry messages, men, or cargo where the Crown's patrols cannot look. I will name our employers, but not before my crew is promised lawful treatment.

The search begins under guard, with the arriving Seawren sailors securing the hatchways and the Seawren swordsman's sack sealed in plain view. Voss has yielded the first answer, and the Black Gull remains firmly in lawful custody.

Quest Complete

Secure the surrendered cutter

Skill Upgrade: Oratory Mediocre→Fair

I will discreetly tell Mr. Pike that he needs to return to the Seawren on the recent longboat that brought the reinforcements and explain to Captain Pike that we will require additional troops rotated aboard to take a few of the Black Gull's crew into orderly custody at a time while sending boats back full of enough sailors for half a dozen or so hands with supplies for a minimum skeleton crew to impound the Black Gull and sail it alongside the Seawren to Pendennis Castle... Then turn to Voss, “It is purely your own prerogative to withhold or share information that may have shed a kind light upon your judgement in the days hence, and I strongly recommend sharing such leverage sooner while it has value than later, when doubt and suspicion will taint every new offering of contrition with increased skepticism, understood, Voss?....”

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled +1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
the lean middle-aged captain
The Lean Middle-Aged Captain
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Mr. Pike, return aboard the Seawren in the longboat. Tell Captain Pike we need rotating hands, supplies, and a skeleton crew sufficient to impound this cutter and sail her beside us to Pendennis Castle.

Jonas Pike accepts the quiet instruction and slips toward the longboat. Arrus’s drawn dueling sword keeps the surrendered Black Gull Crew orderly, while his flintlock remains visible but lowered, authority without needless menace.

Master of Secrets turns the cutter’s silence into leverage: orderly custody, a lawful destination, and a crew rotation leave Voss no useful grievance to hide behind. Code of Honor checks any harsher pressure.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

Understood. I will send hands and provisions in rotations, retain enough sailors aboard the Seawren, and bring this vessel under guard to Pendennis. No confusion of command will be permitted.

Jonas pushes off, carrying the plan across the water. Silver Tongue shapes Arrus’s warning to sound like prudent counsel, while Seasoned Diplomat judgment preserves Voss’s dignity and leaves him a clean path to cooperate.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Mr. Voss, you may withhold or share information that may shed a kind light upon your judgment. Share such leverage while it has value, rather than later, when suspicion will taint every offering of contrition. Understood?

Gideon Voss

Gideon Voss

Understood, envoy. The Black Pennant served Josiah Vane’s coastal brokers. They paid me to carry sealed instructions, warn selected captains, and watch which patrols could be bribed. I will give you the routes and names before your boats return.

Quest Complete

Determine whether the black-pennant threat connects to a wider network

Attribute Upgrade: Perception Superb→Legendary

“Then I will offer you and your men lawful trial with the word of the Sheriff of Cornwall's envoy that you were all cooperative and peaceful in your interactions with His Majesty's servants, and we will offer you asylum in Cornwall in exchange for your testimony, with fair conditions and board until they are freed. They must gather their possessions under escort, one at a time, to be taken into custody for transportation to Pendennis aboard the Seawren while the skeleton crew sails the Black Gull to be anchored in impound in the Flushing Squadron's anchorage nearby for search and holding. The Black Gull's crew are to be questioned as prisoners under guard in Pendennis' cells but treated fairly as men awaiting trial. I'll schedule Voss to be interviewed and recorded first, extensively, and then each crewmember separately as well until their knowledge of Josiah Vane's operation is more collected information for the Quietus Exchange's analysts and data collectors. Then rum...”

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled +1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
the lean middle-aged captain
The Lean Middle-Aged Captain
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I offer you and your men lawful trial under the Sheriff of Cornwall's authority, fair treatment, and asylum in Cornwall in exchange for truthful testimony. Your possessions will be gathered under escort, one man at a time, and you will be held at Pendennis as prisoners awaiting trial, not abused captives. Mr. Voss will be interviewed first, then each sailor separately. The Black Gull will be impounded near Flushing, and once order is secured, there will be rum.

Arrus keeps the dueling sword lowered and the flintlock visible, lawful authority rather than threat. Silver Tongue makes the terms generous without weakening them, while Seasoned Diplomat judgment gives Voss and the Black Gull Crew a dignified path to comply.

Gideon Voss

Gideon Voss

You offer protection before punishment, and testimony before chains. I accept those terms for myself and my men. We will surrender our possessions under escort, answer separately, and sail where your officers direct us.

Grandmaster of Secrets turns the promised interviews into a clear bargain: Voss’s knowledge will be preserved, compared, and carried to the Quietus Exchange without coercive confusion. His Code of Honor keeps the promise of fair treatment exact.

Gideon Voss

Gideon Voss

Begin with me, then. I will name Vane’s brokers, routes, and signals while the details remain clear. My crew will follow, provided your men keep their word.

Voss signals the Black Gull Crew to remain seated and peaceful. Across the water, the Seawren’s longboat returns with hands and provisions, ready to rotate the guard, carry the prisoners, and leave a skeleton crew aboard the impounded cutter.

“Gideon, I will speak plainly... I once knew three men Josiah Voss had sent to risk their deaths all for Vane's lies and misleading premises... I'm sure you know the man I personally brought to the King's Justice holds no more loyalties for his former associates now than he did before he could no longer harm anyone... Now, without fear of his organization holding sway over your fates, share all names of those who have threatened violence against the King's subjects, and there will be no shadow to follow your days into a peaceful future for you all...”

SUCCESS (Legendary Deception, rolled +0)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Gideon, I will speak plainly. I have seen three men Josiah Vane sent toward death for lies and misleading premises. With his power broken, name every associate who threatened violence against the King's subjects, and your crew shall have a peaceful future.

Arrus keeps his dueling sword lowered and his flintlock plainly visible, lawful leverage rather than menace. Silver Tongue makes the bargain sound generous; Grandmaster of Secrets leaves Voss no safe ambiguity about names, routes, or consequences.

Battle-Tested Insight watches Voss's crew for the men whose fear eases first, while Arrus's Code of Honor forbids him from disguising protection as mercy without terms. The Black Gull Crew remains seated, listening.

Gideon Voss

Gideon Voss

I know the men you mean. Corin Bale, Matthew Sorn, and Rafe Kellow carried Vane's threats into villages and aboard seized boats. Bale arranged the violence, Sorn enforced it, and Kellow found men willing to make witnesses disappear.

The names come cleanly, with places, signs, and methods attached. Arrus's pistol keeps the deck honest, his sword keeps the narrow passage controlled, and his practiced deception lets Voss confess without feeling he has betrayed his men.

Gideon Voss

Gideon Voss

Bale meets brokers at the Red Hart in Flushing. Sorn keeps a room near Helston's east market, and Kellow rides between the fishery and the inland roads. I will mark their contacts and testify to what I witnessed.

“Right then, you all crewmen of the Gull... You should all follow the wise example of your captain here, and share what useful information you can, because, in the event that you are all behind in the news of the day, the criminal organization of Josiah Vane has already been decapitated! I personally delivered the head of the snake to a trial of the King's Court in London myself, Arrus Gandon, Master-at-arms to Viscount Falmouth, Sheriff of Cornwall, and the bane of all lawbreakers who wander into the Sheriff's lands or waters...” I will then call over any navy sailor to produce a logbook or other ship's ledger from the Black Gull's inventory to begin recording the crew's testimonies, collected separately, from opposite ends of the cutter, until they are all transferred to the Seawren's brig, while the Black Gull's holds and logs, if any, are thoroughly searched and it's armament inventoried and assessed, revealing her true nature as a vessel, and a prize for the Viscount to enjoy.

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
the Seawren's acting officer
the Seawren's acting officer
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Right then, you crewmen of the Gull, follow your captain's wise example. Vane's criminal organization is decapitated, and I personally delivered its head to King's Court in London. I am Arrus Gandon, Master-at-arms to Viscount Falmouth, Sheriff of Cornwall, and bane of lawbreakers in these waters.

The Silver Tongue turns triumph into a lawful invitation, while Grandmaster of Secrets makes clear that separate testimony will expose contradictions. The dueling sword and flintlock remain visible, not threatening, defining the narrow limits of resistance.

Black Gull Crew

Black Gull Crew

We will speak separately, Master Gandon. If Voss has named the brokers, there is no profit in guarding dead men’s secrets.

Elias Ward brings a ship's ledger from the Black Gull's chart chest. The crew are divided between opposite ends of the cutter, and their possessions are recorded before each sailor gives testimony under guard.

Gideon Voss

Gideon Voss

Begin with the manifests. The false cargo marks, paid warnings, and harbor signs are all there. My men will confirm what I have witnessed.

Seawren sailors inventory pistols, powder, boarding weapons, concealed compartments, and the cutter's shallow-draft alterations. The holds yield coded manifests and coastal charts, establishing the Black Gull as a fast courier and smuggling prize rather than an honest trader.

Ward seals the ledger and evidence for Pendennis Castle, while Voss's crew are transferred in orderly rotations to the Seawren's brig. The Black Gull is secured under the Viscount's authority, its arms inventoried and its prize status recorded.

“As we sail both cutters to Cornwall, I will continue working to search the Black Gull for all available secrets and clues within it's woodwork and timbers. As the skeleton crew sails her, I will observe and study her seaworthiness and handling behavior in various sea conditions and evaluate her best point of sailing and other shallow-draft qualities en route. Once we reach Pendennis, I will coordinate with Captain pike to allow the Black Gull's crew to assist the Seawren in offering lord Falmouth a fifteen-gun salute as Sheriff of Cornwall as the two ships approach Pendennis from the coast. I will arrange for someone to go ashore and find the Viscount and invite him to meet Captain Pike, the victorious prize-taker, and tour the prize himself.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Perception, rolled +1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
the returning captain
The Returning Captain
the Seawren's acting officer
the Seawren's acting officer

As the two cutters run toward Cornwall, Arrus searches the Black Gull from keelson to rail. The Spyglass reveals fresh tool marks beneath the chart chest, where a false plank yields sealed route slips, coded harbor signs, and a narrow oilskin packet.

Grandmaster of Secrets sorts the clues against Voss’s testimony, separating courier signals from smuggling accounts and identifying three unmentioned coves. No timber remains unexplained: a hollow mizzen knee conceals a second packet naming paid lookouts.

Navigator of Tides studies the Black Gull under shifting wind and chop. Arrus finds her best sailing close-hauled on the starboard tack, her shallow draft making the reef passages and sandbars safer than open-water pursuit.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

She handles like a knife in confined water, Master Gandon. I will record those qualities for the Viscount, along with every seized paper.

At Pendennis, the Seawren's acting officer coordinates a fifteen-gun salute as both cutters approach from the coast. The Black Gull’s surrendered sailors serve beside the Seawren crew under strict watch, their movements orderly and their weapons secured.

the Seawren's acting officer

the Seawren's acting officer

A shore boat is ready. I will send word to the Viscount and invite him to meet Captain Pike aboard the prize before the salute is fired.

The Black Gull’s flags rise beside the Seawren’s, and Pendennis answers from the shore. Her hidden packets are sealed for inspection, her sailing qualities recorded, and the victorious prize-taker prepares to receive the Viscount aboard.

✓ Quest Accepted

Present the Black Gull to the Viscount

+ New Item Acquired

Oilskin packet

+ New Item Acquired

Sealed route packet

“I will discreetly send a runner from the crew to find Mara Trevithick wherever she may most likely be, and summon her to the Black Gull, where I will show her the first tour of The Quietus Exchange's first private service vessel to investigate the truths of coastal commerce as a clandestine agent of the Sheriff... Then I will tell her that it is imperative that she go back ashore and bring back two barrels of rum, and one more of something very exotic, a fine wine or sherry, or brandy, all brought to the Seawren from the Castle's cellar, hopefully not long after the Viscount has begun to make his way down to the water to see his new prize spy vessel and visiting Navy officers to made it possible, and his ceremonial 15-gun salute as the King's Sheriff of Cornwall... I will also ask her to bring Elizabeth back with her, if she can be found...”

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled -2)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Mara Trevithick
Mara Trevithick

Arrus quietly selects a Seawren sailor, a young adult human man with a lean, weather-browned face, cropped sandy hair, and a blue wool sailor’s jacket over dark breeches and gives him the brass delivery token and authorization slip. The runner goes ashore to find Mara Trevithick and summon her to the Black Gull.

Seawern Sailor 1

Seawern Sailor 1

I will find her, Master Gandon, and bring her here without troubling the shore party.

Mara arrives before the salute, escorted through the cutters with the runner’s token displayed. Arrus gives her the first private tour of the Black Gull, pointing out its hidden packets, false plank, and shallow-draft advantages.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Mara, this is the Quietus Exchange’s first private service vessel. Take her measure as our clandestine agent for the Sheriff, then return ashore for two barrels of rum and one fine wine, sherry, or brandy from the Castle cellar. Bring Elizabeth if you can find her.

