
Captain Redmane stands on the quarterdeck with the command ledger, signal book, and master’s keys in hand. The privateer spreads the signal book beside the captured Spanish colors as twelve newly sworn crewmen secure the guns and wheel.
Beyond the flagship’s guns, three distant sails gather against the bright horizon. Mateo Vargas watches them from the rail, his expression tightening as Spanish colors flicker in the wind.

The Privateer
Those sails are the squadron’s outer watch. One signal may call them close, send them hunting elsewhere, or convince them this flagship still commands the anchorage.

Mateo Vargas
Choose carefully, Captain Ballantyne. If they recognize the capture, every gun beyond the reef may turn against us.
Vargas remains beside the quarterdeck rail, separated from his disarmed officers but still wearing his sword. The privateer waits over the open book, one finger marking the fleet’s challenge code.

The Privateer
The red pennant orders an approach. The white lantern sends them toward the eastern shoals. The Spanish night code could make them obey before suspicion catches up.
Wind snaps the captured colors above them. The gathered sails alter course by degrees, waiting for the flagship’s answer while the command ledger lies open to its sealed fleet orders.
“I send the white signal toward the eastern shoals”
SUCCESS (Legendary Intrigue, rolled -1)

Captain Redmane opens the signal book to the white lantern entry and studies the fleet orders beside it. Reads Naval Tactics reveals the eastern shoals as a convincing refuge, not merely a diversion.
The wanted poster tucked beneath the ledger catches at the edge of her sleeve, threatening to expose her likeness. She turns the obstruction into a shield, keeping her face away from the rail while her hand lifts the white lantern.
Her Silver Tongue supplies the clipped Spanish cadence of an urgent navigational order. The signal book gives each shutter beat its precise meaning, and the white pattern flashes across the bright water.

The Privateer
White to the eastern shoals. They will read it as a command to pursue a fleeing vessel through the shallows.
The distant Spanish squadron answers. Its three sails bear away toward the eastern shoals, leaving the captured flagship’s anchorage clear and obeying the false order without firing a gun.

Mateo Vargas
They have taken the bait. The squadron will search the shoals while your prize remains unchallenged.
The privateer lowers the lantern, and the crew breaks into swift, disciplined motion around the guns and wheel. Vargas watches his squadron vanish eastward, confronted at last with a capture his own signal helped secure.
✓ Quest Accepted
Win Vargas’s cooperation
“Can you persuade your officers to serve under my command?”
YES, AND MORE (Likely, rolled 4)

Captain Redmane addresses the disarmed Spanish officers with the captured ledger open before her. Her command is decisive, her prize secured, and the uncertain men find no advantage in resisting.

The Privateer
They will serve you, captain. Not merely until the next tide, but for the voyage, if you grant them shares and protection under your colors.
The officers lower their eyes, then one by one surrender their swords. Their senior boatswain steps forward first, followed by the others, and their obedience becomes an oath rather than a surrender.

Spanish officers
We will serve Captain Ballantyne and keep this flagship under her command. Give us terms, and we will uphold them before the fleet.

Mateo Vargas
Then hear their value, Captain Ballantyne. These officers know every hidden anchorage between here and Havana, and they will not betray you lightly.
The privateer gathers the surrendered swords while Redmane’s crew secures the quarterdeck. With trained Spanish officers added to her force, the captured flagship can now sail as both prize and convincing command vessel.
“I offer Vargas shares and protection under my colors”
SUCCESS (Good Diplomacy, rolled +1)


Captain Redmane
Lieutenant Vargas, accept shares in this prize and protection under my colors. Serve with me, and your knowledge will profit rather than perish.
Captain Redmane sets the command ledger before Vargas, its fleet orders and columns of shares making the offer concrete. Her Silver Tongue gives the terms the polished certainty of a royal contract.
The wanted poster shifts beneath the ledger’s edge, briefly exposing the likeness that could turn mercy into evidence. Redmane angles the page over it, hiding the danger while keeping Vargas’s attention on the figures.
Her Inspiring Presence steadies the quarterdeck: the surrendered officers watch her as a commander already distributing a future, while the crew stands ready behind the guns and wheel.

Mateo Vargas
You offer protection beneath colors that have already taken a flagship. I accept the shares, Captain Ballantyne, and I will serve your command.
Vargas removes his sword belt and lays it beside the ledger, making his acceptance visible. The Spanish officers follow, and the crew answers with a sharp approving cheer.

Mateo Vargas
My officers will hear these terms from me. This flagship, its anchorages, and its knowledge are yours to command.
The command ledger records the new shares under Redmane’s colors. Vargas now stands persuaded and protected, while the captured flagship gains officers bound by profit, reputation, and oath.
Quest Complete
Win Vargas’s cooperation