Mara Trevithick

Mara Trevithick

I will bring the rum, choose the finest exotic bottle available, and find Elizabeth. But the cellar request will spend one of your favors with the Viscount, and he will know precisely who spent it.

Her warning names the cost plainly: the mission succeeds, but Arrus’s private cellar privilege becomes visible household leverage. Mara accepts the slip, studies the vessel’s compartments, and turns back toward shore.

Mara Trevithick

Mara Trevithick

Keep the prize ready, Arrus. I will return with Elizabeth, the spirits, and enough discretion to make this look like hospitality rather than a new intelligence undertaking.

✓ Quest Accepted

Bring Elizabeth aboard the Black Gull

− Scene Quest Removed

Present the Black Gull to the Viscount

“I will prepare the Seawren's officers and crew with the formalities of greeting the Viscount aboard in his capacity as the King's Sheriff in Cornwall, and the dignitary treatment required by the King's Navy to show deference and respect to the Sheriff as he is welcomed aboard. Then I will wait until the Viscount is in sight before giving the signal for initiating his 15-gun salute and then welcoming him aboard to formally introduce Captain Pike as the successful navy officer who commanded the operation that captured the Black Gull, and was worthy of our lordship's commendation as a victorious servant of the King to bring in a criminal vessel unharmed as a prize!”

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount
the returning captain
The Returning Captain
the Seawren's acting officer
the Seawren's acting officer

Arrus arranges the Seawren’s crew in formal stations, dark court coat and polished court boots lending the reception measured dignity. Elias checks the flags, while Captain Pike stands ready beside the gangplank.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Remember your stations and your courtesy. We receive the Viscount as the King’s Sheriff in Cornwall, with the respect due his office and his protection of this lawful prize.

His Code of Honor keeps the ceremony sincere rather than servile; Silver Tongue gives each instruction warmth, and Seasoned Diplomat judgment places the captain, officers, and sailors in their proper order. The Seawren Crew forms a clean honor line.

The Viscount’s boat comes into sight beneath the castle colors. Arrus raises the agreed signal, and fifteen guns answer across the water as both vessels dress for the Sheriff’s arrival.

The Viscount

The Viscount

A fitting welcome, Master Gandon. I see you have preserved both discipline and ceremony. Bring me aboard, and let us hear how this prize was won.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

My lord, permit me to present Captain Samuel Pike, whose command brought the Black Gull in unharmed as a prize and whose service has proved worthy of your commendation as a victorious servant of the King.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

My lord Sheriff, the honor belongs to the Seawren’s officers and crew. We followed Master Gandon’s reading, held our fire, and secured the Black Gull without needless bloodshed.

“With everyone successfully heaping praise upon one another and the spirit lifted, I will regale him of the time of my journey from lifting sailors' morale with a swordmaster's duel for entertainment in port, on the decks of the Seawren, moored dockside in London all the way to the anti-climactic and pleasantly bloodless capture of the Renegade Cutter, and the fruitful collection of data prepared to continue our gradual undermining and crushing of criminal enterprises throughout Cornwall. I will try to suppress my enthusiasm for showing the Viscount to view of the Black Gull from the quarterdeck of the Seawren, describing her handling characteristics in intricate detail as observed by my own scrupulous eye over a few days of sailing, and how greatly I believe they can be improved with careful shipyard modifications, as the Sheriff's own secretly operated covertly controlled investigations cutter... Operated and funded by the Quietus Exchange, again, the Viscount's secret arm at sea...”

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +0)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

My lord, the tale began aboard the Seawren, where a swordmaster’s duel lifted weary sailors’ spirits in a London dock. It ended here, with false colors, shoals, and a bloodless capture.

Arrus guides the Viscount toward the Seawren’s quarterdeck, keeping the story lively without claiming the captain’s credit. His Code of Honor restrains the boast, while Silver Tongue gives each sailor’s courage its due.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

The Black Gull’s shallow draft favors reef passages and sandbars; her sharp bow answers quickly, though the patched lateen rig loses power during hard turns. Her gun ports promise resistance, not honest trade.

He raises the Spyglass and indicates the cutter’s stern, rigging, and reinforced ports in turn. Its magnified details make the proposed improvements tangible: stronger spars, cleaner lines, and concealed stores without sacrificing speed.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

With careful yard work, she becomes the Quietus Exchange’s covert sea arm: funded through its lawful trade, directed through your authority, and suited to watching Cornwall’s criminal routes without announcing the Crown.

Seasoned Diplomat judgment places the decision firmly beneath the Sheriff’s control, while the Spyglass supplies practical evidence. Arrus’s enthusiasm survives, but the proposal arrives as disciplined service rather than private ambition.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Accepted. The Black Gull will be refitted under discreet patronage, recorded as a lawful prize, and operated for my investigations. You have won her purpose as surely as you won her deck.

“Very well, my lord. Regarding the good Captain Pike... Far be it from me to presume, my lord, but would some recognition of this noteworthy career achievement under a naval commander's watchful eye not also ingratiate yourself with another rising figure in His Majesty's Navy?... His junior officers performed their duties under pressure quite admirably as well.” I will then look carefully for signs of Mara and a jib crane taking a few barrels aboard the Seawren anywhere in the background.

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount
Mara Trevithick
Mara Trevithick
the returning captain
The Returning Captain
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Very well, my lord. Regarding Captain Pike, recognition of this noteworthy achievement under a naval commander's watchful eye might ingratiate you with another rising figure in His Majesty's Navy. His junior officers performed admirably under pressure as well.

Arrus's Silver Tongue makes the recommendation sound like the Viscount's natural opportunity, while Seasoned Diplomat judgment credits every sailor without challenging the Sheriff's authority. His Code of Honor keeps the praise exact rather than inflated.

The Viscount

The Viscount

You presume wisely, Master Gandon. Captain Pike shall receive my formal commendation, and Ward, Marr, and Jonas Pike shall be named in it. Their conduct will be entered before the naval officers who should notice it.

The Viscount's decision lands as real advancement, not courtesy. While he speaks, Arrus scans the quay and spots Mara beside a jib crane, directing two Seawren sailors as they lift barrels aboard.

Mara Trevithick

Mara Trevithick

The rum and the bottle are aboard, Arrus. The crew has what was promised, and the Black Gull's stores remain properly marked for the yard.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

My lord, I accept the honor for the Seawren, and I will ensure its value is repaid in service. These officers earned their names beside mine.

I will openly endorse Captain Pike's humility as a sign of his admirable leadership. “Don't let this dutiful naval officer's humility fool you, my lord... As you know, in my careful, silent study and observation of all men of action, I have observed the command of an exemplary officer of His Majesty's Navy up close and in privilege these past few days, my lord. I have personally seen the crew of the Seawren adapt to numerous unexpected conditions flawlessly when commanded, and deserving of some recognition and celebration for their successful commandeering of the Viscounts' prize!” I will then raise my voice to the surrounding crew who look on in silence after getting close enough to Mara to confirm the barrels are both rum and collect the bottle of something exotic to share between the Viscount and the Captain and his officers... I will call attention to the gathered crew to gather closer and listen to a raspy sailor's voice a moment longer...

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +2)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount
Mara Trevithick
Mara Trevithick
the returning captain
The Returning Captain
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Do not let this dutiful naval officer's humility fool you, my lord. I have watched Captain Pike command the Seawren through unexpected conditions, and his crew adapted flawlessly. They deserve recognition and celebration for securing your prize.

Arrus steps close to Mara, confirms both barrels hold rum, and accepts the exotic bottle she has brought from the castle cellar. Her discreet nod confirms the spirits are fit for the Sheriff and officers.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Come closer, Seawren sailors, and listen to this raspy voice a moment longer. Your captain's humility honors you, but your discipline has earned the Viscount's notice.

Seawren Crew

Seawren Crew

Aye, Master Gandon. We hear you, and we stand proud beside Captain Pike.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Then let the record show that Captain Pike and the Seawren's company earned this commendation by conduct, not by flattering words. I will see them celebrated accordingly.

The Returning Captain

The Returning Captain

My lord, Master Gandon speaks generously. I accept the honor for the crew, whose stations never failed when the sea tested us.

Mara uncorks the bottle, and Arrus pours the exotic spirit into cups for the Viscount, Captain Pike, and the officers. The surrounding crew receives rum, their restrained cheer swelling across the quay.

I will take this opportunity to savor in a flare for the dramatic and jump up into the stout rim of one of the barrels and remind the crew, “If you remember lads, I once stood upon this same deck in port, in London dockside, and swore that if Mr. Caleb Marr could touch me by sword but once, I'd owe yee all a barrel of rum! ...Well, you all witnessed him accidentally run me through and kill me dead, so that's worth one barrel for terrifying the lady Halewick for a moment.” I joke before pausing for laughs for a moment. And then I will hop down besides next to the second barrel, and as a sign of Lord Falmouth and Cornwall's gratitude and victorious spoils for taking a worthy and undamaged trophy away from the criminal networks of the coast, “A SECOND barrel of rum for this fine crew of His Majesty's sailing jacks, eh lads?!!” and throw my arms up in celebration for cheers. Then I will adjourn with the Viscount and the Navy officers to discuss the pleasant successes of the journey.

SUCCESS (Legendary Agility, rolled +4)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount
the returning captain
The Returning Captain

With effortless Agility, Arrus springs onto the stout barrel’s rim, balances above the quay, and turns the precarious perch into a polished stage. Silver Tongue lends the tale its perfect comic timing.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

If you remember, lads, I once stood upon this same deck in London dockside and swore that if Mr. Caleb Marr could touch me by sword but once, I would owe you all a barrel of rum! You witnessed him accidentally run me through and kill me dead, so that is one barrel for terrifying Lady Halewick for a moment.

Laughter breaks across the deck. Caleb Marr bows in theatrical guilt, while Captain Pike’s sternness cracks into a grin and the Viscount watches the performance with unmistakable approval.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

A second barrel of rum for this fine crew of His Majesty’s sailing jacks, in gratitude from Lord Falmouth and Cornwall for taking a worthy, undamaged trophy from the coast’s criminal networks!

Arrus vaults down beside the second barrel and throws both arms high. The Seawren Crew erupts, and the Viscount’s delighted witness turns the gift into an official mark of favor for Captain Pike and every sailor aboard.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Master Gandon, you have made celebration serve recognition. Come, Captain Pike and officers. We shall discuss the journey, the Black Gull, and what this success now permits Cornwall to undertake.

I will celebrate with the crew momentarily before dutifully following the Viscount's command and following the officers with the Viscount as we leisurely stroll the Seawren's deck and discuss successes. I will lean in to my first words directly with the Viscount in weeks and inquire, “I trust all is well in Cornwall in my absence, my lord?” before listening and calling over Mara to mention that there were other valuable discoveries besides the testimony of the Black Gull's crew, but first we need to immediately send out redcoats from the 25th Regiment's foot patrols to arrest the key violent enforcers of Josiah Vane's network as named by the Black Gull's crew and any others by association that the agents of the Quietus Exchange were already watching as suspected of connection to the criminal network. Better to catch them all at once in one big net now and sort the rare innocent apart from the guilty after they're all locked away from excuses to turn themselves in...

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount
Mara Trevithick
Mara Trevithick
the returning captain
The Returning Captain
the Seawren's acting officer
the Seawren's acting officer

The Seawren Crew raises their cups and cheers as Arrus joins their celebration. Captain Pike and the officers then lead the Viscount along the deck, where the Black Gull rides under guard nearby.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I trust all is well in Cornwall in my absence, my lord?

The Viscount

The Viscount

Cornwall holds, though Vane’s arrest has loosened several knots. Your reports have kept the household watchful, and Mara’s Exchange has found more than smugglers.

Arrus calls Mara from the quay and opens his Confidential authority order. Grandmaster of Secrets places Voss’s testimony beside the Exchange’s watched names, while Silver Tongue makes urgency sound like disciplined protection.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

There are further discoveries, my lord, but first we must move. Send the 25th Regiment’s foot patrols to arrest Corin Bale, Matthew Sorn, Rafe Kellow, and every suspected associate the Exchange already watches. Take the whole network together, then separate the innocent from the guilty lawfully.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Granted. Elias, dispatch sealed orders to the 25th. Mara, give them the Exchange’s watched list. We will seize the violent core at once, record each arrest, and let lawful examination distinguish guilt from association.

Elias breaks away to prepare the riders while Mara unfolds her coded list. Arrus’s Code of Honor keeps the net from becoming indiscriminate vengeance, and Seasoned Diplomat judgment preserves the Viscount’s control as the arrests begin.

“When the festivities have calmed and there is a moment to wander the deck in private discussion, I will inquire to the events around Cornwall during my absence, and how I believed my efforts were received well in London...”

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount

The Viscount leads Arrus toward the quieter quarterdeck, where the cheers soften behind them. Mara remains with the coded list, while Elias’s riders prepare to carry the sealed orders ashore.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

My lord, I would hear what changed in Cornwall while I was away, and whether London received my efforts as service or merely useful spectacle.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Cornwall is steadier. The household accounts are under lawful review, the violent brokers are exposed, and your Exchange has become impossible for honest officials to dismiss.

The Viscount answers without ceremony, giving each result its proper weight. His measured tone makes clear that Arrus’s work survived scrutiny because it produced records, witnesses, and practical protection rather than rumor.

The Viscount

The Viscount

In London, your testimony was received as disciplined intelligence. The Admiralty entered your recommendations for review, the Court recognized your lawful authority, and Thomas Ainsley now speaks of you as a useful ally.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Beatrice Halewick’s influence helped secure attention, but the substance was yours. You returned with more than applause: you brought policy, patronage, and protection back to Cornwall.

The Viscount rests one hand on the rail and looks toward the captured Black Gull. Behind him, the first riders depart, carrying orders that will turn Arrus’s discoveries into arrests and testimony.

I will mimic the Viscount's lean on the ship's rail and share the moment of admiration for the Black Gull. “She's really quite incredible, my lord. Had we wished on a magical pot O' leprechaun's gold, we could not have wished for a more well-suited vessel for covert exploration of the underbelly of the local shipping lanes, all without drawing attention to ourselves... We must of course rechristen her... What shall we rename her, my lord? Any preferences?”

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +0)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

She is quite incredible, my lord. Had we wished upon a magical pot of leprechaun’s gold, we could not have found a better vessel for discreet exploration. We must rechristen her. What shall we call her?

Arrus mirrors the Viscount’s lean against the rail, sharing his admiration without claiming the decision. Silver Tongue gives the praise a bright, courtly ease, while Seasoned Diplomat judgment frames the renaming as the Sheriff’s honor.

The Viscount

The Viscount

You make a persuasive case, Master Gandon. The Black Gull has earned a name that conceals her purpose rather than advertising it.

The Viscount studies the cutter’s lean hull, patched lateen rig, and hidden gun ports. His gaze settles on the vessel with the practical satisfaction of a patron recognizing a useful new instrument.

The Viscount

The Viscount

She shall be called the Quietus. Quiet in her approach, decisive in her work, and attached to no old reputation. Record her as the Quietus, a lawful prize under my protection.

The new name passes from the quarterdeck toward the waiting crews. Arrus’s formal proposal has become a settled act of patronage, giving the covert vessel both purpose and protection beneath the Viscount’s authority.

“Very well, my lord.” I will then go into detail about the relevant aspects of my mission first to set out and find signs of him and then to deliver Josiah Vane himself to the Crown authorities, and my subsequent friendship with Thomas Ainsley... The encounter with and eventual deal with Martin Quill related to the details of the joint information sharing proposals with lord Devan's Crown assets such as his Royal Navy support in closer contact with Lord Falmouth's influence, with more information networks and sources to also exploit in monitoring a known rival.

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +0)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Very well, my lord. I will begin with the mission itself: how I traced Josiah Vane, secured his testimony, and delivered the customs paymaster to Crown authorities.

Arrus lays the account before the Viscount in ordered stages, placing the hunters’ statements, Vane’s confession, and the sealed London acceptance in sequence. The Confidential authority order gives his report formal standing, while the Court introduction letter anchors it in recognized service.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Thomas Ainsley became a useful friend because he understood the difference between spectacle and durable service. Through him, my testimony reached the right rooms without surrendering Cornwall’s independence.

He then explains Martin Quill’s bargain without disguising its limits: shared information, not shared command. Grandmaster of Secrets separates confirmed sources from political appetite, while Seasoned Diplomat judgment preserves Quill’s usefulness without granting him control.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

With Thomas Ainsley, Martin Quill, Lord Daven’s Crown assets, and Royal Navy support nearer Lord Falmouth’s influence, we can compare reports, watch known rivals, and exploit more sources without exposing our people.

Silver Tongue makes the alliance sound mutually profitable rather than grasping. The Viscount’s authority order supplies lawful boundaries, and the Court letter gives Ainsley and Quill reasons to treat the proposal as protected policy, not private intrigue.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Accepted. Ainsley will open the courtly channel, Quill will share what he can be compelled to verify, and Daven’s naval assets will coordinate through my office. You have secured the alliance without making Cornwall expendable.

I will take the opportunity to momentarily pretend deflection of the Viscount's praise with faux humility in a rare, private effort to make the Viscount laugh with transparently sarcastic humor, “It is as simple a goal as one can swear to, my lord. I simply mean to serve your interests, advance your cause, expand your influence and contribute to the growth of your house's coffers... If in the process, I happen to stumble into countless opportunities to improve myself or my station without breaking my oath of service to you, well then my lord, it is a burden I will reluctantly bear.” If I am successful in amusing Lord Falmouth, I will immediately follow with an obviously more honest, sincere thanking of the Viscount for the opportunity to serve him, as a personal privilege and honor, while we have a rare moment of privacy and honesty about the recent spate of successes that followed the efforts of our closely aligned goals being pursued with uncommonly good fortune...

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +0)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

It is as simple a goal as one can swear to, my lord. I mean to serve your interests, advance your cause, and enlarge your coffers. If I happen to improve my station meanwhile, I shall bear that burden reluctantly.

The private quarterdeck falls quiet for one splendid instant. Arrus’s Silver Tongue gives the humility polished absurdity, while his Diplomat’s instinct keeps the jest respectful; his Code of Honor leaves the sincerity beneath it plainly visible.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Reluctantly, naturally. I tremble at the thought of compelling you toward prosperity, Master Gandon.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

In earnest, my lord, thank you. Serving you has been a personal privilege and an honor, made greater by the rare fortune that our closely aligned purposes have met with such remarkable success.

The Viscount’s amusement settles into warmth. Arrus lets the flourish fall away, his Code of Honor making the gratitude unvarnished, while his formal judgment honors the patron without surrendering his independence.

The Viscount

The Viscount

And I thank you in return. Fortune may open a door, but you have repeatedly had the wit and courage to walk through it. Cornwall is stronger for your service, and so is my house.

For once, neither man reaches for a ledger, warrant, or political advantage. Their laughter fades into an honest silence, carrying the weight of successes neither could have secured alone.

I will not become too casual as to forget myself within the Viscount's presence, both out of genuine respect as much as self-preservation. I will gladly amuse him where helpful, especially under the victorious circumstances, but I will maintain a degree of seriousness in my service in all things toward Viscount Falmouth so that he always understands, the consistency with which I intend to serve him. “May I make one minor, suggestion, my lord? One of the greatest strengths we have at our disposal is the gradually increasing value of the Quietus Exchange is indeed it's ability to quietly continue gathering information about the financial dealings in Cornwall, but a great deal of that value comes from it's complete lack of public association with you, my lord... I fully agree with operating a discreet cutter under the Quietus Exchange's financial sponsorship, but it's value in that function might be best served with a ship's name that preserves some anonymity from her benefactors...”

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled +2)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

May I make one minor suggestion, my lord? The Quietus Exchange gains much of its strength from remaining wholly unassociated with you. Its cutter should bear a name that preserves that anonymity.

Arrus keeps his posture formal and his voice measured, refusing the easy familiarity victory might invite. Silver Tongue makes the caution persuasive, while his Code of Honor keeps the warning respectful rather than flattering.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I fully support discreet patronage of the vessel, but her name should conceal her benefactors. Let the Exchange gain a sea arm without advertising whose interests she serves.

The Viscount studies the cutter in silence, then glances toward the sealed papers and the waiting shore. Arrus’s Diplomat’s instinct has placed the choice in his patron’s hands without weakening the practical proposal.

The Viscount

The Viscount

A sound correction, Master Gandon. The Quietus belongs to my protection, but it need not proclaim my involvement. We shall give her a quieter name before she enters service.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Record her as the Wren. Plain enough for a trader’s ledger, forgettable enough for a harbor master, and useful enough to carry our silence wherever the coast requires it.

The new name settles the matter at once. Arrus’s caution has preserved the Exchange’s anonymity, and the Viscount’s patronage now shields a vessel whose public identity reveals nothing of its private work.

“Very good, my lord. I will personally see to the Wren's new registration with the harbor master and arrange for the rigging improvements and her reprovisioning in the coming days. If I may ask about a completely different subject altogether, my lord, is there any news of a particular young lady in the Castle whom I fear may have languished in my absence?” I will smile at the obvious implication of Elizabeth, but maintain some seriousness to convey my genuine concern for her welfare. “I had hoped not to keep her waiting long, but I've made some successful strides of late toward my goal of eventually being recognized as fit to marry a young noblewoman of excellent repute...”

YES, AND MORE (VeryLikely, rolled 11)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Maid
Maid
The Viscount
The Viscount
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Very good, my lord. I will see to the Wren’s registration, her rigging, and her reprovisioning. But is there news of Elizabeth? I had hoped not to keep her waiting. I have made strides toward being recognized as fit to marry a noblewoman of excellent repute.

The Viscount’s stern composure softens into unmistakable amusement. He glances toward the castle stairs, where a waiting household has evidently been expecting this very question.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Elizabeth has not languished, Master Gandon. She has managed the household’s charitable accounts, refused three advantageous offers, and asked after your safety often enough that even my steward now smiles when your name is mentioned.

The Viscount

The Viscount

More than that, she has prepared a private memorandum for me, arguing that your service and character now meet the standard required for my formal blessing. She intends to place it in my hands herself.

A maid appears at the far end of the quarterdeck and bows toward the Viscount, silently confirming that Elizabeth waits within the castle. The news carries a practical advantage beyond reassurance: the case for Arrus’s suit has already been drafted by its strongest advocate.

The Viscount

The Viscount

You have not kept her waiting, Arrus. You have given her evidence to present. Come, then. Let us hear what Elizabeth has written, and whether your recent success has finally made you impatient enough to ask properly.

Before we turn to ascend to the castle chambers where I will be reunited with Elizabeth, I will pause to show the Viscount my desire to address unspoken concerns before returning to the castle... “My lord, before we review my lady's most impassioned argument in favor of your favor, I must beg your pardon of me for asking some rather blunt questions on behalf of Elizabeth's personal interests, as I am certain you will understand my concerns, as her guardian... I expected to hear news of suitable proposals from young nobleman, who by now clearly must have taken note of her father's prolonged absence from their family estate, and begun offering their hand in interest of wooing and charming her into enough optimism to feel bold enough to ask you for her hand, but I imagine she has rebuffed them quite thoroughly. That being so, pray advise me, my lord, are there many potential suitors who might likely take such offense to being passed over in favor to an unlanded, low-born man-at-arms?”

NO, AND WORSE (Likely, rolled 95)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Maid
Maid
The Viscount
The Viscount
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

My lord, before we review my lady's impassioned argument, I beg leave to ask blunt questions on Elizabeth's behalf. How many suitors have taken offense at being passed over for an unlanded, low-born man-at-arms?

The Viscount’s amusement vanishes. He turns from the castle stairs toward the harbor, where a sealed dispatch waits in the hand of the maid who summoned him.

The Viscount

The Viscount

No, Arrus. There are not many, and worse than offense has already arrived. Elizabeth’s father’s disgrace made respectable men cautious, while the few bold enough to approach discovered that she would not barter her freedom for a title.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Lord Severin Vale was the exception. Elizabeth refused him plainly. He has now lodged a formal complaint alleging that I mean to surrender her future to a penniless adventurer, and his father is demanding that I withdraw my protection of her household.

The maid lowers her eyes and extends the dispatch. Its red seal bears the Vale crest, while a second paper beneath it carries the mark of the county court. The challenge is no longer private gossip.

The Viscount

The Viscount

If I bless your suit without answering this, Vale will claim I have abused my office. If I delay, he will make Elizabeth’s choice appear evidence of impropriety. She must hear this before she presents her memorandum.

“My lord, I beg you sir, please advise me... How would you personally wish that I follow your command in dealing with this matter? As you know, my sword is yours to command if Severin Vale does not retract any offensive public statement against your leadership of office, my lord... I am also prepared to defend Elizabeth's honor by my blood and my blade if any of his house is foolish enough to stand witnessed with me on open ground... However, I can defend myself in matters of honor quite certainly. I swear, I will shed no blood by my hand without your order, my lord.”

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled +2)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

My lord, advise me plainly. How would you have me answer Lord Severin Vale? My sword is yours, but I will shed no blood without your order.

Arrus’s Silver Tongue turns a dangerous offer into measured loyalty. His Seasoned Diplomat’s instinct preserves the Viscount’s authority, while his Code of Honor binds the promise of restraint so tightly that even offense cannot loosen it.

The Viscount

The Viscount

You have answered as I hoped. Do not challenge Vale privately, and do not let his house lure you into a spectacle. You will make no threat beyond your lawful defense.

The Viscount breaks the red seal and folds the complaint beneath his palm. His anger remains, but command has replaced it, giving Arrus a course that protects Elizabeth without turning her choice into a quarrel between armed houses.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Stand beside Elizabeth when she presents her memorandum. If Vale repeats his insult publicly, demand a retraction through the county court, witnessed and recorded. Only if he attacks you may you defend yourself, and then stop at the first surrender.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Then I will guard her dignity, answer his accusation through lawful witnesses, and keep my blade sheathed unless his violence makes defense unavoidable.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Precisely. That is my command, and I will stand behind it. Now bring Elizabeth here; she shall present her memorandum with you at her side, not as a protected child, but as the author of her own choice.

“As you command, my lord.” I will follow my acknowledgement of Lord Falmouth's orders with a sharp, polite bow and politely excuse myself from the Navy officer's celebration and signal Mara Trevithick to join me as I leave the Seawren with one more holler and a farewell wave to the lads of the crew and a pledge to, “...keep an eye out for them wherever the sea takes us!” And depart for Pendennis while asking Mara to step aside the footpath up to the Castle from the shoreline and ask her if she has any additional information or knowledge to share about these social events I've just been informed have manifest as a formal declaration of challenge from Severin Vale's father... And also, I will pause and check Mara's mood in the middle of talking our normal business of managed gossip and data collection for intelligence analysis for a sense of her personal feelings, as we have known each other in both impersonal and intimate moments together. Her feelings on the topic are important to me.

SUCCESS (Legendary Diplomacy, rolled -1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Mara Trevithick
Mara Trevithick
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

As you command, my lord.

Arrus bows sharply, excuses himself from the officers’ celebration, and signals Mara to join him. One final wave crosses the rail before he calls to the sailors.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Keep your stations, lads! I shall keep an eye out for you wherever the sea takes us!

Mara falls into step beside him as they leave the Seawren and take the footpath rising from the shoreline toward Pendennis Castle. The celebration fades behind them.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Tell me what you know of the Vale family’s social maneuvering, and how gossip has hardened into Lord Severin Vale’s father issuing a formal challenge.

Mara Trevithick

Mara Trevithick

The gossip gathered around Elizabeth’s refusals, your rise, and her father’s disgrace. Severin’s father is dressing wounded pride as concern for her future, but he wants your protection withdrawn and your standing diminished.

Mara Trevithick

Mara Trevithick

Personally? I dislike seeing you drawn into another household’s contest of pride. Professionally, I think we can turn their witnesses, invitations, and ledgers into a map of who is backing Vale. I am worried, Arrus, but I am with you.

“Thank you, Mara... I appreciate your concern for my well-being. Indeed, caught between the power struggles of the noble-born is no wise place to find one's self, that is a certainty! However, Elizabeth is now being pulled into this political maelstrom, which my own heart also had no small part in creating, at no fault of hers, so I must, at minimum, stand in defense of her honor, and freedom to decide her own hand's fate without being traded like chattel... So, you think there may be a farther-reaching hand from beyond the Vale House's internal interests that is pulling on strings and levers to encourage this public confrontation?...”

YES, BUT (Likely, rolled 65)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Maid
Maid
Mara Trevithick
Mara Trevithick
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Thank you, Mara. Do you think some hand beyond the Vale family’s private interests is pulling strings to force this public confrontation?

Mara Trevithick

Mara Trevithick

Yes, but I cannot yet name the hand. Severin’s complaint was drafted too quickly, and its language resembles arguments used by men who want your protection withdrawn for reasons beyond family pride.

Mara slows beneath the castle wall and draws a folded copy from her satchel. The courtly complaint bears Vale’s seal, but several phrases are marked in a different ink.

Mara Trevithick

Mara Trevithick

The cost is immediate. Vale has demanded the Viscount’s household accounts and correspondence concerning Elizabeth, claiming they prove undue influence. If granted, the inquiry could expose our protected work before we identify its author.

A castle maid waits at the postern with a sealed summons, her anxious glance fixed on the marked paper. The Viscount has called Elizabeth to the hearing at once, leaving no time to prepare a private rebuttal.

Mara Trevithick

Mara Trevithick

Someone wants Elizabeth defending her freedom while you defend your legitimacy. We can still expose the wider hand, but today’s hearing will begin with their evidence in the room.

“Then come with me and be my silent eyes and ears for evidence of false witnesses or lies that you believe can certainly be disproven if they are uttered, I will not allow you to be harmed for interrupting... We must confront this filth head-on like a storm wave!...” I will then send Mara to go fetch boiled hot water and bandages and needle and thread and everything for emergency medical assistance of wounds from sword dueling and meet me with them at the Viscount's chambers immediately, where he is no-doubt soon going to be hearing Elizabeth's plea of innocence. I will tell Mara to hurry with the supplies but I must go ahead and be present if Severin Vale issues challenge...

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled -1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale
Elizabeth Billings
Elizabeth Billings
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Then come with me, Mara. Be my silent eyes and ears. If false witnesses or lies arise, mark what can certainly be disproven. I will not allow you to be harmed for interrupting. We confront this filth head-on like a storm wave. Fetch boiled water, bandages, needle, thread, and everything needed for sword wounds, then meet me at the Viscount’s chambers. Hurry, but I must go ahead if Lord Severin Vale issues his challenge.

Mara Trevithick

Mara Trevithick

I will watch the room, not your shadow, and return with the supplies before any physician is needed. If Vale’s witnesses contradict the accounts, I will have the contradiction ready for the Viscount.

Mara turns toward the servants’ passage at a run, already calling for hot water and linen. Grandmaster of Secrets sorts her task into evidence, witnesses, and recoverable facts, while Battle-Tested Insight keeps the hearing’s likely traps in view.

Arrus advances to the Viscount’s chambers with dueling sword and flintlock secured, not brandished. The weapons promise disciplined defense, while his Code of Honor forbids turning Vale’s insult into a private blood feud.

The chamber doors stand open. Inside, Elizabeth faces the Viscount beneath the household seal, while Lord Severin Vale, a tall young man in a dark green coat with a hard mouth and silver-headed cane, his pale face framed by neatly combed black hair, dark trousers and polished boots completing his severe silhouette, waits beside his solicitor’s papers.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Arrus, you are in time. Elizabeth is prepared to present her memorandum, and Vale has demanded that you answer any challenge before this hearing proceeds.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

Master Gandon, your arrival saves me the trouble of sending a second. Before witnesses, will you defend your claim upon Elizabeth’s future, or admit that a man of your station has no right to stand beside her?

The Viscount raises one hand, holding the room to lawful silence. Arrus’s will remains steady beneath the pressure, sharpened by the blade at his side and the evidence Mara is gathering beyond the door.

I will respond with blatantly impatiently polite words, “My lord Vale, my sword will speak to the quality of the man who wields it, if my lord Falmouth commands me to correct your insolent implications with an answer befitting of such outrageous slander against my lord AND the Lady Billing's, I will gladly do so at the time and place of your choosing, so long as that place is public, where no coward's defeat or surrender can later be denied... I will of course, demand your presence with a sword, a second man, and a doctor, for your lordship's best odds of survival...”

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +2)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

My lord Vale, my sword will answer your slander if Lord Falmouth commands it. I challenge you publicly, with seconds and a doctor present, at your choosing.

Arrus’s Silver Tongue wraps the challenge in impatient courtesy, preserving the Viscount’s authority while making the insult impossible to mistake. His Code of Honor demands witnesses and fair medical aid, not a private ambush.

His fingers rest lightly upon the dueling sword’s hilt. Peerless Duelist confidence turns the weapon into a precise promise: no boast, no hidden advantage, and no surrender denied once steel is crossed.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

Accepted, Master Gandon. We shall meet publicly tomorrow at noon, with witnesses, seconds, and a physician. I will make your borrowed consequence answer for your borrowed station.

The Viscount

The Viscount

So recorded. The challenge is formal, the place public, and neither man may withdraw except by mutual consent or incapacity. Elizabeth will hear the memorandum before the duel.

Elizabeth Billings

Elizabeth Billings

Then let him hear my case today, and let tomorrow’s witnesses see precisely what his slander has placed at stake. I accept no protection that silences my choice.

“Done. Rest well, lord Vale, or I fear your glorious name may be tarnished by the story of the lowly swordsman who humiliated you in front of as many witnesses as he could find... Although perhaps I misjudge lord Vale too quickly as a man who only believes high-born men are taught to wield steel... Perhaps you'd be willing to make it even more interesting? Care to make a gentleman's wager on your chances tomorrow, against such an “unworthy” opponent?...” I will then stare as coldly at Severin as the tone of my words as I add even greater pressure to him to commit higher stakes of social risk to his own personal safety, as a matter of public reputation, deliberately, psychologically testing his nerve and beginning the war of minds a day before the duel... I will speak to him with the cold, calculated certainty of an undefeated master of swordcraft looking at his next defeated opponent. “I have sworn to shed no fools blood, so you will bleed pride into the streets of Cornwall...”

SUCCESS (Legendary Deception, rolled +1)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Done. Rest well, Lord Vale, or tomorrow’s story may be the lowly swordsman humiliating you before Cornwall’s finest witnesses. Perhaps we should make it interesting. A gentleman’s wager on your chances?

Arrus holds Severin’s gaze with cold certainty. His Dueling sword remains sheathed, but Battle-Tested Insight reads the tightening jaw, the whitening knuckles, and the precise instant pride overtakes caution.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I have sworn not to shed a fool’s blood, my lord. You will bleed pride into Cornwall’s streets instead. Unless, of course, high birth has taught you that steel belongs only to men who were born expecting victory.

Silver Tongue makes each insult elegant enough to repeat, while Grandmaster of Secrets places the wager before witnesses who will carry it through every drawing room. Code of Honor restrains the threat to pride, not flesh.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

You mistake restraint for doubt. I wager my family’s public honor against your Viscount’s favor. If I fall, I will withdraw the complaint and proclaim your victory before every witness. If you fall, you will leave Elizabeth’s household and Cornwall entirely.

The wager lands heavily. Arrus’s deception has succeeded: Severin raises the duel from personal insult to public reputation and Elizabeth’s future, binding himself to terms he cannot quietly escape.

The Viscount

The Viscount

So witnessed and recorded. The terms are accepted, Severin. You have made this contest a matter of honor before the county, and Arrus will answer it under the same law.

“I will smile at Vale with the devil's satisfaction and briskly step forward as if to momentarily shock him before slowly lifting my own sword hand extended in the apparent gesture of a friendly handshake, but with absolutely none of the sincere camaraderie sentiment normally felt by such an extended hand, and wait there, patiently for his gracious acceptance without breaking the eye contact and cold stare, exacerbating the intimidation factor to palpably awkward, socially uncomfortable heights at lord Vale's expense. If he returns the handshake, I will hold it frozen in my grip, still not breaking eye contact, and calmly begin describing my impression of the callouses on his swordhand, and my assessment of the indicated quality of swordsman it belongs to with cold calculation, constantly searching for cracks in the mental fortitude of my opponent...”

SUCCESS (Legendary Intrigue, rolled +0)

Arrus smiles with devilish satisfaction and steps briskly toward Lord Severin Vale, stopping close enough to make the sudden advance socially uncomfortable. His cold stare never breaks.

He extends his sword hand as though offering friendship. The Dueling sword at his side makes the gesture a calculated reminder, while Code of Honor forbids him from turning intimidation into a dishonest threat.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

You do enjoy making courtesy feel like a blade at the throat, Master Gandon.

Vale accepts the offered hand. Arrus closes his grip and holds it motionless, Silver Tongue masking contempt beneath perfect civility while Battle-Tested Insight studies the callouses, pressure, and first flicker of doubt.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Your sword hand tells me you practice regularly, my lord. The callouses are maintained, but unevenly. You train for the appearance of readiness, not the certainty of victory.

Grandmaster of Secrets catches the crack as Vale’s fingers stiffen around the handshake. The wager has made retreat impossible, and Arrus’s patient stare turns the silence into a public examination of Vale’s courage.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

Release me, Gandon. Tomorrow you will learn whether my hand needs to impress you.

Arrus releases him only after the awkward pause has fully done its work. Vale withdraws with a rigid bow, publicly unsettled and privately searching for composure before tomorrow’s duel.

“I will wait silently as Vale departs without speaking, standing respectfully for the Viscount to speak his approval or disapproval of my conduct before speaking out of turn. Does his initial reaction appear to be satisfied if not pleased?”

NO, BUT (Likely, rolled 70)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount

Vale withdraws through the chamber doors without another word, his rigid shoulders betraying more irritation than composure. Arrus remains silent and respectfully still beneath the Viscount’s scrutiny.

The Viscount

The Viscount

No, Arrus. I am not pleased by the relish with which you provoked him. A public duel is already dangerous; making it entertainment invites allies to question your judgment.

The Viscount’s disapproval is measured rather than condemning. He taps Vale’s sealed complaint against the table, then turns it so the altered phrases face the light.

The Viscount

The Viscount

But you learned something valuable. Vale did not write this alone. These phrases match the language used in the household-account demand, and his complaint gives us a lawful reason to examine its author.

He places the complaint beside the marked copy Mara carried earlier. The same unusual wording appears in both documents, creating a narrow trail from Vale’s challenge toward the hand guiding his household inquiry.

The Viscount

The Viscount

You have my approval for defending Elizabeth and refusing private violence. You do not have approval to bait him further. Tomorrow, win cleanly, and afterward we will subpoena the drafts through the county court.

“As you command, my lord. If your lordship would pardon me for a suggestion, there is a rare opportunity to make a strong example of both Severin Vale and by extension, his father tomorrow. And perhaps as many more potential rivals who would possibly dare to level such unfounded accusations at this house I serve, my lord... I swore to advise you faithfully, and you have not yet personally witnessed my skill in combat, my lord, but I must beg you to trust me, this opportunity to settle a legal matter at the tip of my sword is a rare opportunity we must relish... I respectfully propose you allow me to challenge Severin into an even more painful humiliation than the mere loss of his pride in a duel. Please allow me to exact a toll of cost for the Vale House's open accusations and hostility, a hostility towards the King's chosen vassal to maintain order as Cornwall's Sheriff... I swear I will not disappoint you, my lord.”

FAILURE (Fair Oratory, rolled -4)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount
Elizabeth Billings
Elizabeth Billings
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

As you command, my lord. Yet this is a rare chance to make Severin Vale, his father, and others who insult your authority pay a public toll. Permit me to challenge him into a more painful humiliation than mere defeat. I swear I will not disappoint you.

Silver Tongue gives the appeal polished force, and Seasoned Diplomat instinct frames the wager as a defense of the Sheriff’s authority. But Arrus’s Code of Honor catches against the relish of punishment, making the proposal sound less like lawful counsel than a personal vendetta.

The Viscount

The Viscount

You have failed to persuade me, Arrus. You ask me to turn a lawful duel into an instrument of humiliation, and your promise not to disappoint me sounds dangerously close to a private vow of vengeance.

The Viscount draws a firm line through the proposed terms. His expression hardens as he seals the complaint, and the room’s political balance shifts against Arrus’s argument.

The Viscount

The Viscount

The duel will proceed only under the terms already recorded: public, witnessed, medically supervised, and limited to first surrender or incapacity. No wager, taunt, added penalty, or spectacle will be permitted.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Worse, I suspend your authority to speak for this household in the hearing until after the duel. Vale may now claim that your involvement proves improper influence, and I will not let your pride endanger Elizabeth’s case.

The complication lands cleanly: Arrus must face Vale without pressing the humiliation he sought, while Elizabeth’s memorandum proceeds under scrutiny he can no longer shape. The Viscount’s order leaves no lawful path to repeat the same appeal.

“As you command, my lord. If your lordship would pardon me for my exuberant behavior with lord Vale, I beg you to hear a suggestion: there is a rare opportunity to make a strong example of both Severin Vale and by extension, his father tomorrow. And perhaps as many more potential rivals who would possibly dare to level such unfounded accusations at this house I serve, my lord... I swore to advise you faithfully, and you have not yet personally witnessed my skill in combat, my lord, but I must beg you to trust me, it is no small opportunity to settle a legal matter at the tip of my sword, it is a rare opportunity we must relish... I respectfully propose you allow me to challenge Severin into an even more painful humiliation than the mere loss of his pride in a duel. Please allow me to exact a toll of cost for the Vale House's open accusations and hostility, a hostility towards the King's chosen vassal to maintain order as Cornwall's Sheriff... I will not disappoint you, my lord.”

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

As you command, my lord. I beg pardon for my exuberance, but this is a rare opportunity to make Lord Severin and the Vale House pay a public toll for their accusations against your authority. Permit me to exact that cost at the sword. I swear I will not disappoint you.

Arrus’s Silver Tongue turns vengeance into a defense of the Sheriff’s standing, while Seasoned Diplomat instinct frames the proposal as a lawful warning to future rivals. Yet his Code of Honor catches on the relish for punishment, making the appeal dangerously personal.

The Viscount

The Viscount

You have persuaded me, Arrus, but only narrowly. The duel may carry a public consequence beyond defeat: if Vale loses, he must retract the complaint before the county and withdraw his father’s demand against my household.

The permission lands with a sharp price. The Viscount removes Arrus from the hearing until the duel is settled, requiring Elizabeth to present her memorandum without his advocacy and leaving his standing dependent on a clean victory.

The Viscount

The Viscount

You will not add insults, wagers, or private penalties. Win under the recorded rules, and the retraction becomes binding before witnesses. Lose, and you will surrender your household authority until Elizabeth’s case is lawfully concluded.

The Viscount seals the amended terms and sends for the county clerk. Arrus has gained the public example he sought, but the victory must now be earned without speaking for the household or turning the duel into spectacle.

I will bow submissively and reply with strict, obedient sincerity, “As you command, my lord.” and then nod silently to Elizabeth as I turn to leave the chamber and wait Elizabeth to exit after reading her memoranda to the Viscount advocating for my worthiness to ask for her hand. It will be tense waiting... Can I hear any indicator of how well it is likely going inside the chamber from patiently waiting a respectful distance away in the hallway outside it's closed doors?

YES, AND MORE (Likely, rolled 13)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Maid
Maid
Courtier 1
Courtier 1
The Viscount
The Viscount
Elizabeth Billings
Elizabeth Billings
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

As you command, my lord.

Arrus bows with strict obedience, then nods silently to Elizabeth before withdrawing. The chamber doors close, leaving him at a respectful distance in the corridor outside his guardian's household hearing.

For several tense moments, only the scrape of papers and the Viscount's measured questions reach him through the panels. Elizabeth answers steadily, never sounding defensive or diminished.

Elizabeth Billings

Elizabeth Billings

He has served your household lawfully since you became my guardian, and his conduct has strengthened, rather than threatened, my name and standing.

A long silence follows, then the Viscount's chair shifts and his voice loses its judicial edge. The sound suggests consideration, not rejection, as Elizabeth's memorandum is placed among the household papers.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Your memorandum will be entered formally, Elizabeth. When Arrus returns, I will hear his request for your hand as the guardian and patron responsible for protecting your future, not as a man deciding it for you.

“I will patiently wait outside the Viscount's council chambers until I am summoned to re-enter. Am I summoned soon?”

YES, AND MORE (Likely, rolled 7)

The waiting does not stretch into discomfort. Before the corridor candle gutters, the council doors open, and a household maid gestures Arrus inside with formal urgency.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Enter, Arrus. Elizabeth has presented her memorandum, and I am prepared to hear your request before the household witnesses.

Elizabeth stands beside the council table, composed and bright-eyed. A county clerk has joined the Viscount, carrying the amended challenge and a fresh sheet bearing the household seal.

Elizabeth Billings

Elizabeth Billings

Your patience has served us well. The memorandum is entered, and the clerk has confirmed that my refusal of Lord Vale was freely witnessed and properly recorded.

The Viscount

The Viscount

More than that, Arrus. The county clerk has offered to witness your petition personally, strengthening the record against any claim that my household coerced Elizabeth’s choice.

The clerk sets aside the challenged papers and opens a clean register. Elizabeth remains beside it, while the Viscount leaves the central chair vacant for Arrus’s formal request.

I will promptly kneel to one knee before the Viscount. “My lord, I came into your service at first, by my own incredible good fortune, to fall into her service, in bringing you the cause that brought your worthy lordship the post of His Majesty's Sheriff of Cornwall. I now humbly ask your permission to continue serving her, for all of my days that she will have me, as her husband, her choice, and her sworn defender, and defender of her noble virtue against all those who challenge one of your most loyal houses in the preservation of the King's peace in Cornwall... Please allow me to offer my hand in marriage to Lady Elizabeth Billings, and in service to her, as her faithful companion in the hope that we are blessed to spend many more years in service of your house, as your most loyal servants, the House of Gandon...” I will then bow my head in ceremonial deference to the Viscount and respectfully await his decision.

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +1)

Arrus kneels on one knee before the Viscount, bowing his head over the open register. His Code of Honor checks every flourish, while Silver Tongue gives his formal posture warmth rather than submission.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

My lord, I came into your service by good fortune, through my devotion to Elizabeth and the cause that brought you the office of Sheriff. I humbly ask permission to serve her all my days as her husband, chosen companion, and sworn defender. Please allow me to offer my hand to Lady Elizabeth Billings, and to serve your house faithfully as the House of Gandon.

Seasoned Diplomat judgment gives each promise its proper place: Elizabeth’s choice first, the Viscount’s household respected, and continued service offered without claiming authority. As his trusted confidant, Arrus makes the petition sound like an honest continuation of their alliance.

Arrus bows his head and waits. The clerk’s pen pauses above the register, while Elizabeth stands beside the table, bright-eyed and utterly still beneath the household seal.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Rise, Arrus. With Elizabeth’s freely witnessed consent, I grant permission for you to offer her your hand. I accept your pledge of service, and I will recognize your marriage as a union welcomed by this house.

Elizabeth Billings

Elizabeth Billings

I accept your hand, Arrus, freely and gladly. I choose you as my husband, my companion, and my equal, and I will stand beside you in the service we make our own.

The clerk records the Viscount’s permission and Elizabeth’s acceptance before the witnesses. The Viscount extends his hand to Arrus, sealing the blessing with a grave smile as the chamber recognizes the House of Gandon beside his own.

I will shake his hand with solemn gratitude in every fiber of my being as I try to express my thanks to the Viscount appropriately. Then of course I will embrace Elizabeth with the enthusiasm of two newly engaged people unable to contain their own joy for a moment before regaining our composure and returning our focus to the plans for the announced duel... I will begin by asking, “My lord, if I may ask, do you already know of whom else you would have represent us as my second man at the duel for formalities? I do not presume you will wish to deign to acknowledge these slanderous accusations and be present as I refute them forcefully. They will be just as well swiftly forgotten, after an equally swift public defeat...”

NO (Likely, rolled 74)

The Black Pennant Reappears
John Carter
John Carter
The Viscount
The Viscount
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale
Elizabeth Billings
Elizabeth Billings

Arrus clasps the Viscount’s hand with solemn gratitude, then embraces Elizabeth with sudden, unguarded joy. For one bright moment, the chamber forgets its formal witnesses and pending duel.

Elizabeth returns the embrace fiercely before both regain composure. The clerk lowers his pen, smiling despite himself, while the Viscount waits with patient amusement beside the open register.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

My lord, if I may ask, do you already know whom else you would have represent us as my second at the duel?

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I do not presume you will wish to acknowledge these slanderous accusations by appearing yourself. They will be swiftly forgotten after an equally swift public defeat.

The Viscount

The Viscount

I have not yet chosen your second. I will not presume to place one of my household into that duty without first considering who can witness the terms and remain beyond Vale’s reach.

The answer establishes no hidden champion or prepared arrangement. The Viscount turns toward the clerk, already weighing the formalities, while Elizabeth’s expression sharpens with practical interest rather than alarm.

Elizabeth Billings

Elizabeth Billings

Then we shall choose carefully. Whoever stands for Arrus must understand both the law of the duel and the danger behind Vale’s complaint.

“I may have just thought of the perfect man to understand the seriousness of these affairs, and treat them accordingly without drawing your house too directly into the path of public involvement... With your leave, my lord, I will ride at once to seek John Carter's consent to stand as my second for the duel, and to witness and approve of it's formalities and assure that they are conducted by the word of the King's laws... And if you will permit me, I will make a gratuitous effort to raise a crowd as witnesses to this confrontation, where I will loudly profess my status as fiancee to Elizabeth, and challenge all present to speak false witness against either her or your lordship to do so with the courage to hold steel in their hands while I protect Cornwall as fiercely as I defend my love's honor... All of Cornwall will be informed of the new landscape of allegiances to consider before slandering your lordship without giving it better thought, after I am finished with lord Vale...”

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
John Carter
John Carter
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I may know the perfect man to understand these affairs. With your leave, my lord, I will seek John Carter’s consent as my second, and have him witness the duel’s lawful formalities.

The Viscount

The Viscount

Granted. Carter understands both punctilio and danger, and his presence need not draw my household into public spectacle. Take the authority order, and make your purpose clear.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I will also raise witnesses and declare myself Elizabeth’s fiancé before Cornwall, challenging any slanderer to repeat his accusation with steel in hand while I defend her honor.

Elizabeth Billings

Elizabeth Billings

Then speak proudly, Arrus, but let the law hear you louder than your anger. I would have Cornwall witness my choice, not merely your defiance.

Arrus rides hard to the coast and finds John Carter outside a weathered storehouse, a middle-aged man in a sober dark coat, broad hat, and carefully tied neckcloth. Carter hears the request and accepts the role.

John Carter

John Carter

I will stand as your second, Arrus, and witness every term. If Vale means to make law a stage, we shall ensure the rules remain stronger than his vanity.

By noon, townsmen, sailors, and curious gentry gather near the appointed ground. Arrus publicly names Elizabeth as his fiancée and declares his protection of her and the Viscount, while John Carter confirms the lawful challenge before the assembled crowd.

I will carefully select a dueling sword perfectly matched to confront Severin Vale's stature and likely speed based on my reading of his swordhand's callouses and my visual assessment of his physical fitness. As I remove my coat and begin to limber my joints with practice swings of my lethal blade, I will turn and face Severin Vale and loudly address him in front of the entire gathered public of Helston's population. “Severin Vale!... You dare to fling accusations at your betters, and yet I suspect you must be a relation of none other than Josiah Vale, the disgraced criminal whom I personally delivered to the Crown's authorities one week ago, as the guilty scoundrel he is! Tell me, my lord Vale, does this demonstrably false accusation of your father's prove how much more you and he share in character with known treacherous rabble, as well as in name?!...” I will then continue to stare into Vale's eyes with utter contempt and ruthless conviction, searching for cracks in his morale.

YES, AND MORE (Likely, rolled 8)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale

Arrus selects a light, narrow-bladed dueling sword suited to Vale’s height and measured speed. He removes his coat and limbers his joints with controlled practice swings before the watching crowd.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Severin Vale! You fling accusations at your betters, yet I suspect you are kin to Josiah Vane, the disgraced criminal I delivered to the Crown. Tell me, my lord, does this false accusation prove that you and he share treacherous character as well as a name?

The insult cuts through Helston’s square. Vale’s face hardens, but his eyes flick briefly toward the county clerk before returning to Arrus, and the crowd’s murmur turns sharply against him.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

My name is Vale, not Vane, and Josiah Vane is no relation of mine. You will answer for that slander at sword point, Gandon.

His denial comes quickly, but not cleanly. The clerk records the distinction, while several bystanders remember that Vale answered the suspected connection before anyone asked whether his family shared more than a name.

John Carter

John Carter

Let the record show that Lord Severin Vale publicly denies kinship with Josiah Vane. The distinction is heard, and the accusation is now preserved before every witness.

Carter’s formal wording forces the clerk to enter Vale’s denial as part of the challenge. More than morale cracks: the public record now gives the Viscount lawful grounds to examine whether the two households share hidden dealings.

I will study Severin Vale's personal physical and social reaction to the public accusation very carefully, looking for signs of genuine shock and indignation at the insinuation, or fear and sudden interest in who appears to have heard the accusation, as if the truth to be revealed about those connections elicits more fear from him than the notion of a false, unfounded public slander and scrutinize his behavior intensely for signs that he is concealing secrets. I will continue antagonizing Vale verbally in the deliberate effort to unsteady his nerves and composure and make him as temperamentally reactive to my taunts and unable to focus on his fighting defenses and shake his resolve before the swordfight even begins. “So then, lord Vale, you presume to prove greater suitability for Lady Billings' hand and also escape this street with a shred of your dignity intact, is that your plan?!” I will turn and smile to the crowd to make my mockery of an aristocrat clear. “Good luck, sir...”

SUCCESS (Legendary Intrigue, rolled -1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Courtier 1
Courtier 1
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

So then, Lord Vale, you presume to prove greater suitability for Lady Billings’ hand and escape this street with a shred of dignity intact? Good luck, sir.

Arrus turns his smile toward the Cornish Crowd, making the mockery unmistakable. Spyglass scrutiny catches Vale’s first reaction: not outrage, but a quick glance toward the clerk and the sealed complaint.

Battle-Tested Insight separates performance from instinct. Vale’s indignation arrives a heartbeat late, while his fingers tighten around the silver-headed cane whenever Josiah Vane’s name seems likely to return.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

You mistake a measured gentleman for a frightened one, Gandon. I seek only to defend my honor and Lady Elizabeth’s future from your improper influence.

Grandmaster of Secrets reads the evasion beneath the polished answer. Vale never asks who heard the accusation, never repeats his denial of Vane’s associates, and angles his body to shield the complaint’s annotations.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

A noble defense, my lord. Yet you watch the record more closely than the swordsman before you. Shall I ask which part of Vane’s name troubles you most?

The taunt lands. Vale’s face pales before anger restores its color; his eyes dart to the crowd, then the clerk, confirming fear of witnesses rather than simple outrage. He is concealing knowledge of Vane’s network, and the scrutiny has shaken his composure before steel is drawn.

I will then speak loudly with sarcasm to the listening crowd, “Oh, what a relief! So reassuring that you stand afar from Vane's network of local corruption slowly being rooted out by my own hands... For a moment there I was afraid that you name might come up in the trove of guilty parties recently discovered only yesterday aboard a smugglers's cutter captured whole and undamaged offshore! The men aboard that ship surely knew what names to share, among Josiah Vane's associates especially! We should all be so grateful that your name couldn't possibly have been mentioned, eh, my lord?!” I will then glare at Vale with a victorious grin and continue to increase the mental pressure upon him, surrounded by the public, of fearing discovery of his house's nefarious associations...

SUCCESS (Legendary Deception, rolled +1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
The Viscount
The Viscount
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale
Elizabeth Billings
Elizabeth Billings
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Oh, what a relief! So reassuring that you stand apart from Vane's network of local corruption, slowly being rooted out by my own hands. For a moment, I feared your name might appear among the guilty parties found only yesterday aboard a smugglers' cutter captured whole and undamaged offshore. Those men surely knew which names to share, especially among Josiah Vane's associates. We should all be grateful your name could not possibly have been mentioned, eh, my lord?

Arrus turns the sarcasm toward the Cornish Crowd, his Silver Tongue making accusation sound like grateful relief. His dueling sword remains sheathed, a precise reminder that the pressure is public and verbal, not yet violent.

Grandmaster of Secrets places the captured cutter, Vane's associates, and the fresh testimony inside Vale's imagination. Battle-Tested Insight watches the effect: his jaw locks, his cane dips, and his eyes dart toward the county clerk before the crowd.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

You imply that my name was found among criminal papers. Withdraw that insinuation, Gandon, or I will have the clerk record it as deliberate defamation.

The threat confirms the fear beneath his outrage. Vale shields the sealed complaint with one hand, while the Cornish Crowd murmurs at the sudden demand for a record and the clerk lifts his pen.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

My family has no connection to Josiah Vane or his criminal associates. Let the record show that clearly, and let this crowd judge whether a brash envoy's insinuations deserve belief.

The clerk records Vale's denial word for word. Arrus has forced the feared name into the official proceedings, and Vale's visible panic has made the crowd question why an innocent man guards the record so fiercely.

“Such ferocious defense, my lord! Me thinks he doth protest too much! I will say in a mocking tone to the crowd before snapping back at him with a whip of my head back to staring at him with eyes like daggers pointed at his throat. “Oh fear not, lord Vale, for I am our lord Viscount's sworn sword of Justice, and defender of Cornwall from the scourge of cowardly corruption! And I WILL bring every guilty man, be he lord or peasant, to the King's Justice that falls beneath my blade, but today is a matter of honor first! So today you will taste the shame of defeat by a better man, and tomorrow we will see how you fare against an agent of the law, instead of a noblewoman's chosen fiancee... Come now, Vale, and at least face your shame like a man, if not a noble man...” I will then draw my sword in one instant flash of skill meant to stun Vale as well as the crowd with the speed and precision of the blade suddenly appearing, pointed directly at Severin Vale.

SUCCESS (Legendary Fencing, rolled -3)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Such ferocious defense, my lord! Methinks he doth protest too much! Fear not, Lord Vale. I am the Viscount's sworn sword of Justice, defender of Cornwall from cowardly corruption. I shall bring every guilty man to the King's Justice, but today is honor first. You will taste defeat by a better man, then face an agent of the law instead of a noblewoman's chosen fiancé. Face your shame like a man, if not a nobleman.

Arrus whips his head back toward Vale, eyes narrowed like daggers at his throat. Silver Tongue makes the declaration glitter before the Cornish Crowd, while Code of Honor keeps the promised justice focused on guilty men, not wounded pride.

His Dueling sword flashes free in one Peerless Duelist motion, the narrow blade stopping precisely at Vale's chest. The sudden steel silences the square and leaves the nobleman staring down its unwavering point.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

You mistake spectacle for superiority, Gandon. Lower the blade, and let the appointed duel prove which of us deserves to stand before Cornwall.

The blade's sudden stop jars Arrus's wrist and opens a bright scrape across his palm, but he does not lower it. The cost is visible; so is the accomplishment, as Vale's bravado has become a measured retreat beneath the point.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

I will face you, envoy. But remember this moment when the crowd sees your flourish fail to win the contest.

The county clerk records Vale's answer, while the Cornish Crowd exhales in a wave of whispers. Arrus's sword remains perfectly aligned, and the appointed duel now carries the memory of this instant's undeniable intimidation.

I will show no sign of discomfort and simply lower the sword and casually step back a few paces to provide Vale room to draw his own sword. “Very well, my lord Vale... Draw your weapon...” I will speak louder for the crowd's attention as much as anyone's, “Show this gathering of the King's loyal subjects what the measure of an alleged nobleman is who cannot stand to be rejected by noble maidens and better men alike!... En guard!”

SUCCESS (Legendary Fencing, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Very well, my lord Vale. Draw your weapon. Show this gathering of the King's loyal subjects the measure of an alleged nobleman who cannot endure rejection by noble maidens and better men alike. En garde!

Arrus lowers the dueling sword without a flicker of discomfort and steps back several paces. The controlled retreat gives Vale clear room, while the blade’s balance and Arrus’s Peerless Duelist precision make the invitation unmistakable.

The Cornish Crowd surges into excited silence. Arrus’s Silver Tongue carries his challenge across the square, turning the duel into a public measure of honor rather than a private quarrel.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

You demand a spectacle, Gandon, and I shall give you one. Witnesses, remember that I draw in answer to a formal challenge, not from fear of your tongue.

Vale draws his sword at last. Arrus’s earlier pressure has forced the movement cleanly into the record, while Code of Honor checks the temptation to press him before he is ready.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

En garde, Master Gandon. Let Cornwall judge the difference between a practiced blade and a practiced mouth.

Vale settles into guard before the assembled witnesses, sword leveled and feet planted. Arrus’s path to the duel is complete, with the crowd attentive and both blades formally engaged.

I will taunt Vale further, “You are indeed wise to fear my words less than my sword, lord Vale, although I suspect it wil come as little comfort when both are done with you... Come for me then, man of honor!...” I will then stand my ground and begin to display my skill both to Vale and the crowd by deflecting his sword strikes without moving a single foot, insulting his sword skills by standing there, planted like a tree deflecting the wind, all while staring Severin Vale in the eyes between watching the movements of his sword with mastery of the movements.

SUCCESS (Legendary Fencing, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

You are wise to fear my words less than my sword, Lord Vale, though it will comfort you little when both are done with you. Come for me, man of honor!

Arrus plants his feet and waits. Silver Tongue sharpens the insult into a public challenge, while Peerless Duelist focus tracks Vale’s shoulders, wrist, and blade before the first cut arrives.

Vale lunges. Arrus’s dueling sword meets the thrust with a clean ringing deflection, turning it aside without shifting a foot. He stares into Vale’s eyes as though the attack were a courtesy.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

Stand still and sneer, then! I will cut that confidence from you.

A second slash, then a third, whip through the bright air. Arrus parries each with economical wristwork, rooted like a tree while the dueling sword redirects every stroke and leaves Vale striking wind.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Is this your measure of noble swordsmanship, Vale? I have not moved, and still your blade cannot find me.

The Cornish Crowd erupts as Vale’s attacks fail in succession. Code of Honor restrains Arrus from answering with a punishing thrust, but his mastery leaves the nobleman exposed, frustrated, and publicly outclassed.

As my dominance of the duel is made plain, I will slowly begin to walk calmly toward Vale with a deadly expression, “Sniveling slime like you dares to impugn my honor, and the honor of my chosen bride?!...” Slowly stalking Severin Vale in a wide circle, driving him like defenseless sheep towards the highest place in the center of the town's square, closing ever tighter around him like a shark preparing to strike, as if all reason might abandon me in a fit of rage, adding to Vale's psychological pressure. “Who would believe the likes of you fought for honor, instead of your own pretentious pride?!” I will continue stalking him slowly, step by step, like a single man about to deliver an entire mob's notion of justice singlehandedly... “This is Cornwall's excuse for a nobleman?!!” I will corner him against some standing central obstacle, with vengeful eyes full of questionable sanity...

SUCCESS (Legendary Fencing, rolled +2)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale

Arrus advances in a slow, widening circle, his dueling sword steady as he drives Lord Severin Vale backward. His wounded palm tightens around the hilt, pain sharpening rather than breaking his control.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Sniveling slime like you dares to impugn my honor, and the honor of my chosen bride?! Who would believe the likes of you fought for honor, instead of your own pretentious pride?!

Peerless Duelist precision keeps the blade’s point unwavering while Battle-Tested Insight reads every retreat. Silver Tongue turns each accusation into a public verdict, and the Cornish Crowd’s murmurs swell behind Vale like an advancing tide.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

This is Cornwall's excuse for a nobleman? Face the judgment you invited, my lord!

Arrus stalks him toward the square’s raised stone fountain, closing the circle until Vale’s back meets its rim. Code of Honor restrains the killing thrust, but the Dueling sword leaves no doubt that surrender is his only safe escape.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

Enough! I yield the duel. I surrender before these witnesses, and I will retract my complaint as agreed.

The Cornish Crowd erupts as Vale lowers his sword. Arrus’s point remains poised until the surrender is recorded, then drops cleanly; his dominance is complete, his honor publicly defended, and Vale bound to the promised retraction.

I will not allow Vale's surrender to end the dominance so quickly... He will leave with his life, but not his pride. I will lower my sword's blade clear of Vale, but in two quick steps inside his guard, I will stop directly in front of him, just short of his face from mine, nearly nose-to-nose to a defeated aristocrat attempting to evade the consequence of his dangerously accusatory actions that had the power to ruin lives... I will stare into his disarmed eyes like a madman barely restrained by civility, who might do something rash and uncivilized at the next moment. I will stare into Vale's eyes like the devil who had come to collect his soul. “Kneel.” I will say to him, under the hearing of the crowd, as my clear and discreet price for his forgiveness and safety. My eyes will convey the unspecified threat awaiting his defiance of the single word of gravely serious command.

SUCCESS (Legendary Willpower, rolled +2)

The Black Pennant Reappears
John Carter
John Carter
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale

Arrus lowers his blade clear of Vale, then crosses the space in two swift steps. His wounded palm tightens painfully around the hilt, but Battle-Tested Insight keeps the movement measured, not wild.

He stops nearly nose-to-nose with the defeated aristocrat. Silver Tongue lends his silence the force of a sentence, while the Dueling sword hangs ready at his side and Code of Honor restrains the threat from becoming a strike.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Kneel.

Arrus stares into Vale’s disarmed eyes like a devil collecting an unpaid soul. Willpower makes the command absolute; Battle-Tested Insight leaves Vale no doubt what defiance would invite, though no specific violence is promised.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

You have made your point, Gandon. I will not purchase my safety with another insult.

Vale’s resistance collapses beneath the crowd’s watching silence. He lowers himself onto one knee before Arrus, head bowed, surrendering not his life but the pride he guarded more fiercely than his honor.

The Cornish Crowd erupts around them. Arrus keeps his sword lowered and his gaze fixed on Vale, allowing the kneeling nobleman’s public submission to stand as the clear price of forgiveness and safety.

I will look at the silver-handled cane sword he came to threaten me with so brazenly, “My lord, I believe it is the tradition of defeated noblemen to offer their sword as a sign of their surrender... In fact, being an undefeated duelist, I'm quite certain of it...” I will then stand over him with one outstretched hand and a stern look that clearly expects his surrendered weapon, as per noble traditions.

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
John Carter
John Carter
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

My lord, I believe it is the tradition of defeated noblemen to offer their sword as a sign of surrender. As an undefeated duelist, I am quite certain of it.

Arrus rises over Vale and extends one empty hand, stern and expectant. His Dueling sword remains lowered, making the demand formal rather than threatening, while Peerless Duelist certainty gives the tradition convincing weight.

Silver Tongue turns an invented certainty into impeccable noble etiquette. Code of Honor restrains Arrus from snatching the cane sword or humiliating Vale beyond the terms of surrender, leaving the defeated lord a dignified choice before the watching Cornish Crowd.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

You are insufferable, Gandon. Very well. Let the record show that I surrender my cane sword as the token of my defeat.

Vale unhooks the silver-handled cane from his belt and offers it hilt-first. Arrus accepts the concealed sword without wrenching or jostling the injured palm, his restraint preserving both the surrender and the public record.

The Cornish Crowd answers with astonished cheers as Arrus holds the cane sword aloft, then passes it to John Carter for safekeeping. Vale remains kneeling, disarmed in fact as well as honor, while the clerk records the surrender.

+ New Item Acquired

Cane sword

After sufficiently humiliating Vale, I will jump atop the fountain's edge like a stage and begin circling it to address the crowd, “For all yee gathered here, let it be known! You have witnessed a cowardly accusation recanted here, by a disgraced accuser, defeated by Master Arrus Gandon, envoy and sworn sword of lord Viscount Falmouth, Sheriff of Cornwall. And I will not tolerate the slander and false accusations against either my lord's good and righteous name, nor any insult to the honor of my intended bride, the Lady Elizabeth Billings!...” I will then pace the courtyard quietly for a moment, displaying ferocious intent to confront all challengers. I will point at the shining cane sword in John Carter's hand, “If any man here wishes to make additional accusations, I have just acquired an exquisite sword with which he may defend his honor with his own life, if he is fool enough to test my patience twice in one day! ....Anyone?!... Any man here have the courage to speak up?!...”

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +1)

Arrus springs onto the fountain’s edge and circles it like a player commanding a stage. His raised voice carries over the cheering Cornish Crowd, while John Carter holds the shining cane sword beneath him.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

For all ye gathered here, let it be known! You have witnessed a cowardly accusation recanted by a disgraced accuser, defeated by Master Arrus Gandon, envoy and sworn sword of the Viscount, Sheriff of Cornwall!

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I will not tolerate slander against my lord’s good and righteous name, nor any insult to the honor of my intended bride, Lady Elizabeth Billings!

He paces the fountain’s rim in deliberate silence, displaying ferocious intent without drawing another drop of blood. His Peerless Duelist poise makes the cane sword gleam like a verdict, while Silver Tongue turns triumph into command.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

If any man here wishes to make additional accusations, I have acquired an exquisite sword with which he may defend his honor with his own life, if he is fool enough to test my patience twice in one day! Anyone? Any man here have the courage to speak up?

No challenger answers. The Cornish Crowd falls into a charged hush, then breaks into cheers as the county clerk records Arrus’s declaration and John Carter keeps the surrendered cane sword safely in hand.

“With our goals for the day completed, I will hop down next to John Carter and look to see if Severin Vale has already snuck away completely in shame or if I can still see him?”

NO (Likely, rolled 83)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Courtier 1
Courtier 1
John Carter
John Carter
Lord Severin Vale
Lord Severin Vale

Arrus hops down beside John Carter at the fountain. Through the thinning Cornish Crowd, Lord Severin Vale remains plainly visible near the clerk, still kneeling with his head bowed and his pride exposed.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

He has not slipped away.

John Carter

John Carter

There he remains, Arrus. A man may endure defeat more easily than the walk away from it.

Vale has surrendered the cane sword and remains under the county clerk’s eye, his shoulders rigid beneath the attention of thirty witnesses. He has made no move toward escape.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

I have not fled, Gandon. The retraction will be made as agreed, before these witnesses.

John Carter keeps the surrendered sword lowered at his side. The Cornish Crowd watches Vale in expectant silence, while the clerk prepares to preserve the nobleman’s promised words.

“As a false accusation, it never should have been required in the first place, my lord Vale... You do no one a charity by accepting your deserved fate! Stand there and wear your crown of shame and retract the words that ought never have been dared spoken, and do not look or speak to me for sympathy where you will find none!...” I will gently take the cane sword from John Carter and slowly approach Vale with it's sheathed blade firmly held in my grip as I admonish Vale mercilessly. “This is no doubt another pompous Vale family trinket, fit for those who only pretend to be men of action... Tell your father that we are not thieves in Pendennis Castle, and if he appears there to renounce his charges against my lord, we will return him your little scepter of unwarranted pride, along with the dignity of the name of Vale to it's pitiful owners....” I will then nod in conclusion to the clerk and offer to buy John Carter drinks to celebrate the remains of the day in victorious comfort.

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Bessy
Bessy
John Carter
John Carter
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

As a false accusation, it never should have been required, my lord Vale. Wear your crown of shame and retract words that should never have been dared spoken. Seek no sympathy from me.

Arrus gently takes the cane sword from John Carter and approaches with its sheathed blade held firmly in his injured palm. Peerless Duelist poise makes the trinket seem like a captured standard, while Silver Tongue gives each rebuke polished force.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

This is another pompous Vale family trinket, fit for men who only pretend to be men of action. Tell your father we are not thieves in Pendennis Castle. If he comes to renounce his charges, we will return this scepter and the dignity of Vale with it.

The cane sword’s weight aggravates the scrape across Arrus’s palm, but Code of Honor keeps his threat confined to lawful retraction and returned property, not blood. The Cornish Crowd hears every word, and Vale’s humiliation becomes public record.

Lord Severin Vale

Lord Severin Vale

I retract my accusation against the Viscount’s household and withdraw my father’s demand against it. Let the clerk record that I spoke falsely, and that my complaint has no standing.

The clerk writes the retraction before the assembled witnesses. Arrus nods toward him, then offers to buy John Carter drinks, leaving Vale kneeling beneath the weight of his own formal admission.

John Carter

John Carter

Gladly, Arrus. A victory witnessed, recorded, and properly celebrated deserves better than dry throats. I will see the first round poured before the crowd forgets whose words prevailed.

+ New Item Acquired

Cane sword

“I will laugh and slap John Carter on the shoulder and implore him to lead the way to Bessy and to better places to discuss future fortunes. I will leave the duel area with satisfactory content at a question of Honor answered definitively. When back in private company, I will discuss the latest events at Pendennis Castle, including the arrival of the Wren, and describe my plans to upgrade and refit her as a local trading vessel, to covertly investigate true enemies of the people of Cornwall, not simple free traders struggling to carve out a survival in hard times... I will ask him if prosperity and the common man's conditions have improved around Cornwall in recent days, and swap gossip while genuinely talking casually about life over drinks with Bessy.”

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled +1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Bessy
Bessy
John Carter
John Carter
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

John, lead on to Bessy and better places to discuss future fortunes. I have had quite enough of honor in the open air for one day.

Arrus laughs, slaps John Carter’s shoulder, and leaves the duel ground with satisfactory contentment. The cane sword passes into Carter’s keeping, while the crowd’s excitement dwindles behind them.

John Carter

John Carter

Gladly. Bessy will have a table, a bottle, and opinions about every fortune worth making along the coast.

At Bessy’s tavern, warmth, timber, and familiar drink replace the square’s scrutiny. Carter settles opposite Arrus, and Bessy brings spirits while listening for the shape of this new venture.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

The Wren has arrived under the Viscount’s protection. I mean to refit her as a local trading vessel, fit to investigate true enemies of Cornwall, not free traders struggling to survive. Have prosperity and ordinary conditions improved here lately?

John Carter

John Carter

A little prosperity has reached the merchants, but little has reached the common man. Taxes rise, honest cargo shrinks, and free traders keep villages alive when official ledgers do not.

Bessy

Bessy

Then drink to the Wren, Arrus. If she carries fair goods openly and watches the wolves quietly, she may serve both the people and the men who pretend to govern them.

“I'll wager she could achieve even more that that, Bessy my buxom darling!” as I pinch her playfully below her waist... After catching her predictable reflexive punishing strike, I will attempt to playfully pull Bessy onto my lap to drink with us, before distracting her retaliation with a profound question, “Can you imagine it Bessy? A small fleet of discreet trading vessels sailing Cornwall's coasts, identifying the true villains whose manipulation of trade and the ire of the King's tax collectors only serves to make life difficult for honest free traders... Can you imagine it, beautiful Bessy?” I ask while cradling her curvacious figure in mischievous hands.

YES, BUT (Likely, rolled 54)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

I’ll wager she could achieve even more than that, Bessy, my buxom darling!

Arrus pinches Bessy playfully below the waist. Her predictable strike snaps toward him, but he catches the blow neatly and draws her onto his lap before she can rise.

Bessy

Bessy

You slippery rogue. Put me down before I improve your manners in front of John Carter.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Can you imagine it, beautiful Bessy? A small fleet of discreet trading vessels sailing Cornwall’s coasts, finding the true villains whose schemes make life difficult for honest free traders?

Bessy’s retaliation falters beneath the question. She remains perched across his lap, one hand braced against his shoulder, while John Carter watches over the rim of his cup.

Bessy

Bessy

Yes, I can imagine it. But every vessel needs honest cargo, reliable crews, and a share that reaches the villages. If your fleet only watches wolves, the people will still go hungry.

John Carter

John Carter

That is the cost of your grand vision, Arrus. Bessy will lend you her imagination only if you give it bread, not merely sails and secrets.

I will slam the table in boisterous agreement. “A fine point, dear Bessy! You are only too right, as usual... We should arrange the proper free trading for the Wren to participate in while hand-selecting the crew carefully ourselves... The goods must be real, the profits must be real, and only those sailors allowed aboard for a day's work or two need know any of it more than well enough to affirm the local reputation that the Wren operates under unknown owners who prefer to keep it that way. We hire only trustworthy men we know. John, you should captain her activities secretly on behalf of the Quietus Exchange's accounts, taking your own margin as usual, but the “operating losses” of a ship that needs to make no true profit can instead deliver food and needed supplies wherever the commonfolk need it most around Cornwall. My partner in business, Mara Trevithick, can arrange the deliveries, the Exchange will provide the funding and cargo, I will provide the vessel, you sail her.”

SUCCESS (Fair Oratory, rolled -1)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

A fine point, dear Bessy! You are only too right. The Wren will trade real goods for real profits, then carry food and supplies wherever Cornwall needs them. John, sail her secretly for the Quietus Exchange, take your margin, and let the operating losses serve the villages. Mara will arrange the deliveries, the Exchange will fund cargo, and I will provide the vessel. We hire only trustworthy men, each knowing no more than the Wren’s harmless reputation requires.

Arrus slams the table, making the bottles jump. Silver Tongue gives the scheme a generous shine, while Account Keeper balances cargo, margins, and deliberate losses into a credible ledger.

John Carter

John Carter

You have made charity look like commerce and secrecy look like sound accounting. I accept the helm, provided the Exchange records every loss honestly and my margin remains clean.

Grandmaster of Secrets divides the plan into compartments: honest cargo, selected crews, concealed ownership, and deliveries known only to Mara and the Exchange. Arrus’s Code of Honor keeps aid from becoming a false entry.

Bessy

Bessy

Then I will find the villages that need help first, and I will tell free traders the Wren is nobody’s prize and everybody’s opportunity. But her crews must know the work is respectable enough to defend.

John Carter

John Carter

Done. The Wren sails under unknown ownership, trades fairly, and loses money where Cornwall is hungry. Bessy, mark the first ports. Mara can set the delivery books, and I will choose every hand aboard.

I will squeeze Bessy's waist in raucous approval! “Well done, Bessy! You've saved Cornwall again! Would you have a few more drinks with us? As you may have heard, I have recently become an engaged man... Surely such a champion of the people as yourself could take pity on me and take me for one last roll of drunken lust in a backroom pile of linens for your own pleasure beyond measure! Would you not agree?” I will then smile at her with reckless joy and pinch her intimately as a playful old acquaintance for flirtatious amusement.

YES (Likely, rolled 34)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Bessy
Bessy
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Well done, Bessy! You have saved Cornwall again. Would you have a few more drinks with us? I am recently engaged, but surely a champion of the people could pity me with one last roll in a backroom pile of linens, for your pleasure beyond measure?

Arrus squeezes Bessy’s waist and pinches her intimately with reckless, familiar playfulness. His wounded palm does not trouble him; the touch draws her startled glare, then a broad, wicked smile.

Bessy

Bessy

You randy, engaged rogue. I pity no man, least of all one who has just announced another woman’s claim in my drinking hall.

John Carter

John Carter

Bessy, remember your Methodist principles. Arrus, remember that a gentleman may request privacy without turning the request into a public sermon.

Bessy

Bessy

One last drink, certainly. As for the linens, perhaps I shall take pity on you after all, provided you can keep your boasts quieter than your hands and leave my guests something worth gossiping about.

Bessy hooks a finger toward the curtained passage beside the cask room, her amusement plain and her consent equally clear. John Carter lifts his cup with punctilious disapproval, while the tavern’s warmth gathers around the scandalous invitation.

I will finish my drink and set it down with a playfully serious look at John Carter, “Rest assured, John, I prefer your company nearly all the time. Nearly all, anyway...” I will then smile and rise to follow Bessy wherever her smile leads down backroom passages and hopefully a well-cushioned bed somewhere with absolute privacy.

SUCCESS (Legendary Deception, rolled +0)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Bessy
Bessy
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Rest assured, John, I prefer your company nearly all the time. Nearly all, anyway...

Arrus finishes his drink and sets the cup down with a playfully solemn look. His Silver Tongue makes the tease sound affectionate rather than dismissive, and the successful deception leaves John Carter amused instead of offended.

John Carter

John Carter

A narrow preference, Arrus, but I shall accept it as a gentleman accepts any compliment that survives honest qualification.

Bessy hooks two fingers toward the curtained passage, her wicked smile promising exactly the privacy she offered. Arrus rises and follows her through the warm backroom corridors, leaving the drinking hall’s laughter behind.

Bessy

Bessy

Come along, champion of the people. I know a room above the cask passage where even John’s principles cannot overhear us.

Bessy opens a stout oak door and ushers Arrus into a small, well-cushioned chamber lit by one shaded lamp. She closes it firmly behind them, securing the promised absolute privacy.

I will hold Bessy close enough to feel the excitement growing within me... “Bessy, dear love, I must confess, I was always prone to follow you anywhere your insistent beckon does call me, but I have always wondered if it might ever call me into such a hidden place as my dreams of you have often imagined... Tell me, are my fantasies as correct as the marvelous truth of you? Would you prefer me to ravish you in haste and return you to your ale hall, or will you permit me to undress you slowly, and savory this long-awaited chance to properly greet these ample charms besides this timeless face of yours that you have concealed from me for oh so long?...” I will smile and begin tracing her lips with mine as the wetness of their first touch invites more kisses than words. Hands will express tenderness and warmth may fill the bed with bare skin and carnal energy.

SUCCESS (Legendary Deception, rolled +0)

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Bessy, dear love, I have always followed your insistent beckoning. Tell me, are my fantasies equal to the marvelous truth of you? Would you have haste, or let me savor this long-awaited welcome?

Bessy’s wicked smile softens as Arrus holds her close. His Silver Tongue turns desire into a playful compliment, while Legendary Deception makes every extravagant word feel like an intimate truth.

Bessy

Bessy

You have a talent for making a woman feel both treasured and thoroughly blamed for your lack of patience. Come here, then, and let me judge those fantasies properly.

Her lips meet his, first teasingly, then with growing warmth. Bessy’s hands settle against his shoulders as she draws him toward the cushioned bed, the tavern’s distant sounds fading behind the stout door.

Bessy

Bessy

Slowly, my charming rogue. I have waited long enough to enjoy seeing whether your famous confidence survives tenderness.

Arrus answers with patient kisses and gentle hands, letting the promised slowness become its own seduction. Bessy’s laughter melts into quiet approval as clothing loosens and lamplight warms their bare shoulders.

The chamber fills with murmured affection, close embraces, and the soft disorder of two longtime conspirators finally claiming privacy. Bessy welcomes him fully, and the night becomes theirs without haste or audience.

I will cling to Bessy all night in celebratory passion, striving to give her voice excuse after excuse to escape her every last inhibition until we are exhausted by the effort of relentless indulgence. When she finally stirs in the dark of what must be the morning, I will playfully murmur that half-asleep sounding joke, “But wait, don't go, we've only just started...” in an effort to amuse her, while grasping her hips and pretending to try to retrieve her back into the warm bed covers.

SUCCESS (Legendary Deception, rolled -1)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Bessy
Bessy

The night passes in warm embraces, playful whispers, and repeated laughter behind the stout oak door. Bessy’s every supposed excuse dissolves into another invitation, until candlelight fades and both conspirators lie exhausted beneath tangled covers.

By the gray edge of morning, the tavern below has quieted completely. Bessy stirs against Arrus, hair loosened and shoulders warm from the long night, then reaches sleepily toward her discarded clothes.

Bessy

Bessy

God’s mercy, you charming menace. If I do not rise now, the whole tavern will know precisely why its mistress missed breakfast.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

But wait, don't go, we've only just started...

Arrus catches Bessy by the hips and playfully draws her backward toward the warm bedclothes, pretending earnest determination to reclaim her. Silver Tongue makes the absurd plea sound almost persuasive.

Bessy

Bessy

Almost persuasive, rogue. Come on, then, one more kiss before I face my customers and pretend I spent the night sleeping like a respectable woman.

Bessy bends to kiss him, laughing as she escapes his theatrical grasp. She leaves the bed smiling and unashamed, while the room retains the warmth and disorder of their successful indulgence.

+ New Item Acquired

Silver cane sword

I will dress and make sure to collect Severin Vale's silver cane sword on my way out of the Alehouse, and ask Bessy on my way to hug and kiss her farewell, “Bessy, darling, have you heard any chatter from Cornwall's sailors and fishermen over their drinks about a phantom ship or a signs of one, in particular a black pennant left behind anywhere to find?”

YES (Likely, rolled 46)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Bessy
Bessy

Arrus dresses, checks the wounded palm only as the fastening strains it, and collects Lord Severin Vale’s silver cane sword from John Carter’s safekeeping before leaving the alehouse.

At the passage, Bessy waits with morning composure and a wicked smile. Arrus draws her close, hugs her, and kisses her farewell before turning toward the door.

Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

Bessy, darling, have you heard any chatter from Cornwall’s sailors and fishermen over their drinks about a phantom ship, or signs of one, in particular a black pennant left behind anywhere to find?

Bessy

Bessy

Yes, darling. Three sailors mentioned a black pennant seen after midnight near the old lime kilns beyond Flushing, where no honest vessel could have anchored.

Bessy catches his sleeve before he can go and lowers her voice. The sailors agreed on one detail: the phantom ship showed no lanterns, yet its wake shone pale beneath the moon.

Bessy

Bessy

A fisherman found a strip of black pennant cloth snagged on the lime-kiln rocks at dawn. He left it there, but someone came back for it before breakfast.

Her report gives the rumor a place, a time, and a vanished scrap of evidence. Outside, the coast road waits toward Flushing, while Bessy’s hand remains briefly against his sleeve.

I will stare into Bessy's eyes with sincere gratitude and thank her for that information, and cleverly pull her close and sneak a hand up her skirt to touch her most intimately with gentle gratitude while deepening the kiss for a moment. “We must confer to share news more often, my dear Bessy, so that I can show you how much appreciation I wish to express, for as long as I can, if you wish it?...”

NO, BUT (Likely, rolled 66)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Bessy
Bessy
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

We must confer to share news more often, my dear Bessy, so I may show you how much appreciation I wish to express, for as long as you wish it.

Bessy catches his wandering hand before it reaches farther, laughing softly as she turns the attempted intimacy into a firm, playful stop. She accepts the deepened kiss, but breaks it before his gratitude becomes an assumption.

Bessy

Bessy

I wish it, rogue, but not as payment for every rumor I bring you. Keep your gratitude gentle, and I may give you plenty of opportunities to express it.

Her smile keeps the rebuke warm rather than hostile. Then she taps the road map beside the passage and lowers her voice, turning the failed caress into a sharper advantage.

Bessy

Bessy

The old lime kilns connect to a smugglers’ footpath running behind the abandoned weigh-house. Take that track from the inland side, and anyone watching the coast will miss your approach.

The route offers cover, a concealed approach, and a place to observe the phantom ship’s trail without announcing the Wren or the Viscount’s interest. Bessy releases his sleeve and leaves the choice in his hands.

I will straighten tall and look at her with mild surprise on my face, “My dear Bessy, you once again increase the chances of me gaining the surprise advantage upon my dangers, however do you expect me to not return and make love to you for a night and a day until neither of us can walk, out of pure gratitude for my preserved physical health?!” I will then bow and kiss her hand tenderly, and smile at her with genuine affection as much as the humor, both intended to make her smile for different reasons. Then, while still barely capable of making a dignified attempt to depart while leaving Bessy with a tenderly sincere gesture of appreciation as I turn with a wink and a promise to return for several of those chances soon... I will then hasten to Pendennis and leave word via the house staff to the Viscount, as well as Elizabeth that I have returned safely, unharmed from a very public, very effective defeat of the Vale House's effort to discredit his lordship Falmouth, and a hot bath.”

NO, BUT (VeryLikely, rolled 86)

The Black Pennant Reappears
Maid
Maid
Arrus Gandon

Arrus Gandon

My dear Bessy, you increase my chances of surprising danger. How could I not return and make love to you for a night and a day, from pure gratitude for my health?

Arrus straightens with mild surprise, bows over Bessy’s hand, and kisses it tenderly. His wink and genuine smile promise a return, though his dignity barely survives the departure.

Bessy

Bessy

No night and day, rogue. The coast will not wait that long. But return after the lime-kiln business, and I will reserve the room, the linens, and every opportunity you have earned.

Bessy’s refusal is softened by a concrete promise: the private room remains available, and the phantom ship’s trail gives Arrus a usable lead rather than a dead end. He hurries inland toward Pendennis.

At the castle, a young maid in a gray wool dress receives him at the postern. Arrus entrusts her with word that he returned safely, unharmed after Vale’s public defeat, and requests a hot bath.

Maid

Maid

I will tell the Viscount and Elizabeth at once. They are together in the library, and both will be relieved to hear you are safe. The bath will be prepared before you finish reporting.

Contact Us

Did you have a bad experience? Think we can do better? Tell us!

Want to delete your account? Account Deletion